The Daily Tribune: Most Undervalued Posts of Nov 15 - Part I

in curation •  3 years ago 

What if every voter had an equal say no matter their Steem Power? The Daily Tribune finds out and highlights those posts that would have been rewarded most but weren't. In ancient Rome, the Tribune of the Plebs was the voice of the people, serving as an important balance to the power of the ruling class. With your help, we hope the Daily Tribune will serve a similar purpose for the Steemit community.

In order to allow highlighted posts to benefit from greater visibility before the first payout, we plan to post twice a day, each covering the prior 12 hours of posts that have had at least 3 hours for votes to come in. Each post will rank the top 80 most undervalued posts for that period.

Please note that this isn't necessarily a direct criticism of Steemit's reward algorithms. An automatic reward system needs to be resilient against more potential abuses than a community driven effort such as this one, in which humans remain in the loop to reward deserving posts with more votes or flag undeserving ones.


Rankings

Nov 15 - Part I (View Yesterday's )

Below each post title, we list some important stats, which take the following form:

# Votes | Equal Voter Payout - Actual Pending Payout = Difference in Value + Time Bonus (# Hours Old) = Projected Difference in Value
If you want to see more about how we rank posts, you can read about some of our methodology, data analysis and technical details in our initial post.

If you'd like to see Steemit's rewards be more democratic, please consider following us as well as browsing the rankings and upvoting posts you agree are undervalued. Also, we are very grateful to @jlufer, @thecryptofiend, @matrixdweller, @barrydutton and any others we missed for the recent resteems.

RankAuthorPost Title and Stats

1

@future24 The second try to get back to Berlin from Amsterdam... 😅✈
271 | $23.69 - $2.29 = $21.40 + 4.9% (5.3) = $22.45

2

@victoriart Cherry & Chocholate Muffins - Super Recipe
200 | $21.19 - $0.17 = $21.02 + 1.5% (8.9) = $21.33

3

@timcliff I am a huge Obama supporter. I voted for Hillary. Now I support Trump.
208 | $19.37 - $0.73 = $18.64 + 1.0% (10.0) = $18.83

4

@electrowarrior Donald Trump's first 100 days in office
163 | $18.46 - $0.27 = $18.19 + 0.9% (10.5) = $18.35

5

@papa-pepper AND THE WINNER IS.... THE SUPER-HOT PEPPER CHALLENGE FROM @papa-pepper
250 | $19.10 - $4.23 = $14.87 + 2.4% (7.3) = $15.23

6

@tommycordero Our first week in Santo Domingo turned NSFW
298 | $22.88 - $8.04 = $14.84 + 0.4% (13.0) = $14.90

7

@lukestokes Exchange Transfer Report: 11/06/2016 to 11/12/2016
189 | $19.76 - $6.84 = $12.92 + 1.9% (8.1) = $13.16

8

@haphazard-hstead SteemitPhotoChallenge 17 Entry 3 – Oak Savannah Countryside, Douglas County, Oregon
156 | $12.41 - $0.30 = $12.11 + 0.8% (11.0) = $12.21

9

@surfermarly Mi noveno steemit poema: 'LA LUNA' [modern Spanish poetry]. Celebrando la superluna - un fenómeno astronómico histórico que tiene lugar esta noche!
118 | $11.85 - $0.26 = $11.60 + 0.2% (14.0) = $11.62

10

@streetstyle Students Protest TRUMP in Downtown Los Angeles, Today 11/14/2016
205 | $16.55 - $5.88 = $10.67 + 0.5% (12.4) = $10.72

11

@crypto.owl Russian blockchain meet up in Moscow
91 | $9.39 - $0.09 = $9.30 + 7.7% (4.2) = $10.02

12

@opheliafu SteemFest Sunday sketching
277 | $24.54 - $16.75 = $7.79 + 0.3% (13.6) = $7.82

13

@edgarsart A Poet! Commissioned Portrait Drawing By EdgarsArt
81 | $6.81 - $0.19 = $6.62 + 5.1% (5.2) = $6.96

14

@royalmacro Diwali - Festival of Lights & Kali Puja - Worship of Power against evils [Series Photography] #06
86 | $6.74 - $0.29 = $6.45 + 3.1% (6.5) = $6.65

15

@bullionstackers Baby Sucking Up - In Night Photography series #11
124 | $6.94 - $0.44 = $6.50 + 1.8% (8.2) = $6.61

16

@contentjunkie [STEEMIT SURVEY] Coca Cola vs Pepsi Cola - Which Tastes Better?
200 | $7.01 - $0.43 = $6.58 + 0.2% (13.8) = $6.60

17

@bola Guess How Many? #57
130 | $6.53 - $0.08 = $6.45 + 0.2% (14.0) = $6.46

18

@jlufer The photo of the day Exotic butterflies and hummingbirds.
69 | $6.32 - $0.30 = $6.02 + 0.9% (10.6) = $6.07

19

@halo STEEMIT GIRL HALO ♡ THE BLACK #56
149 | $9.27 - $3.30 = $5.97 + 0.4% (12.9) = $5.99

20

@asdes Valencia, Spain - night city
81 | $5.77 - $0.04 = $5.73 + 4.4% (5.6) = $5.98

21

@sulev Editing a photo
146 | $8.38 - $3.13 = $5.24 + 10.0% (3.5) = $5.77

22

@jlufer Mystic tree of my payments the last guayacán
103 | $6.95 - $1.49 = $5.46 + 0.1% (14.6) = $5.46

23

@exploretraveler Photo of the day ~ Chocolate of Belgium
227 | $18.41 - $13.02 = $5.39 + 1.1% (9.6) = $5.45

24

@runridefly My 1971 Chevy C-10, I love my brother and out of contol mulberry trees. I need something to post. Thankful for all the followers and I'm addicted to steemit.
63 | $5.51 - $0.21 = $5.30 + 2.1% (7.6) = $5.41

25

@steemokto My photography: "night impressions from Hamburg" (original steemit content)
144 | $6.77 - $1.53 = $5.24 + 2.5% (7.2) = $5.37

26

@craig-grant Lifetime bitcoin daily payments from cryptocurrency mining contracts, have fun :)
136 | $8.78 - $3.49 = $5.28 + 0.3% (13.3) = $5.30

27

@sweetsssj Travel with me: My experience of the Sotheby Auction Company.
359 | $28.71 - $23.57 = $5.14 + 2.8% (6.9) = $5.28

28

@knozaki2015 I travel the world Part 132: Hummbar Amsterdam having a Lobster Roll
401 | $35.11 - $30.32 = $4.79 + 8.2% (4.0) = $5.18

29

@marius19 Enjoy your life as it is...+Decorative paper flowers
90 | $7.30 - $2.27 = $5.03 + 2.2% (7.5) = $5.14

30

@daveks Canmore Alberta p5
95 | $5.30 - $0.22 = $5.08 + 1.2% (9.5) = $5.14

31

@mokluc The scary “TRUTH” about social media FACE recognition software...
116 | $6.35 - $1.84 = $4.51 + 11.1% (3.3) = $5.02

32

@drac59 Cooking "Cake with liver and pumpkin" Готовим " Пирог с печени и с тыквой"
131 | $5.76 - $1.49 = $4.27 + 12.5% (3.1) = $4.80

33

@kszchopstix The Galloping Commuter - Original Photograph
112 | $5.29 - $0.65 = $4.63 + 0.7% (11.2) = $4.67

34

@steevc A sporting chance
141 | $6.10 - $1.71 = $4.39 + 5.9% (4.9) = $4.65

35

@mikkolyytinen Ice giant
85 | $6.47 - $1.87 = $4.60 + 0.0% (14.9) = $4.60

36

@blinova Countryside Selfie - SteemitPhotoChallenge #17
70 | $4.84 - $0.36 = $4.48 + 2.6% (7.0) = $4.59

37

@keuudeip Against the sea
143 | $6.83 - $2.48 = $4.35 + 4.4% (5.6) = $4.54

38

@lyubovbar Bulrush - in the Snow (Photos @lyubovbar)
144 | $5.38 - $1.29 = $4.09 + 10.7% (3.4) = $4.53

39

@contentjunkie FBI Says Alleged Hackers Used FIFA To Steal Millions From EA
191 | $5.66 - $1.26 = $4.40 + 0.1% (14.3) = $4.41

40

@doitvoluntarily Former Deputy PM Calls Cannabis Criminalization 'Absurd'
131 | $7.79 - $3.54 = $4.25 + 1.6% (8.6) = $4.32

41

@screenname The Daily Tribune: Most Undervalued Posts of Nov 14 - Part II
58 | $4.55 - $0.26 = $4.29 + 0.6% (12.0) = $4.31

42

@abdullar SteemitPhotoChallenge #17 - Countryside - Entry 2 - winter in korea
48 | $4.80 - $0.59 = $4.21 + 0.8% (10.9) = $4.25

43

@adelja The true needs of men and women.
136 | $5.61 - $1.65 = $3.97 + 6.6% (4.6) = $4.23

44

@daveks the Daily Pic #51
84 | $4.33 - $0.23 = $4.10 + 1.8% (8.1) = $4.17

45

@norbu Upgraded Google Play Music Has A Robot DJ Now to Choose Tracks According to your Moods!
147 | $5.27 - $1.26 = $4.00 + 1.8% (8.2) = $4.08

46

@profitgenerator Bitcoin Security Overview & Quantum Computers
85 | $4.44 - $0.71 = $3.73 + 8.2% (4.0) = $4.03

47

@bacchist Trump in the White House: An Interview With Noam Chomsky
85 | $4.49 - $0.65 = $3.84 + 4.6% (5.5) = $4.01

48

@ace108 @stellabelle, bot on me - an orginal poem (by @ace108)
128 | $6.21 - $2.28 = $3.93 + 0.6% (12.1) = $3.95

49

@mindhunter How To Do A 'Blind Reading' Exercise That Will Increase Your Intuition.
60 | $3.72 - $0.18 = $3.53 + 9.6% (3.6) = $3.87

50

@verbal-d Poetry Dice Challenge # 3: Labyrinth Of Souls (Original Poem)
195 | $12.98 - $9.13 = $3.85 + 0.4% (12.8) = $3.86

51

@bola Sentence Unscrambler #64
46 | $3.84 - $0.01 = $3.83 + 0.7% (11.5) = $3.85

52

@majes Dr Ron Paul discusses Donald Trumps win (video)
114 | $4.00 - $0.20 = $3.80 + 0.5% (12.2) = $3.82

53

@mweich Little Monsters - Part 26: Ammophila, Alien is real.
95 | $5.25 - $1.57 = $3.68 + 3.2% (6.4) = $3.79

54

@dmilash The Animals - are not clowns
117 | $7.25 - $3.74 = $3.51 + 5.0% (5.3) = $3.68

55

@reneenouveau NaNoWriMo: Halfway there! Anyone else ready to give up?!
63 | $3.98 - $0.32 = $3.66 + 0.3% (13.4) = $3.67

56

@maarnio Crypto Contest November 15: I/O Digital Currency
147 | $7.37 - $4.07 = $3.30 + 11.3% (3.3) = $3.67

57

@mrosenquist Where Hackers Take their Money – Casinos, Cryptocurrency, and Virtual Worlds
37 | $3.79 - $0.16 = $3.64 + 0.5% (12.5) = $3.66

58

@jlufer Árbol místico de mis pagos el ultimo guayacán
142 | $7.89 - $4.25 = $3.64 + 0.2% (14.0) = $3.65

59

@steemcultures The Reality
131 | $6.52 - $3.01 = $3.52 + 3.5% (6.2) = $3.64

60

@pilgrimtraveler When the Lord knocks at the door of your Heart
47 | $3.40 - $0.02 = $3.38 + 1.3% (9.3) = $3.42

61

@skeptic Drunk
113 | $3.35 - $0.15 = $3.21 + 3.8% (6.0) = $3.33

62

@kyusho Vrikshásana
151 | $3.12 - $0.18 = $2.93 + 12.7% (3.1) = $3.31

63

@rileyechard My Story - Riley E.
49 | $4.60 - $1.34 = $3.25 + 0.5% (12.4) = $3.27

64

@bola Fill In The Blank #49 (Marijuana)
51 | $4.41 - $1.19 = $3.22 + 0.8% (10.9) = $3.24

65

@asdes Valencia, Spain - walk around the city
112 | $6.89 - $3.79 = $3.11 + 3.8% (6.0) = $3.22

66

@p0o Steemers Coding Class 02 - Learn Coding 10 Minutes a Day For Very Beginners
167 | $6.88 - $3.70 = $3.18 + 1.3% (9.4) = $3.22

67

@seisges DE SESMA A ALSASUA, Navarra.
134 | $5.15 - $2.01 = $3.14 + 0.3% (13.5) = $3.15

68

@ozzy-vega Argentina/ promoviendo Steem en mi vuelo a Argentina y mi meta de 5000 mil Steem para Fin de año.
125 | $4.36 - $1.39 = $2.97 + 3.6% (6.1) = $3.08

69

@dimplesdiary Pindaya's Treasure: Thousands of Statues in A Cave
129 | $4.00 - $0.98 = $3.02 + 1.7% (8.5) = $3.07

70

@everittdmickey TEOTWAWKI (An Original Novel - Episode 95)
135 | $4.66 - $1.65 = $3.01 + 1.4% (9.0) = $3.05

71

@shortcut Artwork of the Day #55 - My finding is to imagine
30 | $3.12 - $0.11 = $3.00 + 0.2% (14.0) = $3.01

72

@riosparada A MESSAGE FROM GRASSHOPPER!
131 | $4.44 - $1.50 = $2.94 + 2.0% (7.8) = $2.99

73

@imperfectu Imperfectu App: The Path To An Inclusive Tijuana (Mexico)
131 | $6.10 - $3.28 = $2.81 + 3.5% (6.2) = $2.91

74

@ash Exchange Spotlight: 1broker
38 | $2.84 - $0.30 = $2.54 + 11.5% (3.3) = $2.83

75

@mrwang Poppin' Champagne - Music Video - Lone Stars Entertainment
68 | $3.46 - $0.64 = $2.81 + 0.6% (12.1) = $2.83

76

@full-steem-ahead Turning Bitcoin into Steem – the Evolution of BitShares part 3
96 | $7.38 - $4.68 = $2.70 + 1.1% (9.8) = $2.73

77

@narrowminded 7 REASONS I NO LONGER BELIEVE IN A PRETRIBULATIONAL RAPTURE - Reason 5 - A Video Series
78 | $2.72 - $0.07 = $2.65 + 1.8% (8.3) = $2.70

78

@eric-boucher Steemit Photo Challenge #17 - Countryside - "Of Fields and Fences"
24 | $3.04 - $0.53 = $2.51 + 0.5% (12.6) = $2.52

79

@steemradio Thank you for missing us! @steemradio will come back bigger and stronger!
25 | $2.39 - $0.03 = $2.36 + 6.7% (4.5) = $2.51

80

@johnnyyash The great things in life DON'T come from government
153 | $6.36 - $3.88 = $2.47 + 1.4% (9.1) = $2.51
Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

I appreciate seeing these lists every day. I find some interesting posts that I wouldn't have seen otherwise. Eventually even the bots will develop higher Steem power and reputation, so their impact should help us all out - in the long run. Better to get upvotes now, with low payout, than no upvotes at all. And comments are always nice to see! Steem on - to everyone on this list!

  ·  3 years ago (edited)

Thanks for featuring me again. I think the voting rewards are made confusing by the high number of bots with little SP that vote on posts. Even a hundred of those may make you nothing, but a single whale vote can make you a lot. It's how the system has been designed. We don't want those bots to have undue influence.

but a single whale vote can make you a lot

And it sucks!

I don't complain when I get one. The fact that we can make anything here is a bonus. I make far more than any other site I've used

My argument was more focused on equality of votes. I too have no qualms about the payout and am happy with what I make. I also realize this is in beta and know things will change, but I constantly reiterate the point that equality is very important if the platform is to survive.

Thanks for a stimulating comment! :)

Thanks for being part of the discussion. I think Steemit can appear unfair to new users, but it's all documented. I wonder if they expected some users to get so influential this quickly.

I think we basically have no clue as to what is ahead, but we can debate, and that is a good thing facilitated by steemit. But for it to grow, it has to survive the barrage from every angle. And the best way to win in the long run, is to be fair. Just my opinion.

Why not equality of financial investment? Why can't it be "fair" for those who were willing purchase influence or take a risk early on mining a highly speculative cryptocurrency project?

"Fair" can be interpreted many ways. A single bot dishing out 100's of votes isn't "fair" from my perspective at all. Someone investing real money to power up that bot and dish out those same 100 votes... well, I'm more okay with that.

This is exactly why I proposes real discussion. We are in a new ship and staring at a frontier "where no man has ever gone before". I get you when you say that equality for the people who have made the investment should be respected, and I agree.

But on the voting side I feel we have to be "seemingly" fair, and as this tribune post shows, the differences are not much. According to @screenname 's calculations we see that the monetary difference is small and I feel it can be accommodated, or a way found to balance the payouts!

Well i see my post...thanks

Many thanks to you @ screenname and all your team for the support to the community, excellent election the selected, congratulations to all the nominees,
I appreciate the trust and support of my work thank you very much.
Reestemit, the post

Thanks for having and supporting me! I think bots are part of the game as on any other platform nowadays.

This post has been ranked within the top 80 most undervalued posts in the second half of Nov 15. We estimate that this post is undervalued by $7.38 as compared to a scenario in which every voter had an equal say.

See the full rankings and details in The Daily Tribune: Nov 15 - Part II. You can also read about some of our methodology, data analysis and technical details in our initial post.

If you are the author and would prefer not to receive these comments, simply reply "Stop" to this comment.