Notes #32 - It's Show and Tell Time

in #writing7 years ago

Notes From an Amateur Writer - cover


Notes From an Amateur Writer #32
IT'S SHOW AND TELL TIME

This Blog series is an exercise in creative writing. Sometimes expressed in short story forms, sometimes as a journal, or just my thoughts written down. This is my attempt to help coalesce my writing ideas and knowledge into usable form. It is a nursery of sorts for the stories that are on their way, or yet to be written.


Let Me Tell You a Story

I sat at the table, staring across at the man facing me. He wore a dark suit, his tie slightly loosened. His hands were resting near the edge of the table, as if awaiting further orders. His eyes gave little away, gazing at me blankly, like two loose discs hovering in mid air. His body language however, it told me more than I think he intended. He felt panic. That much I could sense.

"So how much longer is it going to be?" he asked.

"It shouldn't be too much longer. But I'm not in control of these things."

"You told me it would be finished by now. I can't afford to have this take any longer. I think they are onto me. I feel like they're watching me. You need to hurry up." He looked at me angrily.


The Internal Director

Cut, cut, cut.

"Woah, who said that? Who just called cut on my writing session. I was just getting into that. First draft, a bit rough, but going somewhere."

I said that.

"And who are you?"

Your internal movie director. I was watching over the words you were writing, and they were going well. Well enough anyway. Until that last word.

"Angrily? What was wrong with that?"

Okay, this is going to hurt me more than it will hurt you. But it's for your own benefit.

He slapped me across the back of the head. "Jesus, man. What's wrong with you?" He slapped me again. The force of his hand made my head jerk forwards, crashing into the desk. I wanted to grab him by the scruff, and let him know just how pissed off I felt. Give him a taste of his own medicine. Except he wasn't real. He was just another imaginary critter floating through my internal writer's world. He had slapped me, and then retreated. I wanted to throttle him.

A deep belly laugh emerged from the shadows. I could see his eyes peering out at me. 'Seeing' your response to my aggression was so much more interesting than being 'told' you were angry. Wouldn't you agree?


It's Show and Tell Time

'Show, don't tell' is one of those pieces of writing advice that gets thrown out at writers a lot. Like all rules it has its uses. It exists for a reason. But like all rules, breakages are allowed. But how do you break a rule if you have yet to master the art of applying it correctly?

I have a tendency to drift into too much tell in my writing. I am aware of that. But knowing that, or being told that, is not the same as seeing it and completely understanding where I am telling too much, and how to fix it.

My Kindle recently made a book recommendation to me based on other books I have read. It was 'Understanding Show, Don't Tell (And Really Getting It)' by Janice Hardy. The recommendation arrived at a time when this particular issue has been at the forefront of my mind. So I made a purchase and proceeded to read through it. And I am glad that I did. The book 'shows' what this rule really means and the way in which to apply it for better writing. I love the irony in that. Imagine reading a book on 'Show, Don't Tell' that is all tell. I am sure those books exist. Fortunately this wasn't one of them. And it has made a difference, because I was able to 'see' what this rule actually means, how to apply it, and when to use it and when not to use it.

I will be doing a review post for this book so I don't want to go any further into the specifics of it here, but it has broadened my thinking in this area through it's properly structured and applied explanations of this rule.

I haven't done any formal writing courses or study. I finished High School twenty-seven years ago, so even though I was good at English classes, they were some time ago. And given that I went to an inner city Government school the curriculum wasn't of a very high standard. I got through all of my schooling without ever reading Shakespeare, with minimum lessons in grammar, and never learning what an adverb was. So being 'told' to not use adverbs was far more confusing than being 'shown' what they are and why – in most cases, but certainly not all – I shouldn't use them.

What this particular book taught me more than anything was why some writing is flat, leaving the reader feeling detached. I do that, and so do other writers, including published authors. Whereas before I had a gut feeling to go on about why a particular piece of writing wasn't working as well as it could, now the specifics have a kind of visual certainty to them.


The Sith Lord Returns

You've learned a powerful lesson there, Padawan.

"You condescending bastard." I slapped him with my open hand, throwing his head to the side. I gave him a subtle smirk. That felt good.

He looked at me angrily. I could see rage creeping into the corners of his eyes, his fingers beginning to twitch. There was menace in his glare, but it was hollow. What he wanted was to respond in kind, but would he? He faded back into the shadows.

One all. I heard his voice echoing out from the depths. I guess he'll be back. If he wants the final word. Well let him bring it then – I'll 'show' him.


All images used with permission, and sourced from Unsplash.com.

Thank you for taking the time to read this. If you liked it then please like, comment, and follow

@naquoya



Short Fiction:

Bang Bang You're Dead
I Have No Name and I Must Scream
The Last Book Store
The Judge
The Man In The Mirror
The End of the World [Part 1] [Part 2]
The Locked Room
The Gods of Love and War [Part 1] [Part 2] [Part 3]
Crossroads
Heart's a Mess
Blasphemous
Jonathan and the Dance of the Leaves

Sort:  

It's always a fun time whenever a conversation between the slick Scotty B. and Naquoya is involved! Show 'em, uh, hmm.. It's hard to tell which of you is which, so that's always good. I struggle with it a lot as well. Maybe it's hard to curb those tendencies. Sometimes I wish there an AI assistant who just nags at you whenever you use too much adverbs. I did create a script that points out how many adverbs I've written, just so I'm aware of what I've been doing. If I would continue writing more, that was on me. Great reflection here, brother!

I think a lot of writers struggle with this one. Perhaps that's only natural. And one thing I did get from that book was that when writing a first draft you shouldn't even worry about it. If as an author we tend to think or write initially in a particular manner than we should write like that, and then on review mark up areas that could do with a deeper narrative.

So rather than fight it, we should write, and then review. That advice helped. It allows for the natural flow of the words to just come out, adverbs and all. Stunted descriptions also. Looking at it from that perspective also shows the need to step up as a writer in terms of reviews and further drafts. I don't tend to do more than 2 drafts for what I publish here. But they are all shorts at the moment.

So yes, it had lots of good advice. Not stifling advice, but ways to improve as a writer and see the results immediately.

As for the conversations in my head, I had the thought to write a book about it - call it Conversation's With God. Unfortunately someone else stole that title.

I should really be reading stuff like that more. Sadly, and I don't know why, my non-fiction reading tends to stray elsewhere. That's why I find your Notes so helpful because it provides an entertaining cliffnotes of those things. I think I much rather read your writing than those people anyway.

Ha! Well I guess that just gives you the challenge of thinking of a better title. Damn that Neale Donald Walsh! But, in a way, thanks as well.

There are a lot of books on the topic and not all of them are worth your time, unfortunately. That's where it can get tricky. I will certainly share the good ones I come across, and write posts on them, so hopefully that will help.

It is indeed a hard skill to master. I am going to get this book. I love stuff like that and although I do not write a lot of fiction these days I love to read on writing. I used to really struggle with telling not showing and it is always on my mind

I've been reading many books on writing. That's how I received this recommendation. And I'm glad that I did. It explained the topic is a very usable way. With a lot of examples. I think I will look into the author's other books too.

I only own a couple of writing books. Ironically some of the ones I have read are really poorly written which is always amusing. Will defo check out this one

In fact I just ordered it. I decided to go for paperback. As much as I love my Kindle, for reference type books I like to have one I can easily skip back and forth on.

I am excited now!

Hard copy version of this one would be a great investment. I may end up there myself. I will refer to this one a lot, for the examples and key words to look for. Hope you get a lot out of it.

Thanks for the book suggestion. @rhondak turned me onto the idea of deep POV through the well-storied blog, and I've read through a lot of that, but a whole book! I'm excited! 😎

I loved the book. I found it to be a wonderful book rich with examples of what to look for and how to apply the rule, as well as when not to. A lot to work with and use in ones own writing.

I bought it yesterday and am reading it now, too.

I hope you get as much from it as I did.

Another excellent post, I think that i will be downloading that book this evening.

I've only just gotten back into writing fiction and I am sure that it could be better, I'll look forward to reading that book over the next couple of days.

When I get my writing to flow and have the reader feel like they are almost a part of the story then it is because I have the show/tell balance right (amongst other important areas - but that one is a key one). The problem is I have no idea how I do that, just that in those situations it works. Then in others I struggle and I can see it and then I struggle to know how to bring the story to life. This book deals with that particular topic better than any thing I have read yet. There are a lot of internet sites that touch on this topic, but nothing really delves in as deep as this. Worth the few dollars that it cost.

I'm being totally honest I think that you more or less always nail it and I really think that when I started following you that you were brilliant, but I think that you have gotten even better over time!

I've just downloaded that book :-)

Thank you. Perhaps we are our own worst critic. I always appreciate and value the feedback that I get. And my writing has definitely improved over these last few months. I think that as I am becoming more more aware as a writer, I am noticing the flaws that exist. Small or large. And I just keep trying to hone the skill, to tell better stories, tell them in more interesting ways, and keep the reader as enthralled as possible. these are the challenges.

I found this fascinating! I am not a writer (hahahaha, I now know the difference between blogger and writer), so I had never come across this rule. I have a thing with interesting new knowledge and I read quite a few novels, so thanks to you I'm going to be saying to myself... rule broken/observed repeatedly. I don't think I am happy about this. Oh, and about yesterday's squiggly line. I typed a word today that I had no idea how to spell and had an expectation of the squiggly line which never materialised. Then I felt weird about that.

The show/tell rule is the bane of many a writer's life. Mainly because it is so poorly taught. Just 'do more of this, do less of that.' But if you don't know what you are looking for it can feel overwhelming. Then it is all pure gut feeling - when the writing feels off, but you aren't sure why. That example I used is a classic one. The adverb to 'tell' what a character is feeling, rather than 'showing' so that the reader can see it for themselves and enter the story at a deeper level.

As for the squiggly line, sometimes my word processor just gives up on me and stops showing the red line altogether. That is a scary feeling. Where's my safety net? Even one I complain about.

I really learnt something new today, thanks to you. Jokes aside, that is what I find pushes my buttons these days. I guess you are around my age, and I don't know if this applies to everyone, probably not, but I love NEW. It's increasingly hard to find?

Learning new things is what life is about. I know a lot of people around my age (and some even younger) who have no interest in it. They know what they know and that's all they need to know.

I pity them, there is nothing like the sweet obsession of a new interest.

For real, cuz.

(That's a new street lingo I am trialling. I think I will stop now. Time to find a new new interest)

Street lingo is good. I have an 18 year old daughter. She uses one term(?) I love.
Extra
It refers to a wide variety of things.
"Joshua is being so extra" a new boyfriend who bought aher a nice present
"It's very extra" on checking out someone's dubious outfit
"You really are being extra" when I overreact
I have a best friend the majority of people find intimidating, who is going through a tough (re sports injuries post). I told her people would never even think of sympathising with her as she is very extra.
I love slang!

I like it. The word extra is truly extra. For real.

Sounds like your book is giving you some good advice. I also battles Little voices in my head as I write, more often than not they are saying, wait a minute read this it's really crap, you have added details that are of no importance, used Too Many modifiers. Finances think for a minute and try to figure out what it is you're really trying to say.

This particular book was extremely helpful. I know of the rule, just never had the exact means of how to apply it. Which just leaves me dizzy knowing the rule applies but not being able to pin it down completely. So then it becomes less of a concern now that I have a much better idea of what I am looking for. Which frees up energy and attention to concentrate of actual writing, or more internal dialogue, which hopefully leads to better writing.

I am yet to master this skill i'm afraid, but yo, i just stumbled on this and its great, i like how you lay it all out. Your internal director is good, i need one.

I think a lot of people struggle with this particular skill. But it's good to at least know about it, and know you struggle with it. At least then you can deal with it. That's the stage I'm at. It's not always a problem, but when it does happen its knowing why and what to do about it. That makes a difference.

I see a lot of writing that could do with a better understanding of this skill. And that's published writing (usually self published).

Thanks for your comment.

Congratulations @naquoya! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of comments received

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

By upvoting this notification, you can help all Steemit users. Learn how here!

@naquoya got you a $1.62 @minnowbooster upgoat, nice!
@naquoya got you a $1.62 @minnowbooster upgoat, nice! (Image: pixabay.com)


Want a boost? Click here to read more!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.18
TRX 0.13
JST 0.029
BTC 57452.21
ETH 3016.39
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.36