NSAIDs Like Ibuprofen May Significantly Increase Your Chance Of A Heart Attack

in #science7 years ago (edited)

Have a little pain, take a Ibuprofen (Advil) right? Joints hurting after exercise? Pop an Naproxen (Aleve). They are a pretty safe pain reliever right? Doctors have their patients taking them like they are pez candies some times. There have been reports for quite a while describing some cardiac issues that can arise from use of NSAIDs but it would seem people are starting to take notice.


Source

I'd bet you might have seen this discussed elsewhere in the news recently, but if not lets have a very brief chat about some work published in the European Heart Journal: Cardiovascular Pharmacotherapy titled "Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug use is associated with increased risk of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest: a nationwide case–time–control study"

What Is An NSAID?

An NSAID, or Non-Steroidal Anti Inflammatory Drug that provide three properties to people who take them, analgesic (which is the fancy medical term for pain killing), antipyretic (more medical lingo, this time it means fever reducing), and also anti-inflammatory (HAHA! not so fancy with this term eh medical doctors!).

NSAIDs accomplish these functions through inhibiting two enzymes throughout the body called cyclooxygenases-1 and -2. You may be more familiar with their abbreviated names COX-1 and COX-2. These two enzymes are involved in the generation of a different hormone molecule called a prostaglandin, which is responsible for regulating a variety of cellular pathways including controlling inflammation levels.

These drugs are some of the most commonly used in the world, with up to 27 million people in the US alone reporting using them on a regular basis.[2]

There are two classes of NSAIDS those that non selectively inhibit the COX enzymes, and those that selectively inhibit only COX-2. The variety of NSAID people previously thought to be most relevant to cardiac health (thought to be correlated to an increased chance of stroke and heart failure) were those that non-selectively inhibit the COX enzymes.[3] However the authors of this article state that despite all of the previous evidence there were no clear studies showing a correlation between use of NSAIDs and heart attacks (cardiac arrest).


WHY DID I TAKE THAT ADVIL???

So they set out to see if there was or was not one based upon data from Denmark.

Results of the Study

  • Ibuprofin (a non selective COX inhibitor) was the most common NSAID taken (51% of people in the databases).
  • The use of ANY NSAID was associated with an increase in the risk of a heart attack (increased risk by about 17-49% with 95% confidence)
  • Most of this risk came from non selective COX inhibitors (Such as Ibuprofen aka Advil), they increased the risk 18-48% with 95% confidence. However no significant correlation was found for Naproxen (Aleve) despite it also being a non specific NSAID.
  • NSAIDS selective for only inhibiting COX-2 (like celebrex) did NOT show a strong relationship to heart attacks like the Ibuprofen did.

What Should We Think About This?

The research indicates that Ibuprofen especially has a negative effect on the heart, and supports other previous studies indicating similar findings. I am not going to make any recommendations on how you should live your life, however it is always good to know about the potential risks associated with any drug we put into our bodies. Hopefully findings such as this will encourage more research into other methods of pain control that may not have such significant cardiac effects.

There is always Tylenol (acetaminophen) which is not classified as an NSAID as it does not have the same anti inflammatory effects, and is specific for COX-2, which would likely place it in the category with the other COX-2 specific drugs that do not have the adverse heart health effects. However, if you take this one you likely want to avoid any consumption of alcohol as the combination of the two can lead to severe liver and kidney damage.[4], [5]

Sources

  1. https://academic.oup.com/ehjcvp/article/3/2/100/2739709/Non-steroidal-anti-inflammatory-drug-use-is
  2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23723142
  3. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15705456
  4. http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/814484
  5. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2014937/

All Non Cited Images Are From Pixabay.com or Flickr.com And Are Available Under Creative Commons Licenses

Any Gifs Are From Giphy.com and Are Also Available for Use Under Creative Commons Licences



If you like this work, please consider giving me a follow: @justtryme90. I am here to help spread scientific knowledge and break down primary publications in such a way so as to cut through the jargon and provide you the main conclusions in short and easy to read posts.

Thank you for your continued support of my work! I appreciate all those who follow me (and those who don't too, but I appreciate you much much less ;) ).


Sort:  

Thank you for this article. Adding to the kidney issues, the heart and stomach are also very important to consider. A few points to discuss. One is that you are right, the newest research is saying that COX-2 selective inhibitors are not shown to increase heart attacks (at least Celebrex) in relation to non-selective types. However, Vioxx (COX 2- selective) was taken off the market, due to what is at least debatable now, significant heart mortality increase. There may have been confounding variables in this but one study found that Vioxx doubled the risk of myocardial infarction and the company voluntarily took it off the market. The VIGOR study found a 14% increase in Aleve. I don't fully have confidence in any of these studies at the moment because they are so contradictory even though they are very large studies with much thought and design. Important to note that I think all NSAIDS whether COX 1 or 2 should be treated with caution in those with coronary artery disease. COX 1 and 2 are both found in the vasculature of the heart.

Another note on tylenol: in basic terms it works mostly on the central nervous system. We don't fully understand this mechanism of action and why it doesn't work systemically (not an anti-inflammatory)...One theory is that the drug is broken down peripherally. So I would not expect any cardiovascular effects from it. So it probably modulates (decreases) pain by acting centrally and regulates temperature centrally.

Thank you for the informative reply. I always learn something from our interactions. Didn't know about viox, wonder what the true cause of the heart issues is. Perhaps there is more tissue specificity to some of these compounds then others?

Yeah I know about paracetamol and cox-2 inhibition in the central nervous system. It's fascinating to me how these compounds are so different in their effect but the target is the same.

Good thinking. They are really interesting drugs but as a chemist you may be able to postulate better theories on why based on the structure of the compounds! I'll leave that to you haha. Tylenol basically becomes inactivated. As far as the heart stuff, we really are all over the place. Obviously, we are not understanding it well enough or certain drugs are causing heart issues not from the COX-inhibition. Perhaps the 14% increase with Aleve was true effects from COX-inhibition...but Vioxx DOUBLING cardiovascular mortality....now something else has to be going on there haha.

I discovered you blog when I saw your generous vote on mine. Congrats - you have a new follower! I am told people like those.

I wish more people were informed about simple over the counter meds. My brother is dying because his liver is shot. He is an alcoholic and you can probably figure out what happened. We were raised with Tylenol in the house because that is what they gave you in hospitals. It can't be said enough:

"if you take this one you likely want to avoid any
consumption of alcohol as the combination of
the two can lead to severe liver and kidney damage"

I was never told that about Tylenol when growing up.

Tylenol is a a wonderful painkiller, and quite safe to take AFIK even in large does. Unfortunately the combination of it and moderate doses of alcohol simultaneously leads to liver and kidney damage. I honestly only discussed tylenol in this blog as I wanted to provide an example that when you hear about the potential dangers of NSAIDs, the alternatives also have their own set of potential complications.

In life and in medicine there certainly appears to be no such thing as a free lunch. Every compound we ingest has pluses and minuses to it.

I am sorry to hear about your brother! :(

Thank you for reading.

@justtryme90 That's quite an expose!

I don't take crap I mean .. pharma meds
herbs and water do the trick
even my doctor says that - take a lot of water + rest ;)

IMHO pharma meds always have side effect/s don't they? They heal whichever aching part of your body and kill the filters - the organs suffer all the time or one organ - mostly the kidney.
Way back a long time ago - they just used plants - now they call those who administer homeopathy quack the herbal doctors -too but actually there are still many places specially in Asia - that don't take crap I mean pharma meds and they're just fine - specially in China.

It is important to keep all things in perspective still I think.

IMHO pharma meds always have side effect/s don't they?

Everything has side effects, even something as simple as table salt.

Way back a long time ago - they just used plants - now they call those who administer homeopathy quack the herbal doctors -too but actually there are still many places specially in Asia - that don't take crap I mean pharma meds and they're just fine - specially in China.

Do you know what western medicine calls herbal remedies that work? Medicine.

Herbal remedies often have toxicity issues just like anything else (they aren't studied as much so less is known about them), One caveat to this for those who live in the US when you purchase an herbal supplement, there is no guarantee that you are even getting what you think you are (they are not regulated, nor required to include what they claim as an ingredient, and not shockingly many supplements do not have what you are paying for at all).

I will be honest and state that this study is not sufficient for me to stop using Ibuprofen, as I certainly don't take it with any sort of regularity. Were I a chronic user of Ibuprofen I may have a conversation with my doctor about potential alternatives, but really taking care of ones health is complicated.

I wouldn't trust my health to herbal medicine, if I had done that I would be dead long ago. :)

I am a scientist after all, I trust the answers derived through the scientific method and rigorous analytical testing. I also support continued testing to further reinforce whether what we think is okay, truly is.

@justtryme90 I respect your choice don't get me wrong
and yes not everything that claims or are tagged "herbal" do cure disease some are really quacks - am referring to mostly fresh pick herbs (organic, too) and certified homeopathic meds. I don't know about the US but the EU is very strict with allowing any homeopathic meds to be sold unless well studied.

I respect yours as well. :)

AFIK The US plays it a little loosey goosey with anything that can be labeled a supplement. The EU is more strict in this regard.

Thank you for reading and engaging in discussion.

@justtryme90 I always read your stuff though sometimes I don't comment
I hope your health progress - it's possible :D

EDIT:Thank you - !

Salt is one of the leading causes of congestive heart failure exacerbation haha. The vast majority of my patients coming in with acute CHF exacerbation ate a lot of salt that week haha.

Well, that's too bad. Because ibuprofen also prevents memory loss when marijuanicating; and used with cannabis may prevent Alzheimer's Disease.

http://www.medicaldaily.com/memory-loss-marijuana-blocked-ibuprofen-drug-duo-may-halt-alzheimers-progression-263443

The link you provided me talks about Ibuprofen's inhibition of COX-2 being important (Ibuprofen being a non specific inhibitor of both COX 1 and 2), this article that I have discussed here says the COX-2 specific NSAIDS do not correlate with the heart attack. So perhaps a different, less problematic NSAID would also be fine in the case you linked as well.

Cannabinoids: a real prospect for pain relief doi:10.1016/S1471-4892(01)00120-5

Indeed, i strongly support further research into what we can do with certain cannabinoids.

One of the most remarkable things I've read on the topic is on Cannabinoid-induced apoptosis. There's certainly lots of potential. Let's hope more research teams will find themselves in a political climate where the bureaucracy that is so often coupled to the substance has been reduced.

I couldn't agree more. It's honestly a shame that we haven't been studying these compounds intensively for the past many decades. Think where we could be now had bureaucracy not gotten in the way.

Very logical to stay away from those bottles of crappy stuff !

Thank you for reading! Still, It's not always so easy when you are in pain. I understand why someone would use them, despite the potential negative outcome. Pain, especially chronic pain is awful. :(

Pain is an indicator something is massively wrong so we need to listen to our body and explore what we should change but numbing it with pain killers doesn't help long term . It's just a quick but ineffective fix. Occasionally I had to take those pills as well but I am lucky I found ways to cure naturally. I know it's easy said but when in pain it's easier to grab that toxic stuff

I think, If you are taking it repeatedly, it may probably hurt you. You included nice animation.

You included nice animation.

Gotta put something silly in an otherwise serious post.

I guess all of this is related to the fact that one uses such drugs on a regular basis, isn't it?

Nope. That's not what the article was saying. I don't know the timeframe for the increased chance though.

Yes I know, but I was surprized this was not addressed.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.13
JST 0.030
BTC 64561.21
ETH 3418.15
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.57