The ones that get at least a smile make it in the list! :D
For a glimpse...here's a video of one of their pizzas (the one with topped with little pizzas):
(See the comments below for embedded links & images for each item. You can even vote for this post as a whole, or each of the puns individually. I'll know how much you're laughing along with me!)
21.) Night of the Living Ched (Now I'd like to consider putting some sort of hot sauce in my baked mac!)
23.) The official condiment: Dijon
24.) The Dark...Al Dente?
25.) Steaks to unite Americans....?
26.) 'Herb' my enthusiasm? Yes please!
27.) Unsteakable? (Joss Whedon might like that reference too!)
28.) One serious snack please!
29.) Pizza Seed
30.) A pun evolution during a hot day.
How did I find their Instagram feed? If I remember correctly, I was on Tumblr looking for FNL related posts. Then found one with Coach Taylor (TBA for Instagram link!).
Previous posts from this series:
Search Terms: New York / Pizza / Cheese / Crust / Vegetables / Sauce / Special / Off The Menu / Harvey Dent / Batman / Gotham / Curb Your Enthusiasm / Buffy / Harry Potter / Avocado / Mustard