Improving Autonomy - Vegetables and revolutions inside!

in #education6 years ago (edited)

Some loose ends

At the beginning of my first post on motivation I said I'd be leaving loose ends that I'd later grab to write some more on the subject. Therefore I recommend you to read part one and part two.


brush-3175578_640.jpg
Source: Pixabay

One of this loose ends concerns solutions that can be applied to our educational systems in order to adapt them to the future world. In other words, knowing that intrinsic motivation is what will eventually drive happiness and self-realisation, how can we change our educational systems to get better at it? That's the exercise I'll be making, following the Self-Determination Theory's (SDT) pillars.

Today I'll discuss autonomy and how it can be improved in our educational systems.

Autonomy

The autonomous and self-regulated child is the one that is able to learn for herself. For example if she wants to know what lead to the French Revolution, she will know which teacher to ask for sources and books, and will know how to search. The same happens for arts. For example a autonomous dance student tries to know which particular exercise will help her with a movement she's not so good at, and she will autonomously practice everyday in order to achieve it. Autonomy is one of the sources of intrinsic motivation, because an autonomous child will be able to pursuit goals and succeed.

So what could we change in our educational system to fit a more autonomous promoting environment? A few ideas:

  • Make more questions, and give less "free" answers. Teachers can have a more "passive" role in teaching. Instead of giving information and expecting kids to learn it without any interest on it, they could poke them with projects and questions that make them take action and ask for help, search the internet, and have ideas. How to evaluate them? Just compare what they propose to learn with what they do learn: evaluation is for the teacher to know what's happening and how to help students, and not for extrinsically rewarding them!

  • Wait for higher stages of internalization to teach things that they don't enjoy. This is a big one, because we all have to learn things that we don't enjoy but they may be useful in our future life. But just like you can convince a child that eating vegetables is good for their health, you can also convince them to learn things they don't enjoy a lot. If they are intrinsically motivated and know how to pursuit their goals, they'll develop self-regulatory systems for learning other things as well.

  • Abolish classrooms and seriation by ages. This is not so radical as it may seem, since Finland already does it. By creating open spaces and areas where teachers teach to whoever wants to learn instead of the rigidity of the regular classrooms and classes, students can move and ask different teachers for help, receiving feedback from different students of different ages.


kids-girl-pencil-drawing-159823.jpeg
Source: Pixabay

  • Let students identify, find solutions, and apply solutions to school's problems. Students are creative and they really want to make their school a better place. They are able to find solutions and apply them if we give them autonomy to search, learn and create. They are also able to manage a budget under orientation (that's why teachers are there). A weekly school assembly is the first step to democratize and create workgroups, present and approve solutions.
  • Promote free writing, free art, and creativity in general. This is also a big one. Not only for the "practical aspect" of it -
    In a more and more automated world, creativity will have a predominant role in kid's future lives - but also for the sake of happiness and to let children know themselves

Of course, we should never confuse autonomy with chaos. The environment needs to promote it and leave a free way for it to develop, but in the beginning (first stages of internalization) it definitely needs to be guided by teachers in order to increase autonomy and boost intrinsic motivation. Otherwise the sense of incompetence would jeopardise our efforts.


france-63022_640.jpg
Source: Pixabay

Here are some great posts I read recently and I recommend:

The mundane medicinal and magical common primrose by @skycae

DIY hanging basket by @sherylneil

Adopting the Adoption by @sweetpea

Soviet montage theory and you by @derosnec (there is also the second part, go check her blog!)


If you enjoyed this post please consider:
upvote follow resteem
Source: @runicar
live sustainably

Sort:  

These are some great suggestions. I'll have to go back and read through your earlier posts.

I never really gave it the label of autonomy, but I agree that the most important function of education has to be teaching a student to teach him or herself. Give them the tools to be pro-active in learning, and to hunger for a lifetime of learning.

That's right! Of course students need to have proper guidance, and some need more guidance than others... But that's what the school is for! :)

I was just talking about homeschooling and the problems of the Prussian-based education system. I was attempting to explain the type of education I feel our children need/deserve. This will help; thank you for this article.

In my opinion, homeschooling as a concept is not a bad idea, but the general lack of pedagogical knowledge (which is understandable, of course) inviabilizes its application. I do believe a strong homeschooling component is key to better relationships and it makes a lot of difference in learning and motivation. That's another topic I'll be researching and writing about in the future: relatedness as a key to the self-determination theory :)

Here in Portugal there is a unusual situation that uses homeschooling as a way to flee from the current educational system: the school had less than 10 kids so it had to close (in a small almost deserted village). The mayor and the parents decided to sign for homeschooling - technically legal in Portugal - and hired teachers to start an alternative educational project. And it works much better.

The main problem I see with homeschooling is the lack of socialization. Most people who lack the pedagogical knowledge do not bother to attempt to homeschool (seeing public school as a form of free daycare) but some do abuse the system and essentially put their children to work under the guise of homeschooling.

My current, half-baked plan is public preschool until age five. Homeshcool with certain things like Physical Education, Scouts and sports at public school until age 12-14 then full public school.

Here in the United States we are allowed great flexibility in how we homeschool, giving us a hybrid solution. I look forward to your future posts.

I agree 100% with your approach and view on the subject. I believe a hybrid solution works in most cases, but the government must guarantee that homeschooling is properly done: children are individuals, not property of possibly-negligent parents...

This post just got a free resteem to 5200 followers.

  • For a standard resteem: Send 0.05 SBD to @abasinkanga + post link as memo

  • For a free resteem everyday, join Abasinkanga Resteem Service On Discord Chat > Just Click Here

I think we should teach the children more lessons about life in general, and less lessons about office work. It seems like all the educational system is about office work when life is so much more than that

That's very true! In my opinion an educational system is as good as it is adapted to future challenges. In Finland for example they learn things like cooking, politics, writing, and lots of sports and arts. They learn how to tolerate, how to understand cultural differences, how to respect the nature, etc. Those are the challenges of kid's future!

Congratulations! This post has been upvoted from the communal account, @minnowsupport, by zpedro from the Minnow Support Project. It's a witness project run by aggroed, ausbitbank, teamsteem, theprophet0, someguy123, neoxian, followbtcnews, and netuoso. The goal is to help Steemit grow by supporting Minnows. Please find us at the Peace, Abundance, and Liberty Network (PALnet) Discord Channel. It's a completely public and open space to all members of the Steemit community who voluntarily choose to be there.

If you would like to delegate to the Minnow Support Project you can do so by clicking on the following links: 50SP, 100SP, 250SP, 500SP, 1000SP, 5000SP.
Be sure to leave at least 50SP undelegated on your account.

This post has received a 0.63 % upvote from @drotto thanks to: @banjo.

          Congratulations you have been upvoted because you, or a friend left a post in the NewbieResteem Post promotion Box. Discord Chat channel post Promotion Box.


I'm not sure the American Educational system can be fixed. It is broken, and I see no method of repairing it. It is nothing more than a babysitter for the parents, and the parents bosses.


         

Clicking on the images will take you to "Newbie Resteem Initiative info" - Our Discord Channel - abh12345's - IFC page

We invite you to use our tag (#newbieresteemday) to connect with more of our members. To learn more visit: Come Join Us!!! (Newbie Resteem Initiative)

I bashadow invite you to also click on the IFC Castle and learn about @apolymask and his game, be sure to tell them I sent you. As abh12345 has made lots of votes possible, apolymask thru his IFC game has made lots of fun possible.

Lots of votes made possible due to the kindness of abh12345 and his Steemit Curation Leagues

I believe there's a "soft" way to slowly adapt the system and update it to the present and future challenges. But sure the easy way would be to make everything new.

Here in Portugal there are lots of private schools that designed educational systems from the ground, and they work. Problem is, they're private schools. There is an exception a wonderful public school that "hacked" the system shortly after the revolution of '74 and had amazing results. It's being extensively replicated in Brazil by it's founder José Pacheco.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.13
JST 0.027
BTC 59531.52
ETH 2678.46
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.43