Myanmar Travel Blog Part 4 : Inle Lake fishermen. Real or fake? (All my original photos)

in #travel7 years ago (edited)

Myanmar Travel Blog Part 4 : Inle Lake fishermen. Real or fake? (All my original photos)

pwalk2200_DSC3924.jpg

If you visit Myanmar as a tourist, chances are at some point you will visit the stunning Inle Lake.
Luckily for me, my friend was getting married close to Inle Lake, so I had time to take a boat trip around the lake.

inle001_DSC3825-2.jpg
Chances are that you will get approached by "touts" trying to sell you a boat trip. This guy on a moped was young, but it is typical in Myanmar for kids to start working very young..

The boat trip:

The boat trips are reasonably priced, for a full day we were charged 18,000 qyat (10 pounds sterling / 2 SBD / 0.0009 BTC ) at the time of writing.

For this price, you get a full boat for a full day. (which can be shared by a number of people) and the driver.
The drivers will take you to a lot of touristy areas, (I guess they will make commission for this). Luckily our driver was super chilled and agreed to take us to the places we wanted without any complaint.
Each boat has it's own name which is nice.

pwalk2203_DSC3987.jpg

Spoiling the unspoilt

_DSC3829.jpg

It is now a very "Touristy" experience, with boats full of tourists travelling around the same locations (not as many as Halong Bay in Vietnam though.) There is some irony in that beautiful remote places get discovered by backpackers, then end up being full of tourists wanting a sanitised version of the experience, and in turn spoiling the destinations.

The Fishermen. Government sponsored actors or a real local tradition?

If you look on the internet,or any decent Myanmar photo blog, you will see photographs of the fishermen on Inle lake. Unfortunately I di!n't get them with a draw jopping sunrise or sunset, but they still make for a great photo opportunity. .

_DSC3867.jpg

So how did I realise that they are "fake" and in fact largely a tourist photo opportunity.

The giveaway signs: On the day, I just thought that I got lucky with a lot of the photographs, and was enjoying the day and the beauty of the lake and it's surroundings.

When I got back and started going through my photographs, I started to notice that a large percentage of the photographs had the fishermen staring directly at the camera lens.

Well, of course this could be normal, but then consider the number of tourists that sail around the lake every day. . The novelty of cameras would soon wear off and become a mild annoyance. Plus the tourist boats have really noisy engines which would scare away the fish...

The Truman tourist show.

pwalk2202_DSC3992.jpg

I'm guessing that either (a)( the fishermen are given a set amount of money every day for going out onto the lake to pose for tourists, plus can keep their share of the fish caught.
(b) Most of them are in fact not fishermen, but paid actors (given local wages, it would be relatively cheap to pay the fishermen a 2/3 dollars a day each to ensure the tourism continues. )

This may seem hard to swallow, but a similar event was taking place in the craft villages around the lake, where the women were posing for dozens of tourists whilst carrying on with their work. In this case it's more obvious as most of the tourists will then go on and buy something from the craft village.

_DSC3916.jpg

So how do I feel about the fishermen?

Well, it's a shame that they need to make a living by posing for tourists (I'm not sure if they also catch enough fish to sustain a living). It's the same with the "fake" craft villages that populate the lake. I guess a sanitised version of reality keeps the tourists happy, brings money into the local economy and also helps boost the national tourist trade.

The reality which exists before tourist arrived, and only intrepid explorers, colonists and backpackers visited these regions would have been much harsher, with no flushing toilets, electricity or even INTERNET!!! (Anyone under the age of 30 would probably find the horror of this too much to believe. Is it progress that tourists bring, or in fact a gradual destruction and erosion of local traditions and cultures? Or maybe a bit of both?

Please add any thoughts on this in the comments section, I'd love to hear your views on the matter.

INle203_DSC4054.jpg

So please. Take a blue pill. Sit back and enjoy the photos. ..

pwalk2201_DSC3959.jpg

INle201_DSC3869.jpg

INle201_DSC3903.jpg

INle202_DSC3899.jpg

As President Trump would say " Fake fishermen. Not like me, real proper fisherman I caught more fish quicker than anyone ever. Big fish. Biggest. "

Myanmar blog .jpg

All fishermen photographs taken with Nikon D800, and 70-200 Tamron G2 Lens. Motorbike taken with D800, Sigma 50mm Art.

Myanmar really is a country of contrasts, from people working so hard, to lazing around, beautiful countryside and overcrowded city streets.

Please check out
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
(If you haven't already)

Hope you enjoyed the photographs, please RE-STEEM, FOLLOW and UPVOTE if you like my blog.

A selection of my posts:

Steemit photographers:

My favourite photographers on Steemit: @eyegasm @bescouted @jasonrussell @marinauzelac @juliank @mynewlife @siavatch @timsaid @gringalicious

No more fake news!!!

Bring on

Can't not mention George Carlin RIP.

Powered by @Steemitworldmap

Sort:  

First of all, I love your photography! It captures the atmosphere and the emotion of the place perfectly and I can feel what it is like to be there. The fishermen with the almost untouched land behind them was a picture perfect shot.
Secondly, in regards to your observation, if the government really has set up a system like this then I don't think its all that bad. Even though it might be reducing the fishermen to figures for photos, the commercial nature of fishing has probably made it harder for them to survive so this could be a positive for them.
I really enjoy your photography and posts so going to follow you to see what else you have in store!

Hi Peter, thanks for your comments, glad that you like my photos. Sure I think you are right. It's common around the world for people in tourist areas to be "actors", in London the Beefeaters are playing a role for the tourists, and in other countries there are people playing "roles" that would not be relevant or possible except for tourists. It's probably not a bad job sitting out in the lake and knowing that you will get paid even if you don't catch any fish!!! Really the joke is on the tourists who beleive what they are seeing as I mention in the post. Also this can refer to many things in life, we just accept what we see. Blue pill or red pill...

Congratulations, Your Post Has Been Added To The Steemit Worldmap!
Author link: http://steemitworldmap.com?author=damnthatbanana
Post link: http://steemitworldmap.com?post=myanmar-travel-blog-part-4-inle-lake-fishermen-real-or-fake-all-my-original-photos


Want to have your post on the map too?
Add the following inside your post:
!steemitworldmap xxx lat yyy long description d3scr

(replace xxx and yyy with latitude and longitude)

Heya, just swinging by to let you know you're being featured in our Daily Travel Digest!

Thanks Steemitworldmap!!

Great post @damnthatbanana. You make some interesting points here. Your photos are pretty great though, staged or not. Plus, being vegan, I'm not sad that the fish get to live if it is all staged.

Haha, ethically a good thing I guess!! No fish were harmed in the making of these photographs.

Inle Lake photos are just incredible

Thanks!! I guess you mean mine.

Nice post and really great photos @damnthatbanana, it is a pleasure to be featured alongside you in the #DailyTravelDigest. Have upvoted and followed you :)

Really really nice pictures and congratulations for this post

Thanks so much.

Beautiful images and an excellent piece. Its an interesting issue. I'm a fan of 'each to their own'. People need to earn a living and if the locals have found a way to earn a bit of extra cash then more power to them. I'll never look at those fisherman photos the same way again though.

Yes, it's interesting and happens everywhere, it's not only a case with the fishermen. Probably 95% of things on TV are fake or staged for the cameras, and that's not including films and dramas!! Good luck to them, but the tourist trade can be very fickle. ... hopefully they can catch a few fish too.

Great series man ! I'm about to go to Sri Lanka next 2 weeks, hopefully I'll find some great places to take pictures.

I am looking forwards to your photos that's cool. All of the temples are really expensive to visit, but photogenic. I loved Ella for scenic photographs if you have a chance to go...

Oh did you actually go to Sri Lanka, would be nice to get some recommendations, hit me on steem
chat if you there.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.15
JST 0.029
BTC 63525.38
ETH 2645.15
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.76