The Concept of the Finite Pie and Steemit
I reread this chapter on the Myth of the Finite Pie, in the book called “Killing Sacred Cows” , which was written by Garrett B. Gunderson. In this book, Gunderson discusses nine “myths” which he feels have “crippled our nation for generations:” One of those Myths is the one of the “Infinite Pie”. This myth is often traced to a 18th Century Philosopher Thomas Malthus, who famously pined that the number of hungry mouths in the world had no limit, but the available food to feed them was limited.
In my mind, I breakdown Mr. Gunderson’s prose to basic concepts which I ponder and examine. This simple incorrect statement by Mr. Malthus is suppose to be the basis of the Myth of the Finite Pie, which is the concept that wealth and resources are limited and you must get yours before someone else gets it, and it’s corollary thought, if someone gets wealthy first, you can only get wealthy by taking it from them.
I enjoyed pondering this thought, because the opposite financial and philosophical theory is the basis of Cryptocurrency at its highest and best use, in my humble opinion and is the highest and best use of the Steemit platform, also my humble opinion.
It is my assertion, which I share with Mr. Gunderson, perhaps as a demonstration of the validity of the theory “That we seek out authors who agree with our personal assertions for validation”, that the pie is actually infinite. In the basic sense I believe Mr. Malthus to be wrong about humanity being incapable of feeding all its hungry mouths by increasing food production, based on my observations that we have developed the ability, but not the will to feed all hungry mouths. And my observation that wealth is not finite, so you don’t have to “...rob Peter to pay Paul” you can actually earn or produce more money or wealth to pay them both.
It is probably hard for some or perhaps many of you to believe this Myth is a foundation of human behavior. This Myth of the Finite Pie is also called a “Scarcity Mindset” by Mr. Gunderson and many other authors. But apparently, according to many Psychologists and Sociologists, many human behaviors are derived from this belief system, which results in un-necessary competition and waste of resources in situations where collaboration would be more productive. Now I don’t feel these principles are universal, as there are definitely some things which are finite, such as time in a day, lions named Mufasa and other unique, unreproducible resources. But truth be told the number of 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style homes we can build, one half acre lots we can clear, clothes for our bodies, food for our mouths, immunizations for our children cars, watches, phones, etc these are resources we can create almost infinitely based on the amount of land and resources on the earth. And we can create much of these resources more efficiently in a cooperative and collaborative fashion, then if we each create each item ourselves.
Now on to the meat of this post, I share Mr. Gundersons’ belief that wealth isn’t finite, that it is created and in free and open economic systems we can work together to create significant amounts of wealth, which can be distributed widely, albeit unequally due to natural differences in motivation, effort and desire for accumulation. But I believe that capitalism, free market economies and yes Cryptocurrency can be mechanisms for collaborative creation and distribution of wealth. It was this possibility and indeed the very nature of the Steemit system of wealth creation, which attracted me here initially. Now while nothing made by imperfect people is perfect, and most would agree that Steemit is not perfect and in fact is constantly evolving through HardForks into a different entity. We are attempting through distributed proof of stake and stake weighted consensus, to achieve a better system of creating and distributing wealth here. Those of us here hopefully understand that by curating, upvoting and being curated and upvoted in return, we are creating and distributing rewards/wealth in varied proportion to our motivation, effort and stake. The industrious and astute attempt to compensate for their lack of stake with effort, motivation and implementing what they learn on the platform to receive a greater share of rewards to spend or increase their influence and hence their rewards.
This is a complex social and financial experiment, where we each bring to bear our personal talents and the free marketplace of Steemit tells us what our stake and talents are valued at in this market. This is not to be confused with some absolute measure of value, but merely what it is valued at today, in this market with multiple forces at work determining its current stated value.
✍🏼 By written by Shortsegments
Read other articles by me on the Steemit Social Media Platform, where writers get paid for their content by the community by upvotes worth the cryptocurrency, called Steem.
Please follow my Steemleo investment Blog
Please follow my Twitter Feed Here
![BF4F2613-2A40-4B4A-8A5B-9306C59296CD.gif](https://steemitimages.com/0x0/https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmb9TS566scoa9aHSDuFSYFZANfaCqorMAgtRXxVUNbxF9/BF4F2613-2A40-4B4A-8A5B-9306C59296CD.gif)
😅😊
We all know that these experiments won't work. Too many are too lazy to work and a small group have to feed and carry them all. Without money the value will be given to grain, apples a service in another way and the end will be the same.
Do you Steemit is unsuccessful in distributing rewards/wealth?
@shortsegments I think Steemit is. It needs more people to join, more writers but writers are not Al or existed. They run out of here. This platform is ruled by a few rich men who make their own rules if it comes to voting, downvoting, what is trending. ❤️
I agree that Steemit is still not completely decentralized, but the increasing number of Minnows and dolphins suggests we are moving in that direction. I am encouraged by the widening distribution of Stake.
It is easy to grow with Steem being so low it says nothing about writing or good content. It is clear to me since the last HF this is a platform for investors mainly and that somehow is a problem.
I agree that these ideas have limits, hard work and motivation can produce success despite the economic system, but the product of laziness is the same and is a drag on all systems except those where the penalty is “need & want” humans are complex in some ways, simple in others, rewarding laziness encourages more laziness. 😰
Posted using Partiko iOS
I agree with that and laziness is what is rewarded here most.
I agree with that
And laziness is what is
Rewarded here most.
- wakeupkitty
I'm a bot. I detect haiku.
Interesting ideas. Inflation and rewards can make it that wealth is created infinitely on Token blockchains, but what does that due to value?
!giphy good+job
!popcorn
Cheers 🥂
#steemleo #palnet #neoxian
Posted using Partiko iOS
giphy is supported by witness untersatz!
!COFFEEA $trdo
for you
Congratulations @avare, you successfuly trended the post shared by @shortsegments!
@shortsegments will receive 0.14607338 TRDO & @avare will get 0.09738225 TRDO curation in 3 Days from Post Created Date!
"Call TRDO, Your Comment Worth Something!"
To view or trade TRDO go to steem-engine.com
Join TRDO Discord Channel or Join TRDO Web Site
Replace every time you used the word steemit with steem and the post makes more sense. Remember that steemit is just a website that uses the steem blockchain (which is the layer that actually distributes the token).
Regarding the core of your post I kind of agree. There are certain resources that are finite (oil comes to mind) that eventually are going to run out but I think that humanity will in the not so distant future switch to more sustainable alternatives.
Don't get me started on asteroid mining. Once we overcome the technological hurdles that such an endeavor entails we are looking at an amount of resources that dwarfs are current reserves.
Wow! You should write a post on asteroid mining. It sounds interesting.
Posted using Partiko iOS
This is new and catchy
Posted using Partiko iOS
Congratulations @shortsegments, your post successfully recieved 0.14607338 TRDO from below listed TRENDO callers:
To view or trade TRDO go to steem-engine.com
Join TRDO Discord Channel or Join TRDO Web Site
Thank you
To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.
![](https://steemitimages.com/640x0/https://s18.postimg.org/51o0kpijd/play200x46.png)
Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.