ADSactly World - Venezuela and its socialist measures

in #world5 years ago

Source


Introduction


Some time ago I decided to start a new series of articles about the Venezuelan situation, with the goal of providing some coverage to the type of measures that resulted in the economic collapse of the country, as well as encouraging others to research and discuss this topic.

As the majority of the readers would probably know, Venezuela is a country that is currently experiencing the worst economic and political collapse of its entire history. The level of corruption and looting coming from government officials is absolutely unprecedented, even to the point of having links with drug cartels and Islamic terrorists.

This disaster started when the Venezuelan voters decided it was a good idea to support a socialist revolution following Cuba steps under the leadership of a radical military person such as Hugo Chavez.

For some time, people from all over the world that support this ideology were amazed at the “beautiful” revolution that was taken place in Venezuela. I indicated a specific example of this in the first article where I shared a quote from the website of the well known American socialist Bernie Sanders:

These days, the American dream is more apt to be realized in South America, in places such as Ecuador, Venezuela, and Argentina, where incomes are actually more equal today than they are in the land of Horatio Alger. Who's the banana republic now? Source


Source: AP

One of the reasons I decided to write these articles was because since the Venezuelan collapse a few years ago, there is a narrative trying to portray this country as something different than socialism, when it is actually a perfect example of what happens when socialism is implemented. Before the collapse it was celebrated as a great socialist victory, after the collapse, it suddenly stopped being an example of socialism...

So far, I have covered the first 4 measures taken from Karl Marx’s book. The first one was discussed in the first article and the next 3 measures were discussed in the second article.

Today, I am going to continue with some of the remaining measures. I also recommend anyone to first check out the previous 2 articles mentioned before, in order to avoid repeating arguments, ideas, etc.


Karl Marx Measures


  • Centralisation of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly. Source: this measure was half applied. In Venezuelan the banking industry is mixed, there are private banks and public ones. There are also banks that were taken over by the government like the Bank of Venezuela, expropriated by Chavez in 2009.

In those years there were also rumors that some government’s cronies were investing heavily in other banks such as Banesco to gain administrative control over them. Besides, there is also an organism called SUDEBAN which means “Superintendence of the Institutions of the Banking Sector of Venezuela”. This organism belongs to the Ministry of Popular Power for Economy, Finance and Public Banking, and its functions are to oversee and regulate pretty much any activity that happens on the banks.

To give you a quick example of how disastrous are these distortions caused by the government’s intervention, currently the majority of the credit cards have a limit of around 1-3 dollars in local money. There are some banks that can offer bigger limits, but the majority are unable to offer bigger credits because of the lack of sufficient cash flows to handle this type of operations.

To put this into perspective, the basic food basket in Venezuela is around 300 USD, it depends on how many people live in a single house, but the number should be very close to 300 American dollars and the minimum wage is currently around 13 dollars on a monthly basis. I don’t use the local money (Bolivares) to measure prices because as some you might know, the hyperinflation makes it pointless to use Bolivares because prices would change every day. This is why a growing number of people are starting to simply use USD.

The following picture is from a well known report from American journalists where they compared how many Venezuelan bills it took to purchase just 1 chicken. This photo is from last year so today the price of the chicken in local money is much higher:


Source: Carlos Garcia Rawlins/Reuters

The great disparity in minimum and average salaries with food prices is the reason why a lot of people in Venezuela have been losing weight for years. This worrisome circumstance is described as “Maduro’s diet”, in my case, I prefer to call it the socialist diet.

  • Centralisation of the means of communication and transport in the hands of the State Source: such as with the previous point, the transport industry is mixed. We can find both private companies or individuals offering this service and public ones doing the same. However, there is a strict centralization regarding the prices because these are determined by the government, and as expected, when a government enforces a price over some product or service, everything starts to fail.

In Venezuela there has been a severe crisis in the transportation sector for years, sometimes there are problems with finding replacement tires, other times there are problems finding other replacement parts, and these are issues that affect the whole industry. This results in a reduction of the available units offering transportation services. Last year it was reported that around 90% of the transportation industry was inactive. I couldn’t find more recent statistics but the situation hasn’t improved so far.

This problem causes very difficult moments for the people that need public transportation to go to their jobs, and there have been some instances where desperate people take the drastic measure of using trucks that are designed to transport animals, not humans. Sadly, pictures like the one below are becoming more and more common as people use any type of vehicle to transport themselves, regardless if the vehicle has seats or not.


Source


Conclusion


In this article, I continued with the exploration of Karl Marx’s measures and shared my own views about whether these measures were applied in Venezuela or not. If you notice the last measure it says “means of communication” and I didn’t mention anything about them. The fact is that there are so many things to say about the way the means of communication were treated by this government that I will leave that part for the next article.

As always, I invite every Steemian to share their views and opinions about the difficult Venezuela’s situation, especially fellow Venezuelan Steemians that are experiencing the collapse of this socialist model.

Authored by @dedicatedguy

Click on the coin to join our Discord Chat



Go Adsactly

Vote @adsactly-witness for Steem witness!
Witness proposal is here:


Witness Proposal
Witness Proposal Update


Go To Steem Witness Page
In the bottom of the page type: adsactly-witness and press vote.
witness vote.gif
Use small letters and no "@" sign. Or, click here to vote directly!
Thank you!


Sort:  

Your post, @dedicatdguy, like the two previous ones, is very wise.
Like cice @hlezama, only people who are outside and do not live in Venezuela, trapped by that ideological blackmail that is socialism, can defend what is happening in Venezuela. We should tell users like @andyjem, come and live here, that is, in Venezuela (I am here and I suffer daily in a desperate way) and stop talking so much bullshit (forgive me).
When they feel hunger in their stomachs, the impossibility of accessing the most basic health service, spending hours waiting for a public bus, hanging on the doors of the very few that circulate (with the risk of falling) or like animals in a truck, we speak, Mr. @andyjem. In my country (perhaps in Latin America) there is a sharp expression: "You don't even have the fucking idea...".
Thanks again for your post, @dedicatedguy. Greetings.

Originally, Venezuela is a strange country to me. However, I read a report about Venezuela yesterday, I have leard that once a time Venezuela was rather a wealthy country, people lived in a comfortable life, they could go shopping in Miami, US freely. However, all of sudden, everything was changed. Maybe it is just due to the so-called socialism. So I am very interested in reading this blog, and I understand such kind of anger and suffering very much.

Great post, @dedicatedguy.
I'd invite people like all the socialist steemians to go visit Venezuela, spend a whole month living with 10 dollars (which is about the amount most people may be able to get a month), enjoy (like I just did today and am now exhausted) two or three long walks under about 37 degrees to run basic errands that can easily become a nightmare thanks to all the centralization policies, wait a couple of hours (like I did in the morning at the notary, which ended up being 3 hours) just to have a doc checked and get the news that you have to come back for another 3-hour line (if you're lucky) to get the second step of the process (and there will be a 3rd step), get sick and go to a hospital (out of which they'll come out sicker than they were and demoralized by the utterly dantesque spectacle), and then tell the world how much the want that socialist american dream.

Every single post here on Steemit in favor of socialism, in defense of Maduro, in reaction to some anti-socialist agenda comes from people who have no idea of what they are talking about, who have not lived a single day under the real devastating effect of that fucked up ideology, who deep down become supporters of hatred, discrimination, corruption and violence.

I agree. It is a real shame to see people defending this totalitarian ideology. I really hope that with the help of international allies this nightmare can end soon.

This post is accurate, if it were not Venezuelan I would say that this is something impossible to live, much less in these times.
But it is very sad and heartbreaking to know that each of your words are true, there is nothing worse in the world than this unfortunate socialist system, that all it has done for years has been destroying everything beautiful and prosperous that Venezuela had.

As a Venezuelan I am sad to know that everything you say is true, here you have to have more than ingenuity to survive with that painful salary that is only $ 11 a month, and to give you a very simple example of the Venezuelan miracle, a 1 Kg of Spaghetti is worth $ 2.5. and like that there are many others that simple, but I would spend hours and hours writing.

Here nothing is efficient, transport, health, education, basic services such as water, electricity, telephony and even domestic gas is a real headache.

I really liked reading your post and it is good for me to know that there are people in the world who care about Venezuela, and I also think that the intervention is taking a long time to arrive, Venezuela needs more INTERNATIONAL SUPPORT NOW!

it is good for me to know that there are people in the world who care about Venezuela

Thank you, I am Venezuelan as well.

Meanwhile, I just want to say I thank you greatly, @dedicatedguy for helping educate the community about the reality in my country and this alleged socialist model.

My friend @hlezama already said what I wanted to say.

To those who defend the regime and all its supporters: Please, come live a month in Venezuela. Then we can have that conversation.

Yes, it is easy to defend socialism while living in free and prosperous countries. What I have noticed is that socialists tend to be very hypocrite.

Please don't think America is the answer.
They will rape your country for its resources. As they have done in the middle east .
Your answer is taking control internally.
Easier said than done I know.
But better the Devil you know.
I have no answers other than never trust the USA.
Russia may be a better bet.
Socialism has a far better track record. Capitalism is for the rich not the people.

Posted using Partiko Android

Loading...
Loading...

oh dear

In Honduras we have had the exact opposite measures taken and we are in even worse shape than Venezuela, obviously there is something very wrong in the political thinking in the world and in those who root for any political system.

I don't know if Honduras is really worse than Venezuela (I highly doubt it), but by looking at its position in the economic freedom index https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking it is not a surprise that Honduras could be a better country.

The tragic thing in Venezuela is that it was once a prosperous country but socialism destroyed it.

Most third world countries could be better countries if they weren't exploited by first world countries and corporations. Honduras is worse off than Venezuela, only thing is that we have always been in such bad conditions that being in such a bad shape is considered normal.
We have an illegitimate government that actually stole the election, over 20% of our population has emigrated, we have the highest poverty level in Latin America, the divide between rich and poor is the highest in Latin America, the largest unemployment rate in LA, need I go on?

I don't deny that Honduras is in bad shape. But that is mainly due to its lack of economic freedom.

Regarding Venezuela, I invite you to take a read here https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/17/world/americas/venezuela-economy.html & https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-17/tear-gas-and-condom-shortages-what-dating-is-like-in-chaotic-caracas

What really amazes me is that people who complain about the MSM and fake news take whatever the MSM says about Venezuela as completely unbiased. I don't know what is happening in Venezuela, but I do know one thing when people from the opposition in Venezuela go out and protest pro government protesters also come out and the numbers of both groups are similar, in Honduras when people come out to protest the only ones who defend the government are the army and the police, go figure that one out.

What really amazes me is that people who complain about the MSM and fake news take whatever the MSM says about Venezuela as completely unbiased

You have Venezuelans saying the country is destroyed, you have news article from tons of websites reporting about the destruction, and you still don't accept it? Why is that?

but I do know one thing when people from the opposition in Venezuela go out and protest pro government protesters also come out and the numbers of both groups are similar

This is wrong information. I suppose you only believe government propaganda am I right? Because the only way to believe such a thing is to consume propaganda from the chavistas. Could you explain why you believe such a lie? I would like to see the source of that info to confirm you are believing the government propaganda.

No, you have it wrong dedicated guy, I will tell you something before this fake news word even came out I knew news were not quite truthful, when I was a teenager in the 70's I used to be a DXer better said I listened to shortwave radio and I used to listen to both sides of the stories, from the VOA, BBC, Deutshe Welle, radio Free Europe and from Radio Moscow, Radio Budapest etc, (I guess you get the idea) of course the version of each side was completely opposite to the others, eventually I found out both sides were lying, and since then I don't believe any news source. Now in the present and in Latin America news is completely biased into the US side of ideas. Why not? Economically all LA is dependent on the US. So whenever news comes out of the US government or US news media I tend to believe I am seeing or reading outright lies or at least very biased news. I know people who have been to Venezuela who tell me things are not quite as the media would have you believe, are they lying? Maybe, I have no way of knowing except if I went to Venezuela and lived the things first hand.
I will tell you one thing, all political systems, I don't care what they are, are just created for the enrichment of the few who are at the top, the rest of the population can live off of the scarps left after this.
On the other hand you don't believe Honduras is in worse shape than Venezuela, I will have you know Honduras has been the poorest country in Latin America for over 100 years, and this thanks to big interest groups and of course invasions by US marines to make sure these groups were not touched. Don't think I am an anti US person, I admire many things about the US, but I don't think US meddling has ever helped another country.

I know people who have been to Venezuela who tell me things are not quite as the media would have you believe

Are these people socialist by any chance? BEcause socialist tend to deny the Venezuela disaster for the simple reason the cause of the disaster is socialism itself.

What the media has been reporting about Venezuela has been absolutely true so far. You can even check the comments of fellow Venezuelans in this same article and see what they have to say.

are just created for the enrichment of the few who are at the top, the rest of the population can live off of the scarps left after this

People at the top will always have more benefit, the way to reduce poverty and have a strong middle class is with a free market economy, not with a socialist model.

but I don't think US meddling has ever helped another country.

US helped in WW2 against the national socialist from Germany. They also helped the Koreans in the Korean war against the socialist soviets. Thanks to the US South Korea exists, otherwise it will be just 1 Korea and it will be a horrible place like North Korea is today.

Panama is another example of a successful intervention.

Honduras has always been poor and that is very sad, but Venezuela was a very prosperous country in the past and socialism destroyed it. We all hope it can be prosperous again after socialism is defeated with the help of our allies Colombia, Brazil and the US.

As for economic freedom, all our economic policies are dictated not by the government but by the US and by multinational corporations, so would they be the problem?

I do believe the problem in Honduras is the lack of economic freedom. Here is another index, this time about the ease of doing business and Honduras is in position 121 http://www.doingbusiness.org/en/rankings

A very bad position that helps explain why the country is not very prosperous. Now, who decides Honduras politics, I wouldn't know, but I believe there are price controls on certain products and a government monopoly in electricity and telephone right? If that's the case, then Honduras should start by adopting a model that resembles a free market, rather than a centralized planned socialist economy.

Wrong, telephones are run by two companies both of which are foreign capital, Tigo and Claro, the government telecommunications company is nearly broke. Electricity is being privatized which is the main reason we are now paying the highest rates in Central America and are also seeing five hour blackouts every day.
You are really wrong, we have no socialist economy, in fact I have read that Honduras should be a Libertarians paradise, except for the fact that to become this paradise the Honduras government and military have had to be inflated so the population can't revolt against this paradise. Still the people do revolt. See it is like anarchy, a great idea except that you need a government to implement it.
I think you should read up on Honduras , you might be surprised because I can see most of what you are saying is speculation.

Loading...

Sir @adsactly it would be owner to read your post . You display the reality of a true world what we have to do . Thanks for your awesome post .#adsactly #great thinker

Hi, @adsactly!

You just got a 0.34% upvote from SteemPlus!
To get higher upvotes, earn more SteemPlus Points (SPP). On your Steemit wallet, check your SPP balance and click on "How to earn SPP?" to find out all the ways to earn.
If you're not using SteemPlus yet, please check our last posts in here to see the many ways in which SteemPlus can improve your Steem experience on Steemit and Busy.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.30
TRX 0.12
JST 0.032
BTC 63701.54
ETH 3092.31
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.87