You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: I propose to support Steemitboard to reward users for their achievements

in #utopian-io7 years ago (edited)

I am just a regular user (a minnow), but I would like to express my opinion about this idea.

I understand and support the idea of increasing the Steem Power amount in the @steemitboard account, but I don't support the idea of giving rewards - Steem and/or Steem Dollars (SBD) - to the users JUST BECAUSE they reached a certain number of upvotes/comments/followers in their account/profile!
Especially comments!

"Or someone get 10,000 comment receive 10 steem."

I think that the amount of spam on Steemit is already big enough!
This action would increase it more! Much more! So this is not a good idea in my opinion.
A lot of posts are receiving meaningless comments, like "Nice post!" and other similar spam-like comments.
I see a lot of posts with spam comments only and these comments have no positive values. These comments just showing the ignorance of the authors of the comments. These comments are ruining the community on Steemit.

Quality over quantity.

The quality should be the primary goal on Steemit, not the quantity!
Only this way Steemit are able to keep and increase it's values! I mean Steem and Steem Dollars (SBD).
Especially in the long run!

If you reward spam comments, then that will bring down the value of Steemit. The value of Steem and Steem Dollars (SBD).
I could only repeat myself: Especially in the long run!

But if @steemitboard would have enough Steem Power, then they could cast worthy upvotes to everyone with a reached milestone.

I am sure that the owners of Steemit and the @steemitboard account will think twice (or more), before they change anything in the rewards.

This is my opinion. Thank you for reading!

Merry Christmas and Happy New Year!

Sort:  

not all the comments have to be rewarded, comments with sertain amount of words and without links and they don't have to be similar, programs can control that by the way !

I don't think that my comment will be the one, which change the minds of Utopian moderators about approving your post. It is their decision, if they are approving your post or not.
Every Utopian post is open for discussion/debating/arguing.
I think that these rewards would make Steemit more complicated.

  • Who would decide, which is a high quality comment?
  • Who would decide these certain words that you are mentioned above?
  • If a spammer decides to write full sentences in one bot-like comment, then how (can?) a program can distinguish these comments from the original, quality, authentic comments?

Not all of the meaningful comments gets upvotes, but I think the community is already rewarding the meaningful, original, quality, authentic comments.

However I completely agree with your basic idea of increasing the Steem Power amount in the @steemitboard account. That would be good for the community.

whales will decide what to reward and how to do it, I am also a little fish like you ☺

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.16
JST 0.029
BTC 62241.82
ETH 2433.73
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.57