You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Steemit and "The Crab Mentality"

in #steemit7 years ago

First of all I will say, I am not a believer in 'everybody should get an equal amount'. That would be ridiculous because some people put very little effort into what they do, while others put a great deal of effort. Though you also need to take into account the effort of engagement. Some people might make more on a post that took less effort to create simply because of the other efforts they have made to write thoughtful, encouraging, helpful comments to others in the community.
While I agree the initiation of the whale experiment was executed poorly since no one knew what the hell was going on and therefore it just seemed they were suddenly being attacked, I think the reason you've seen a change in the outlook of the experiment is not because they're in a crab mentality, it's because it is now understood, and people are excited about their voting power actually amounting to something.
Remember, before this began a lot of people were angry and upset over steemguild and whale autovoting, of the same people being in the top trending regardless of the quality of their content.
I have almost exactly the same amount of people voting on my stuff as before, the only difference is I no longer receive the whale votes...and my last two posts have made three times as much as before. Because the people who read/support my posts have voting power that is worth more than before and they upvote at a hundred percent rather than the autowhale votes that were at a much smaller percent, plain and simple.
I wish that you would have written a post about something else, I would have been happy to send you steem. But this unfortunately just feels like you've taken on a negative mindset that you not only don't wish to change, but you also want to spread. I think people have grown weary of feeling negative about steemit, with one drama after another for a month, and having a change right now is just what most people needed to renew their faith in the platform.
I would actually say that crab mentality applies more to people who find change difficult, who don't like to have things shaken up a bit.

On a personal note, I would challenge you to alter your experiment by writing a post that has nothing whatsoever to do with your feelings about steemit, but rather something that you enjoy and then ask what you've asked in this post. I know I for one would send you steem if you did that.

Sort:  

I would do this, curious about it too. Thanks :)

I am really glad to hear that! I refrain from powering up a portion of steem for just these types of events :) And I apologize if my response seemed harsh in any way, as I believe you are a good man and I still appreciate the challenge you initiated in January that has continued to positively effect my posting habits to this day.

No worries :) I do not experience any burnout, by the way. Life has been a bit bumpy during the last few months, but it's all for the good. As for Steemit, I've been, as you said - and I thank you for acknowledging that - a positive contributor to the platform. I'm just exercising my judgment towards putting more resources into something that took a downward trend. One thing that I harshly learned during the last few months is that I need to have more clearly defined limits in everything I do or I commit myself to do.

On a personal note, I would challenge you to alter your experiment by writing a post that has nothing whatsoever to do with your feelings about steemit, but rather something that you enjoy and then ask what you've asked in this post. I know I for one would send you steem if you did that.

Really great idea and solid advice.

I appreciate that. I have noticed a number of people shifting focus to things other than the good/bad/ of steemit, and it's a refreshing change :)

Loading...

Until some things really straighten up (proper tag usage, subcommunities), the targeted audience of your (my, everyone's) general blog posts will be lost in a sea of other posts. For example, I'd like to read and write about IoT, but this isn't the time or the place to do it efficiently so we are constrained either by exploring the Steem(it) experiment, writing about it, or few other topics that are already established like crypto, photography, or fiction...

I can't agree with that, since I've literally only written posts about steemit probably four times since I began here three months ago. It really has more to do with getting to know people, engagement is truly key.

I know what you're saying, people that you know and that know you will support your writing no matter what it is (in theory), but that's not the point. It works at the level Steem is right now, since there's maybe about 3,000 users really active around. The true success is for you to be able to reach an audience that is directly interested in what you're saying (topic, idea, solution) or for you to get specific information that is in your interest.
Yes, you can build a following with people that have similar interests and check out the same topics but that is scarce right now and it drives a lot of people away due to not matching.

You may be right, though I would say constant posts about steemit's issues would be something that would not appeal to new users. When I first joined it happened to be at a time when people were posting a huge variety of different topics, which is what made this place exciting to me. And if the number of users did drastically increase so would the likelihood of there being more people interested in the topics you write about.

True, a negative attitude is not something that will get any of us anywhere. We can treat issues with responsibility and transparency in an effort to find solutions. Directly said: constant bitching about Steemit won't help :)

Ah, yep, haha! :) Thanks for the follow, followed you back ;)

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.15
JST 0.028
BTC 59449.45
ETH 2406.65
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.43