Censorship: Why All Blockchain Projects Should Join Steem (especially Status)

in #steem2 years ago (edited)

When we at Steemit originally decided to go down this path, we were motivated partly by our fears about what results from centralized control over information. The problem with closed and centralized systems is not that they are populated by evil people--it’s that closed and centralized systems are systematically flawed because people are flawed.

The Problem With Centralized Content Platforms

As long as anyone controls any platform, their flaws will become expressed in the system. If anyone, for example, controls what can and cannot be posted, then they will control what can and cannot be posted as evidenced by the actions of Twitter, Facebook, and now Medium. When faced with something they do not understand, they will be incapable of dealing with it appropriately, for as Upton Sinclair once said, “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”

Since we released and open-sourced the Steem blockchain protocol over two years ago, followed closely by steemit.com (our flagship Steem application), things have certainly changed a lot, but not for the better. This was demonstrated in a recent post by the Status team, a blockchain project that is building a mobile operating system for Ethereum.

Censorship on Medium

In the Status team’s own words:

Recently, we attempted to publish a blog post announcing our latest Bug Bounty Program. The post was immediately suspended, followed by an automated email noting a general violation, without detailing any specifics, and a link to Medium’s recently updated policy regarding cryptocurrencies. Though we had not violated any of these policies, we re-submitted several revisions that carefully edited out any potential trigger words, like “bounty,” “ETH,” and “SNT.” The post was never successfully published.

Like the Status team, we too are concerned about the “creeping censorship around cryptocurrencies,” which only validates our initial motivations for embarking on this journey and why we want to wholeheartedly invite all blockchain projects, not just Status, to Steem - whether it’s through steemit.com, busy.org, dlive.io, or one of the many other user-interface DApps that have now been built to leverage Steem’s Decentralized Content Management System and Decentralized Reward Distribution Mechanism (Proof-of-Brain). Steem remains the only blockchain autonomously rewarding content creators and has distributed over $40 million worth of rewards to users all over the world since its launch.

Steemit.com is the #1 site for user-generated content relating to blockchain technology, but in addition to that, posting through any Steem interface makes your content available to all Steem interfaces, so that you are not beholden to any single platform. Finally, because Steem is a decentralized blockchain, it remains censorship-resistant, meaning your content is safe and not controlled by anyone.

We Believe in Blockchain

As one of the most mature projects in the space, we have proven through action that we believe in blockchain, cryptocurrency, decentralization, and censorship resistance. That’s why we want every project, regardless of whether they are powered by Steem, to feel welcome on this platform we have created. Of course, even if we didn’t want you, there’s nothing we could do to keep you from posting and even earning STEEM! That’s the beauty of decentralization.

So join us, Status! Because just like you:

We want our society to be freer for everyone. We believe the forces of censorship and centralization are often closely bound and we worry when we see the power to freely express ourselves so arbitrarily limited.

If the people at Status--or any other blockchain project--want to communicate with Steemit, Inc. they can e-mail us at [email protected] They can also sign up for a free Steem blockchain account via https://signup.steemit.com/ and start posting their content via steemit.com as soon as their account is approved.

We look forward to having you here!

Team Steemit

Sort:  

Preventing censorship is very important and I think we're all with you there. Decentralization is a critical element. Other projects should be joining Steem for sure. That said, if everything is left up to the masses, then abusers (scammers, spammers, bidbots, etc.) will fill that void and destroy the user experience for those masses fairly quickly, as we've seen here. With a few simple tweaks by the benevolent entity that operates this site, it could be a lot more fun for a lot more people to use.

Steem should be decentralized; Steemit should use some common sense to better manage its site for the vast majority of the users.

Indeed.

The problem with closed and centralized systems is not that they are populated by evil people--it’s that closed and centralized systems are systematically flawed because people are flawed.

Same applies even more strongly to decentralized systems. Indeed, it empowers the most flawed people to run amok with their abuse, crime and scams, with no laws or checks in place. Neither @donkeypong nor I really need to point out the overwhelming amount of evidence for Steemians only behaving in their own self-interests, rather than making Steem a valuable content creation and curation platform.

With centralized systems, there's always competition where the less flawed systems has the potential to win. I hope that's exactly what Communities and SMT will achieve here on Steem.

Beyond that, there needs to be some basic common sense measures to better organize Steemit.com to be better for discovering valuable content. Remember, what consumers really want is creating and consuming good content.

there's that line again: 'good content'. that's surely in the eye of the beholder in a world of free speech. it implies some element of control needed over the 'bad' content.

A lot of the content on youtube has great content, but it's not got the most views. You've got to make a personal effort to engage with a certain kind of 'good' content that is good for you, that informs you, or rewards you outside of it, in the real world.

Agreed, what is good or bad depends on objectivity, not subjectivity. It depends on who makes the rules, on who the judges are. If we are our own judges of each other's content, comments, etc, then we all determine, define, what is good content and what is bad content like you said, in the eye of the beholder, with all doing what is right in his or her own eyes as mentioned in the Bible before the time of the Judges.

there are criteria you could write down to help define what is good or bad content, but this would only go in a certain direction. It's better for bad content. Good content could be informational, but not popular or engaging. Not so easy.

An interesting article. I subscribed to you. Subscribe to me, we will be friends

Hi @liberosist, I have found Steemit Inc. not interested in doing anything to remove the recently discovered flaws with Steemit. I have almost left the platform due to its inherent and persistent flaws. Platform was good. The people behind it let it be ruined. I am here because of the sane voices like yours.

When I joined Steemit in June 2017, I found it to be a gift economy. It has, for best part of last 7-8 months, turned into a bad user experience after invasion of bots. Steemit is not for the masses anymore, I feel.

On behalf of @buildteam I wish to say that we appreciate this official communication inviting all crypto to join Steem, we feel the same and our objective is to help onboard new and existing ICO's onto Steem. This official message will be useful in such future engagements to help further promote Steem. Future positive communication from Steemit like this in future is welcome.

Loading...

This is a great idea and will hopefully lead to some cooperation and partnerships that will help crypto and blockchain projects increase use case and aid mainstreaming.

Yes and I am glad to see that Steemit is reaching out! With EOS social happening soon, we have to do everything we can toi promote SMTs and hivemind communities.. we MUST promote steem, to Reddit 4chan instagram and youtube comments and just go CRAZY promoting steem with quotas and massive amounts of reward pool Diverted to promoting steem on legacy social media with its billions ofusers! imagine we CAn have quarter of a billion users liek reddit but MORE cuz reddit is cool but STOPS being intersting after a point while Steem KEEPS going and is ALWAYS FOREVER interestingc uz WE get to BUILD stuff on Reddit its CLOSED but on STEEM its OIPEN

so yeah man WOOOOOO

We have decided to curate this post with our Steemvoter (SV) Guild; @buildteam and @steemvoter stands in solidarity with the concept of unifying crypto on the Steem blockchain.

Note: You should receive many guild votes shortly to assist with visibility of this post!

This is pretty interesting! It would be pretty cool to have multiple blockchain projects work around here and post their news here instead of sites like medium or twitter that are further censoring crypto currencies, here we have a true space for freedom of speech and every project should feel welcomed here! Just like @mannacurrency was quickly loved and accepted by all steemians! They even saw an amazing growth in their user base after joining Steem and I'm pretty sure that if any legit project decides to make their home here, the results will be the same.

The New Colossus

Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
“Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!” cries she
With silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”

We agree! There are already a number of projects leveraging Steem, but there's always room for more!

We also want to reach out where a lot of people are on places like Twitter because a lot of people are still there.

Amazing timing. My latest blog post talked about the most important aspect of blockchain and cryptocurrency is decentralization. This is what we need to drive home to the masses...the future of humanity is freedom and that can only be achieved through decentralization.

Anything that is centralized is subject to being taken over. It is really that simple. Not all in centralized systems are evil but an evil one will use a centralized system.

I applaud the efforts of the development team to put this idea out there. Promoting STEEM as a decentralized platform is a great idea. I hope this article goes viral throughout the entire internet. It would be great for other developers/projects to see what this blockchain offers.

STEEM is a diamond in the rough as they say. It will not be an undiscovered gem forever.

Time to get on board.

I'm pretty sure if legit projects come, they will be all embraced here, just like Manna was!

They actually have an account here, assuming legit: @status-im

We all should join Steemit.
Looking forward to the release of Steemit media tokens

While I cannot deny the fact that this article is fantastic and well written, I still cannot ignore the fact that there is no true decentralization on Steemit at the moment. In fact, there is a centralization within the decentralization. How do I mean?

At the moment, the whales can flag a minnow into extinction. This means that a whale can censor what he or she wants and does not want. In the end, Steemit has degenerated into a platform where all animals are equal but some are more equal than the others. We claim to be decentralized but we are intolerant.

We must stop flagging by voter power, otherwise we will make a primitive empire out of our beloved Steemit. I trust this meets you well.

That's not quite the same thing as decentralization in this case, however. I know what you mean — it can be intimidating to think that a higher rep can adjust your rewards and penalize your own rep with a heavy flag... but this still doesn't truly censor you. The posts you make are in the chain, for good. Even with a negative rep and UI hidden posts or comments, your followers, and anyone else, can still find the entirety of your work in the STEEM blockchain, forever, just as you put it there. This really isn't true of many other social media, which can disappear any trace of you or your intellectual property at any time.

The flagging and rep system are both tools designed to help our community try to decide on and enforce common societal rules and values, but they are not perfect. There has been a lot of discussion on how to improve these tools, and I think we'll see some positive changes to both over time. While it may feel like true censorship to be flagged, just remember that absolutely nothing and no one can take your work out of the chain and away from the people who are looking for it!

Thanks for this new perspective. Sounds convincing.

Agreed, Steemit seeks for checks and balances. I like the competition of Steemit and cryptocurrencies in general. Free markets can be tough but I like them.

Yes you are right, steemit is actually not decentralised. It is in fact a company registered in NY. So that is an avenue of attack, however the blockchain itself is decentralised. It's on computers all around the world and even if China, Russia and the US got together to unplug all of those computers steem would continue.

I don't know of a portal into the steem bc (busy/steemit/zappl and many more) that is not decentralised. However, with not too much technical skill we can all build our own portal in. It won't be as polished as the above but the functionality is there for all of us and that cannot easily be taken away.

The whales, whilst they have a lot of power, are not centralisation. They are points with a large amount of power but they cannot dictate what you do or write. All they can do is make it harder to find you. Youtube and FB on the other hand can literally stop your content. BTW technically steemit/busy etc can also can also dictate what you see however that would not last long at all.

Governments and corporations are single entities. Each whale is for the most part a different entity with their own ideas and ways of thinking. They might come together on issues but it's not the same as a government or corporation.

Thing is, the whales have to be careful because if they are irresponsible they risk losing everything overnight. That's millions of dollars they can blow if they are too douchie. So it behooves them to take right action. And if one or two whales jeopardise the system it is definitely in the interest of the other whales to correct that. This is one of the philosophies behind steem's voting system and is covered in the white paper.

Agreed, I prefer Steemit over Facebook and even Gab and Minds. I wonder if there are videos or articles on how people can plug directly into the Steem.IO blockchain, to post, or even to design platforms. Like you said, we have Steemit, Busy.org, Dlive, Dtube, and other Steem apps, but I may want to design my own app. We all may want to do that.

check the tuts in this channel
https://discord.gg/VuQeC4
steemdevs on discord

Yes the info is all out there. But it's not neatly gathered hence it's difficult but therein lies opportunity.

Yeah, Steemit can be tough, but do you make money on Facebook? I make money on Steemit. I like that. Facebook deleted my Hitler photo. I don't think Steemit has ever removed anything of mine and Steemit probably can't delete my photos, either, or so I've been told.

why the steem price is getting down if more peoples are still holding steem power then why sudden price drop so much is this steem power holding a virtual nor real

I think it is all the self-voting of comments that are unrelated to the content and difficult to understand.

care to explain the joke? What is "wowzers" referring to? I want to smile too :)

lol took me a moment.

Downvoting a bit because this is kind of off topic for the post, and I don’t believe it is the best “top” comment for what this post is trying to achieve.

@timcliff so you are a witness what you are doing for steem ?

Here is my most recent witness update:
https://steemit.com/witness-category/@timcliff/timcliff-witness-update-2018-05-22

Since that update I have been doing a lot of things, but two of my bigger projects have been:

Because bitcoin is going down. It still seems to be the case that if bitcoin goes up or down by and large all other cryptos do. There might be an anomaly here and there but basically they float on the same waves.

Over time though, like a year, some cryptos diverge.

Because Bitcoin follows the dollar, at least for now, but that is changing as Bitcoin grows and becomes more independent of the dollar and other fiat.

I think that BTC and many cryptos were in a huge bubble. I don't know how one can definitively say that as it's hard to value cryptos however that is what people are saying. And I think that if enough believe it then it is a bubble. So based on that a correction was always going to happen Question is how much.

Did the dark webs die? Government tries to stop the dark webs in the same ways they try to stop drugs, cryptocurrencies, beer, through prohibitions, through making things illegal, etc.

That's why we support consensus instead of censorship on the internet of value.

A world where one single centralized entity decides on which content should be seen and which shouldn't, definitely belongs to the past.

The future is decentralized.
Thanks for spreading the word, Team Steemit.

Decentralization is an Inverted Borg System. Love it.

I Love Steem since it is censorship free
and much more because even the post owner cannot delete the comments added.

In other social media,
the post owners have the right to delete the unwanted comments added,
and by this some can manipulate the facts and deceive and propaganda others.

In Steem, it it not possible.
Steem is Very fair platform where anyone can make opposing opinions shown to whoever's post.
I love Steem the most because of this feature.

Centralized businesses are in panic mode, terrified of Crypto and of the future, which is where this censorship comes from.

Twitter would seem to be the least censored centralized platform for discussing Crypto, but it's hardly conducive to coherent organized thought.

I agree that Steemit and Steem blockchain platforms are the best solution to the censorship problem.

Twitter told me I was a Russian bot. Facebook deleted my Hitler photo.

What kind of post is this? Your new terms of service literally say you will kick people off of Steemit for violating laws of their home country, and that you will obey EU laws(which newsflash has huge censorship issues).

What a joke.

If you want to help stop censorship of cryptocurrencies then Join the Global Class Action Against Facebook & Google's Crypto Ad Ban 👿

Its was Facebook's Crypto Ad Ban that started this censorship craze. It is illegal and anti-competitive and we're suing them for it and need your help.
Its No Win No Fee. So no reason not to join.

See https://steemit.com/cryptocurrency/@apshamilton/we-re-suing-facebook-and-google-for-usd300-billion-want-a-part-of-the-action

EU Bans Memes. Can we stop the EU & the NWO?

I do like the fact that steem is censor resistant and as all the centralised platform step up their control of what can be posted steem can definitely shine.
Then all they will have to do is buy their way to the trending page.

Agreed. Free markets. Competition is good.

One of the big advantages of steem besides the reward system, is that steemit is censorship resistant and that gives the ability for people and companies to share their toughts and views without fear and doubts that their post will be suspended.

Agreed. Upvoted.

Agreed. Upvoted.

Decentralized just in name.. fully centralized by Steemit Inc but behind the shadows

Email sent! Thanks for making this post.

Edit: After I sent the email I remembered another great decentralized app Bisq that features Steem but not SBD https://markets.bisq.network/, not sure if this is fully on their end or just the nature of open source projects that no one is getting regular pay to do all the hard work they do.

I wish both @Shapeshiftio and @Changelly kept Steem AND SBD as part of their daily trading pairs but they always seem to drop off. I have nothing but love for @Blocktrades and use them often, however I believe the benefit of having choices is the best.

Does anyone know why we don't have steem/sbd on more exchanges? I don't get it. Steem has much more intrinsic value than most other cryptos, it's proven and the process of moving tokens is so simple.

The bigger and better steem and steemit become the better for us.

So I'm all for it.

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

To claim that we are censorship resistant media - we need to drop the flag option. Then we will be absolutely free of censorship.

Although I have above opinion- still I also believe that steem is much much better than any other available platform.

Really? I'm 100% for being open, transparant and censorship-resistant. But don't you guys think teams and organizations like Status might be somewhat reluctant to post on Steem due to fear of "downvoting for aggrandizement"?

It seems a great idea. Why not diversify earning and attract more bees to the hive. Just some things have to be looked at carefully and that is security and in light of omsoc's recent loss it should be at the top of the list as he has not been the only one.

Great Message. I like it, we welcome you to Steem! Nice potential branding.

Steemit would be a great alternative to Medium, the problem is that we have no search function and blog filter other than tags which makes it for many people a non pleasant user experience. Rolling these basic features out should be a top priority to get writers and large projects use Steemit instead of Medium.

Nice innotive thought i must say...That is the real truth...Cooperation and unity will really help in this...Thank you sir for the information

What is status? I know minds should join. And steemit should improve the front end. Make the theme look like a newspaper. I love steemit but man its butt ugly compared to others like say, Medium.

Shared on twitter. Stephen

#Promo-Steem #JoinSteemit

Open Invitation to ALL Blockchain Projects worldwide to come and join Steemit. Witness firsthand the sheer brute force and power of the #STEEM Blockchain. #Cryptocurrency #Blockchain #Steem #Steemit

https://twitter.com/StephenPKendal/status/1011351850107404288

20180625_215638.png

You make a good case for the Steem blockchain! No complains from my part. At least not here, not now. Overall, Steem has been, is and probably will be great!

How topical. I'm using Medium (so "pre-blockchain") as a background for a wider reflection on blockchain evolution and impacts in my last post: "Why Blockchain Is a Revolution

The problem with closed and centralized systems is not that they are populated by evil people--it’s that closed and centralized systems are systematically flawed because people are flawed.

this comes off as self-jerk to justify why steemit inc have turned a blind eye and deaf ear to the concerns being raised by just about the only group of people who cares about the welfare of this platform more than their wallet. BTW, the numbers are diminishing by the day because i dont know they aren't jesus christ?

if we go by the math in this statement, it means this decentralized experiment is going to be a flaw-fest then.

lol see how you guys are yapping, beckoning Status to hop on a train whose seats has and is still being infested by fat feral rats with no end in sight because ned's oracles are taking longer than a nine-months pregnant woman to come forth.

Spotcoin & Golden Fleece

Spotcoin and Golden Fleece are both from Georgia. Golden Fleece are mining experts, taking full advantage of the abundance of cheap hydropower in Georgia. Spotcoin has an established OTC, and offers liquidity for mined coins

https://medium.com/spotcoin/spotcoin-golden-fleece-deb137dfeb68

1_0lT0C82yQc-rRjVsmE-nZw.png

Since when does Steemit promote censorship resistance? Pretty much no one cares about it and nothing is made to highlight that this is the real function of a blockchain.

My initial bet on Steem was that by 2020, there would be a prominent newspaper that would publish its article on Steem. Now I don't think that anymore.

Also, I want to point out that the downvoting @ned was doing on @dan's article about EOS were pretty much censorship, whatever @ned gaves as an excuse. So yeah you can get censored on Steem, reduce to slicence and not so many people will know how to read your words

Censorship means removed, generally. So, a downvote (flag) can reduce rewards, ranking, reputation, visibility, completely, or to some extent, but the blockchain is said to be designed to keep the content there. For example, you can still Google it, search it, look it up using Duck Duck Go or other search engines to find Steemit comments, posts, even after they are flagged a lot. I try not to flag people. I don't like flags. Maybe, votes and likes should be kept separate.

Having crypto to join steem is a good ideal more people believe and preferred steemit than any other plat form.

I am an example of such persond😄

very intiristing

While I cannot deny the fact that this article is fantastic and well written, I still cannot ignore the fact that there is no true decentralization on Steemit at the moment. In fact, there is a centralization within the decentralization. How do I mean?

At the moment, the whales can flag a minnow into extinction. This means that a whale can censor what he or she wants and does not want. In the end, Steemit has degenerated into a platform where all animals are equal but some are more equal than the others. We claim to be decentralized but we are intolerant.

We must stop flagging by voter power, otherwise we will make a primitive empire out of our beloved Steemit. I trust this meets you well.

Voting power motivates us to grow, does it not?

No one can deny that the Steem platform is awesome! Thanks to blockchain technology, the interface allows every content manager to discuss catchy topics and share their knowledge. The platform is here to stay, as well as the blockchain. In Blockbasis we recognized this a long time back, so we developed our platform, Blockbasis, where users can send and receive cryptocurrency like Bitcoin, Ethereum and more with just an email address. Besides sending and receiving via email, users can exchange cryptocurrency on our DEX.

Catchy for sure. Like catching fish, food for thought.

I promote Steemit and I believe in depravity, AKA flawness. I love the platforms, the apps of Steem, including Busy and Dlive.

Everyone should join steem, not only is it an all round worth while experience its a platform that encourages good content and also content providers by its decentralized blockchain platform its secure and you control your world too. Looking forward to awesome innovations on this platform.

Great initiative @andrarchy and @steemitblog !
The more platforms realize about censorship and the more get directly censored by medium, facebook and others, will start coming to Steem. The global decentralized communication place that welcomes every other blockchain!

Regards, @gold84

Steem’s... Decentralized Reward Distribution Mechanism (Proof-of-Brain).

It appears to me that steem developers still have work to do to bring trust to proof of brain. The thought was discussed in a recent blog post of mine; whose link is included for your reading pleasure.

https://steemit.com/steem-network/@novacadian/where-is-the-trust-in-proof-of-brain-mining

A solution to abate the creation of counterfeit steem was proposed, in a more recent post, by developing a decentralized anonymous CAPCHA system. The link to the post is included below for your reading pleasure.

https://steemit.com/steem/@novacadian/a-decentralized-capcha-annonymous-proof-of-brain-verification

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.02
BTC 9197.75
ETH 238.37
USDT 1.00
SBD 1.00