Debunk-Tuesday – The Big Water Fraud
Every Tuesday I am going to address one specific myth, urban legend, conspiracy theory or piece of pseudo-science. This time we dive into the shady business of water “revitalization”.
How is this even, wait, what?
Ah. Water. The essence of life. And for making tons of money with useless junk.
Wait, what?
Yeah, you read correctly. There is a whole industry dedicated to the sole purpose of relieving you of your hard-earned money by selling you worthless garbage as miracle technology. I’m speaking of the pseudoscientific claims of revitalizing or energising water, most notoriously the so-called Grander water (1). As Abraham Lincoln once said: “This is an amazing example, that you shouldn’t believe everything you read on the internet.”
According to their statements, the Grander-family's company is selling Grander Water (how original, duh). So, what is it, exactly?
I have added a picture, so you can have a basic understanding of what you are dealing with.
The “normal” water is poured into a machine with a metal cylinder which contains the so-called Information Water. The normal and “unstructured” water flows past the cylinder and while this is happening, the Information Water passes on information (I have no idea which kind of information and I doubt, they have one either) to the normal water. According to Grander Water Technology this process changes the waters’ inner structure (because fuck chemistry), revitalizes and energises the former normal water into Grander Water. Claimed benefits are for example detoxification (doesn’t this remind me of something…?), killing bacteria, reducing surface tension, absorbing less UV light and promoting plant growth.
As you may already have guessed, none of the claims are backed by scientific studies. Quite the contrary.
Nothing but fraud
If you are a dedicated follower of this blog, you will already know that the idea of detoxification of your body is utter nonsense. Although sometimes it might be important to detoxify other things than your body. Contaminated water, for example. There are, of course, ways to purify water of toxins and waste – but Grander Water is not one of them. According to the Austrian Federal Institute of Water Quality (2), the promises made by the distributing company are simply wrong.
The same holds true for the other claims. Hammer (2014) (3) wrote in his thesis, that there is no evidence for any improvement of water hygiene on a microbiological level. I could go on with this, but you get the point.
The market for junk science associated to water products is quite extensive. To give you some idea, you could check this list (4) for example. Although I just focused a bit on the Grander Water there are many other companies trying to lure unsuspecting customers into their arms. Famous claims of water companies trying to sell garbage technology are (5):
Water has a memory and is able to save information
Not a single study was able to show anything close to being a “water memory”.Transmissions of unknown vibrations of (energised) water to humans
For esoteric people/companies everything somehow vibrates (how and why they fail to explain, though). And these vibrations are always good, thus transmit them to humans is awesome as well. Problem is: there are indeed real molecule vibrations, but they have nothing to do with any kind of esoteric vibrations and associated (health) benefits.Water can be energised/revitalized and is able to pass this energy to another water
Science is quite aware of the possible reactions of water in connection to energy injection (e. g: thermal motion, ionisation, plasma creation). Since it is not clearly defined by the selling companies what “energising” actually means, it’s most probably useless nonsense anyway.Improved Water leads to positive reactions in your body
One of the most powerful effects in pseudo-science is the placebo-effect. In short: You expect a treatment to work and to feel better, so you actually feel better after the treatment – no matter if the treatment was in fact just something without any medical ingredient. This is the reason why so many people will tell you, that their Grander Water or whatever they bought really worked – because they want it to. In addition to that, they need a reason to justify their decision to avoid cognitive dissonance (the misbalance of thoughts and behaviour). Or how would you feel, if you just paid a couple of thousand bucks only to realize, that your life-changing machine is a complete useless piece of junk? You really WANT this thing to work as intended.
Keep on fighting
But why is it so successful, then?
Because many people lack a basic understanding of science, yet alone physics and chemistry. Granders’ family business makes about 12 million euros in sales – just because people don’t understand, what they are actually buying.
I have to admit, I kind of acknowledge their ability to sell their product so well, despite all the existing evidence which brands it as fraud. In fact, in 2006 a High Court in Vienna stated, that "Grander technology and/or the Grander water are nothing but pseudoscientific humbug." (6)
Ouch.
Another one? Sure. The responsible retailer for Grander Water in New Zealand had to pay $136,000 as compensation. Grander Water Technology’s marketing department was even able to fool the Austrian Government and the Russian Academy of Natural Science, which both awarded Johann Grander, the inventor of this “revolutionary technology”, with scientific honours. Well played, indeed (8).
Again, people don’t seem to bother that much. Honestly, I can’t really understand why. I tried to, I really did, but even my ability of understanding has its limits.
In the end, for me it serves as a constant reminder, that I cannot give up. That I will keep on fighting for more logic, reason and science. As long as these companies exist selling worthless junk, I will call them out – and you should too.
Feel always free to discuss my ideas and share your own thoughts about the things I’m writing about. Nobody is omniscient and if we all walk away a bit smarter than before, we’ll have achieved a lot.
Thanks for reading and stay smart.
Ego
Make sure, to check out #steemstem for more science related content.
References
(1) https://medium.com/@GranderWater/how-does-grander-water-work-b89077f807d0
(2) Gutachten über die Wirkung des Geräts „Wasserbelebung 380“ der Umwelt-Vertriebs-Organisation auf Testwässer. Bundesanstalt für Wassergüte, Österreich, 25. Juni 1993
(3) Rudolf Hammer: Untersuchung von Effekten in energetisiertem Wasser unter Berücksichtigung ausgewählter mikrobiologischer, physikalischer und pflanzenphysiologischer Aspekte. In: Diplomarbeit am Institut für Hygiene und Medizinische Mikrobiologie, Abteilung für Wasserhygiene, Universität für Bodenkultur Wien.
(4) http://www.chem1.com/CQ/gallery.html
(5) http://www.aktuelle-wochenschau.de/main-navi/archiv/wasserchemie-2014/kw10-das-wasser-zwischen-wissenschaft-und-esoterik.html
(6) Urteil des Oberlandesgerichts Wien Az. 4 R 1/06f vom 17. August 2006
(7) Living Water quackery results in $136,000 payout. Neuseeländische Commerce Commission, 26. Juli 2005
(8) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Grander
Previous posts
Random Science
- Freedom is not a choice
- How meat can change the world
- Glyphosate will not kill you
- Peak Performance - Go with the Flow
- Hangover - A Scientific Guide for Better Mornings
Your Weight is not Your Destiny
- Your weight is not your destiny - Part I
- Your weight is not your destiny - Part II
- Your weight is not your destiny - Part III
- Your weight is not your destiny - Part IV
- Your weight is not your destiny - Part V
Random Thoughts
Psychology of Morality
- Psychology of morality - A story of drowning children, prisoners and ethical monkeys
- Psychology of morality - mirror, mirror on the wall
- Psychology of morality - Hell is other people
Debunk-Tuesday
- The Myth of Multitasking
- Sleep less, achieve more?
- Does Alcohol Kill Brain Cells?
- The Truth about Detox Diets
This series is really the mythbuster of Steemit, I really enjoyed reading this piece @egotheist
Have a nice day!
Luca ✌️
This comment has received a 19.98 % upvote from @webdeals thanks @bafi; Please remember that only posts/comments written between 30 minutes and 4days 23h and 30 minutes will be voted.
Immagine CC0 Creative Commons, si ringrazia @mrazura per il logo ITASTEM.
CLICK HERE AND VOTE FOR DAVINCI.WITNESS
Greetings from @davinci.witness and the itaSTEM team.
I have to show my wife this article as she likes to buy bottled water! H2O is H2O, and the stuff out the tap is just as good as the expensive bottled water.
Fun fact: Depending on where you are living, tap water is actually better than bottled water, because it gets checked daily for any kind of contaminations :)
Compliments for the good job, ironic but prickly.I am an Italian boy of the team Davinci.witness, that care and search the best scentific posts, if have like you can come to find us on the channel discord. a regard @ journalist
I discussed a lot with him recently, and he agreed that it really depends on the types of websites we are browsing. Some blogs are most likely to spread fake information than others.
I got my degree by YouTube-University - so I'm protected against any kind of fake information anyway.
As I said, it depends on which youtube-website you got your degree. Lincoln is 200% positive about it. I just rechecked!
Being A SteemStem Member
Can not deny the benefit from water, right?
Yes.. i thought about the placebo effect when people drink so called "energised water" and actually see improvement. however, this effect is only happened in 5 to 10% test cases?
What about so called experiments where by plants were watered with regular tap water vs energised water.. and the enegrised one results in higher yields?
or that pipes doesnt rust over time with the said "Grander water" vs regular water?
I must say, the science(pseudo science) in Grander water (or similar type ideas)... is hard to explain or perhaps not proven in science. So we can only see observation and outcomes/results of said product. If we say human subjects are subjected to Placebo, then we can test it in animal subjects? give two types of water for animals in the farm to drink, and let them choose.... results in such experiments can be observed and tabulated. The problem is the marketing hype by these companies, i do not know if they are real or not.. no one did any independent studies on the effects (if any)