Let’s Talk About Race 인종에 대하여 이야기 해봅시다
[English][한국어][日本語]
The flipped and switched perspectives on race spread
Chris Buck the famed photographer, released a photo series with O, The Oprah Magazine, called, “Let’s Talk About Race.”
Asian women getting pedicures from white women.
A white girl standing in front of an aisle full of only black dolls.
A Latina woman getting a beverage poured by a white maid.
Chris Buck said: I was actually surprised when I moved here how little talk of race there was. It’s been happening for a long time. Who are we kidding? My grandchildren will be talking about this still.
I think it's time for “Let’s Talk About Race,” like the title of these pictures.
[한국어]
미국의 유명 사진작가 크리스 벅이 오프라 매거진과 '인종에 대해 이야기 해봅시다' 라는 주제로 사진3장을 연재했습니다.
첫번째 사진에서는 아시아인들이 서양인들에거 패디큐어를 받고 있네요. 또다른 사진에서는 백인 여자아이가 흑인인형으로 가득차있는 진열대 앞에서 인형을 고르고 있구요, 세번째 사진에서는 라틴계 여성이 백인메이드에게 시중을 받고 있습니다.
위에 세 사진을 보고 어떤 생각이 드셨나요?
사진의 제목처럼 '우리도 인종에 대하여 이야기해 볼 시간' 인거 같네요.
[日本語]
アメリカの写真家クリスバク氏が「人種について話してみよう」っていうテーマで３つの写真をオペラメガージンに連科しました。
1番目の写真にはアジアの女性たちが西洋人にペディキュアをもらってます。2番目は白人の女の子が黒人人形しかない店だなの前で人形を選んでいます。３番目の写真はラティーノ女性が白人のメイドからお茶をもらってます。
この３つの写真を見て何を感じましたか？
この写真のテーマみたいに、これから人種について話して見る時間だと思います。
저의 포스팅이 좋으셨다면 투표와 팔로우는 라멘걸도 춤추게 합니다^^
If you liked my posting please upvote & follow me. Thank you!
Please Follow @ramengirl
I disagree.
Picture: I think asian people do have better knowledge in stuff like messages. Many of the spa methods are unknown in historic european and american cultures.
Also nobody is forcing asian people to work in a pedicure salon and many asian people in america are rich enough to actually get one themself.
Barbie was developed in a white society and meant to be a rolemodel for young girls. But I dont want to defend barbie. She is skinny, blonde and artificial, I never liked her. Do not buy Barbie and there will be no Barbie.
The English butler was always known to be the best servant. Being able to make him say anything in that adorable polite english accent <3.
I don't want to be mean. I like you @ramengirl . This topic is just really important to me.
@thegermandude, I have to disagree. I think you're unfairly misconstruing @ramengirl's intentions here.
Are you aware of the relationship between nail salons and human trafficking?
Thousands of asian women are tricked or trafficked into working in nail salons in the US alone.
Correct me if I'm wrong but didn't you just have a long exchange with @dwinblood about how slavery still exists in the US prison system? This is simply another form of modern day slavery.
In my opinion, I don't see this article as being racist. All the artist is doing is to point out that there's a class system in the US and in other western societies that is rarely addressed. It's uncomfortable for people to confront, so they prefer not to engage. I feel the artist here is saying we should have a dialog about race and class. I really don't see anything inherently racist about having a dialog.
Why shouldn't people talk about race?
I think we an all agree that Barbie is a terrible product that perpetuates an impossible body image onto young minds.
No, I was not. And of course I condemn this kind of slavery. Thanks for the hint.
I am glad to talk about. I just didnt want to chant "great article", even though I disagree with the points made.
Guess I need to make a whole post apologizing to @ramengirl and explain what I actually meant to say. One of my main critics about the (oprah) article is how it paddles a "we vs them" mentality by bashing caucasians...
I feel bad that my comment reads like I am trying to insult @ramengirl. That was never my intention. I love trying to be funny that is one of the main reasons I wrote
I will try to avoid cheap puns on serious topics like this in the future.
I think this is all a misunderstanding and doesn't call for self censorship. The way i read the article could very well be very different from the way you intended it to come across.
This made me laugh "chant great article", lol. If you mean the Oprah Magazine article, I would agree with you that most of the publication is pure shite. But there was no link in @ramengirl's post that i could find, just one quote from the artist. I can't speak for @ramengirl, but i don't think she was praising the article, just showing the artwork/photography and posing a question.
I've noticed that you've engaged in insightful commentary more than most who join the platform, that is commendable and i usually enjoy your input. We just disagree here. Happy that you responded to clarify what you meant.
Thanks, mate. I also thank you for your response to my first comment. I was afraid my writing could be understood wrong, so it is good to see you describing a different interpretation of my words. At this point I feel like I furthered the division on this topic which is the polar opposite of what I wanted to do!
I am writing a post to clarify as we speak.
The original oprah article, fyi
https://mic.com/articles/177195/these-three-pictures-make-a-powerful-statement-about-race-and-power-among-women#.lgfp5ftE4
https://steemit.com/society/@thatgermandude/this-article-against-racism-is-racist
Couldnt resist clickbait title ^^*, but I think it helps to understand where I am comimg from.
She actually called all western societies racist?
No, I just said let's talk about race with those pictures. Those are interesting pictures, right? I never said that all western societies racist or westerners are racist. Maybe @thatgermandude's comment made people misunderstood which is I don't really want.
I will try to rephrase. It was never my intention to call you racist. I was just trying to argue against the message portrayed in the article.
I am sorry, I never meant to insult you, @ramengirl. I just wanted to discuss the topic...
I deleted "There are racists out there, no doubt. But an article calling all western societies racist is.... well... racist. :D" out of my initial comment.
I tried to be funny, but being funny is not worth hurting you. I am sorry.
no, and I dont believe that is what ramengirl is thinking. I meant the original oprah article.
Great post on important topic !
Thanks :)
좋은 포스팅 잘 보고 갑니다.
감사합니다 :)
I wrote a post to explain why I dont share the opinion presented in the oprah article.
https://steemit.com/society/@thatgermandude/this-article-against-racism-is-racist
이구 ㅠㅠ 의도치않게 disputable & arguable 한 주제가 되었네요. 의미있는 포스팅 잘 보고갑니당:)
@soojiini님 항상 인종차별에 대한 주제는 논쟁을 불러일으키죠... 제 포스팅의 요지와 같이 사람들이 이 주제로 계속해서 이야기를 나누며 조금씩 나아지길 바라봅니다^^
思い出しました。BBCのインタビューを受けていた釜山大学のロバート・ケリー教授のお部屋に二人の子どもたちが乱入した小さい事件がありましたね。あわててやってきた韓国人のお連れ合いさんのことをnanny?と言って論争になったことがありました。あとで夫婦だとわかったんですよね。でもすてきなご夫婦だと思います。考えさせるポスティングをありがとうございます。
あ！@olga2772さん、ロバート・ケリー教授のも私がポスティングしたことがあります。https://steemit.com/kr/@ramengirl/when-the-kids-crash-your-bbc-interview-that-s-not-the-nanny-bbc あの事件が偏見の問題を代表的に見せてくれた例だと思います。こうして色々な人々が偏見の問題について続けて会話したらいいですね！