Stupid Poor People

in #informationwar5 years ago

Why do poor people do such stupid things? Why do they make such poor choices in life? It's so tragic and so sad; if they would just listen to reason, stop complaining and start to better themselves, everything would be alright.


beggar_small.jpg
Image by Michael Coghlan - source: Flickr

Right? ... We all know them; the beggars, the drifters and the homeless, stumbling through life, getting drunk when they get a dollar instead of buying a loaf of bread... Do they even deserve our pity? And these are just the extremes; there's billions of people that live from bill to bill, with a part time job that could be gone just like that, always uncertain if they'll be able to pay next month's rent.

What's wrong with these people? This seems a harsh question to ask, but there's no disputing the facts; research after research shows that the poorer people are, the most likely they are to eat less healthy, use more alcohol and drugs, smoke more, are more likely to get arrested, get thrown out of school more often, watch more TV and exercise less, read less and are more likely to be illiterate, and we could go on a good wile here.

Still, it is wrong to ask what's wrong with these people. And a self-help book, pointing to the "power of the mind", teaching how to bend a negative mindset into a positive one, will not help most of them. To suggest that they themselves have the power to change their lifes, is to misunderstand poverty and human psychology. Margaret Thatcher once called poverty a "personality defect." That's so easy, and so wrong.

There's a reason why poor people make such poor choices in life. It's poverty itself that keeps poor people from making rational decisions about their own lifes. Rational decisions are usually made for the long term, the choices we sit down and think about, planning a route toward some goal in the future. And even then we're not completely rational, just because of who and what we are; just think of presidential elections for example, where research shows we make our decision mostly based on good looks, a trustworthy face, charismatic personality, and much less on actual past voting behavior or even the written proposals of the man or woman. But still, a rational decision is something completely different from an ad-hoc decision we make when falling in love, or when confronted with a crisis.


evicted_small.jpg
Image by Gideon - source: Flickr

In crises we're not that smart and often make terrible decisions. But one thing we can't do, and that is forget about the immediate crisis; it demands solving right away, or else there's no brainpower left to focus on the all important long-term goals. We all know that immediate concerns always trump any mid- or long-term plans; when we're working on something, and our stomach reminds us we haven't eaten since breakfast, it's best to pause and eat a bite, or else we won't concentrate on the work that has to be done, our stomach won't let us.

This is poverty. Poor people's minds are in constant crisis-solving mode. None of our advice will get through to those minds. On average of course; there's the occasional exception everywhere. Trying to teach these people how to "help themselves" is done with the best of intentions most of the time, but it won't work.

Today's post was inspired by a TED talk by Rutger Bregman, the one that upset the billionaire community at Davos at the World Economic Forum by addressing their tax-evasion policies. Rutger is also a strong supporter for the introduction of some form of Universal Basic Income. Personally I am of the opinion that there's no reason for poverty to exist, other than by choice. The existence of poverty is detrimental to all our lifes; it costs more money to fight all illnesses, crime and other poverty related drama's, than to just give them all their basic needs to exist. Another huge advantage I see, is that we'll be motivated by different reasons to work. No one should work, just to gain the right to exist. Working for a living shouldn't even exist anymore; most work will be done by AI and robots anyway.

Here's Rutger's TED talk, which I recommend highly if you heven't seen it yet:


Poverty isn't a lack of character; it's a lack of cash | Rutger Bregman


Thanks so much for visiting my blog and reading my posts dear reader, I appreciate that a lot :-) If you like my content, please consider leaving a comment, upvote or resteem. I'll be back here tomorrow and sincerely hope you'll join me. Until then, keep steeming!


wave-13 divider odrau steem

Recent articles you might be interested in:

Latest article >>>>>>>>>>>Ignorance Is Bliss
The Sinister LeftNow You Know
Life After Game Of ThronesEternal Shock
Huge PerspectiveFake Philanthropy

wave-13 divider odrau steem

Thanks for stopping by and reading. If you really liked this content, if you disagree (or if you do agree), please leave a comment. Of course, upvotes, follows, resteems are all greatly appreciated, but nothing brings me and you more growth than sharing our ideas. It's what Steemit is made for!
Helpienaut_post_banner_02-01.png

I am a proud helpinaut! @Helpie is looking for new members! Helpie has been growing nicely and we are always on the lookout for new valuable members. We are very supportive and community oriented. If you would like to be scouted for @helpie , please drop a comment on THIS POST or contact @paintingangels on discord at paintingangels(serena)#3668.

wave-13 divider odrau steem

Just for Full Disclosure, I'm invested in these crypto-currencies:

Bitcoin | Litecoin | EOS | OmiseGo | FunFair | KIN | Pillar | DENT | Polymath | XDCE | 0x | Decred | Ethereum | Carmel | XYO

wave-13 divider odrau steem

@helpie is a WITNESS now! So please help @helpie help you by voting for us here!Helpie_01.png

Sort:  

We have so many perceptions when we hear a word 'poverty'. Most of us don't understand that these people didn't choose (directly) the place where they are now and they are helpless. Why do you do such 'stupid' decisions when you're poor? Because you need to survive. You do not look long term, you need to survive the night. And you fall deeper and deeper. It's easy to talk about poverty if we've never lived like this.

My dad was living a life in a way (wrong choices) that brought him to the street. He lost everyone and everything and I know that he couldn't help himself. It's a situation where you simply don't see the light at the end of the tunnel. Motivation wouldn't help either. These people need help. I tried to forgive him and help him and it worked. Well, I will never completely forgive him but now he lives a 'normal' life and has a job. I wouldn't say that he ended on the street by choice. It's the choices that he made that led him to such life..

I think that this topic is very sensitive and complicated and it is important to talk about it so thank you for your post!

36

I see dead people...

Excellent and compassionate connection made in your post and in the TED talk between the stress of being in the Scarcity mentality and the inability to 'think clearly' when in that state of mind. Decisions made in a state of confusion are bound to be 'unsound'.

Resteemed! Thanks for sharing 🔆

I'm glad you approve! Thanks so much for the nice words and the support, @barge 😊

Yeah, the destitute are basically in panic mode.

Giving everyone a universal basic income is like putting a band-aid on a severed artery though. All prices would rise as a result. It would be the same endless cycle that we've gotten into with minimum wage.

We have to solve the basic problems that are the cause of suffering for the poor. Like ensuring that there is affordable housing. We also need to ensure there is food for everyone. Not a huge problem in some places, but it is in others. That doesn't mean just soup kitchens serving low quality food to the homeless and destitute. It means providing places that have affordable food for everyone that doesn't carry a stigma. That means you have to locate them in places where people normally go, like city centers and malls. You also can't require they have some card or ID, because some of the people most in need of help have trouble getting such things. You also have to have affordable healthcare, that doesn't require a huge heap of paperwork to get, or some crazy hoops to jump through. There also need to be easy job centers that help find everyone jobs, good jobs. Once you do all that, there's slightly less reason for a universal basic income...but it also means that if you choose to have one, it mainly helps the people that really are in desperate need...though the majority of them should be on public assistance anyway.

Of course, if you actually solved all these problems intelligently, ironically you would be spending less money per person.

Thanks so much for this well thought out response @geekpowered, I appreciate that a lot! Even if I don't agree...

There also need to be easy job centers that help find everyone jobs...

Actually, no. Not everyone can have a job because then jobs wouldn't pay. Also not everyone can have a job because there are better things to do in life, like raising kids, painting paintings, writing songs, inventing new stuff... Also not everyone can have a job because we simply don't have to: when asked, more than 25% of the workers admit their job is useless and doesn't add anything of value. Also not everyone can have a job because Skynet is upon us...

The scarcity mindset is cultivated by a scarcity based economy we've hung on to while leaving the scarcity reality. It's the very thought that everyone has to work for a living that's outdated. For me, the only question is if it;s right that poverty even exists in the abundance we've created. The answer in my mind is a loud and resounding "no, of course not". Ending poverty would not only free up a lot of money, that's the least important thing in my mind; it would free up minds, making them available for true progression on the things that make us human, like science, art and technology. The old saying goes like "money makes the world go 'round" when in actuality money is the biggest obstacle for humanity to rise to a next level. Can we go and colonize Mars? We have the brainpower, the technology and even a healthy pool of volunteers willing to go on a one-way trip to the Red Planet. Literally nothing is stopping us but the money, the economy. We can do anything, but money won't make us do what's most important.

Yeah, we are approaching a point where we will start to enter a post scarcity economy, where practically everything is made by automated machines. But then, what's the point in money at all? To ration a certain number of things? Most people won't be able to figure out something they're good at enough to get paid well doing. If we were truly in a post scarcity economy, we wouldn't need money or to ration anything. But then you'd have the old people taking more than their share.

We aren't truly in a post scarcity economy yet and we won't be for a while. We have the technology for many things to be automated, perhaps even most of society now. But we will need time. Many people need time to change.

Of course it's not right that poverty exists. It's stupid. We grow more than enough food for everyone. And it makes more sense financially to provide healthcare for everyone.

It also makes more sense to switch to high speed rail as soon as possible and abandon cars for the most part, relying on small electric automated vehicles for local transpo. But we won't.

We need to take care of the things that people spend money on that everyone needs, for the benefit of society. Even if we gave money to everyone, they'd just have to pay for these things anyway, and then it would cost everyone more money. Instead, we need to just supply them.

And even if in the future many won't have the jobs they have now, companies still need to go somewhere to find people to fill the jobs they have, and people that want jobs to do have to go somewhere to find one. The current system is just wasteful and stupid. Seriously, we have to go door to door for a job?

You're turning to money to solve the problem of money. We should just solve the individual problems. Eventually we'll move beyond money. And maybe we should have a universal basic income...but we have a lot of other problems that need to be solved to lower how much basic income we need, because we all need to pay for them anyway.

And the problem with going to Mars isn't the money, it's politicians. They're unwilling to put the money forward that it would cost. In truth we could have a launch loop allowing cheap flights to the moon and launching satellites and going to Mars for less than the annual budget of many companies, just a few billion, but we don't. The cost to go to Mars is actually not that much. Instead we spend insane amounts on bombs and planes and big buildings to hold games that will never be used afterwards. The problem isn't money. The problem is people. We don't solve poverty because not enough people in positions to do something want to do anything. And we put them in those positions.

poverty is a lack of hope

I'm thinking that you completely missed the point of the article, but maybe you mean that poverty is hopelessness itself which means that the situation is hopeless, not that those in such a situation don't have hope or lack hope, which if they did would somehow make their situation better or different.

Posted using Partiko Android

Hope is a lack of certainty...

or perhaps a lack of any certainty. homeless people cannot be certain of when they will get their next meal, if they will be safe, where they will sleep. is it any wonder that after a history of poverty they don't trust an apple to fill their belly or a stranger to be kind?

the question isn't what's wrong with them, but what the fuck is wrong with our society the we don't care enough to give them the tools and opportunities to succeed?

The movie "Trading Places" comes to mind. How long would it take for the average person, if their circumstances were drastically altered, to start taking on a homeless mindset?

That's brilliant, and probably deserves an entire post on it's own! Trading Places, of course! Why oh why didn't I think of that..? Thanks so much for this effective illustration 😍 I agree 100% 😊

Good post. I was talking to a long-lost friend a while back, and she said that she'd watched a video about why poor people are poor. That cigarette, that drink, that bite of chemically-engineered food-like structures... Those offer a dopamine hit. That momentary "relief of anxiety" is what those industries are all about... It's what Convenience-Culture is all about. And it is ludicrously profitable. You spoke of the cost of poverty... but consider.. that where there is cost.. somebody is profiting.

Every part of the malaise of poverty is Engineered, because it's profitable. And it does have some "benefits".. like a world groaning under the weight of 8,000,000,000 humans... A world that could easily support that number, given the right policies... But that wouldn't be profitable, now would it?

I just made a post that.. well, it doesn't really relate to this.. but it does.

Again... good post. <3

Thanks for the response my friend :-) A cure for cancer will never make it to the market because there's too much money made on treating cancer... That's how it work, unfortunately.

I'll read your post later; thanks for giving me the heads-up! 😊

Interesting Ted talk, Im addicted to Ted talks I swear! Thanx for sharing

Ted is great! I've been watching that channel for years and am almost always pleasantly surprised. Thanks for stopping by @aliciasteyn, it's much appreciated 😊

This is all so true, zyxxie! I think some people with privileges sometimes do not realize that poverty is not a 'setting' that can be changed simply with 'willing it so'.... it is a condition that affects every fiber, every second of some people's life and it is not an easily solve-able condition...

Love the write up, you always have a lot of empathy in your articles :)

Thanks so much @veryspider, you're too kind 😊 As always 😍

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.29
TRX 0.12
JST 0.034
BTC 63748.21
ETH 3314.18
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.90