Building With Pallets: Is it safe?

in #homesteading6 years ago

We recently began a series of posts that have utilized pallet wood for a variety of items including beehives, cutting boards etc. There have been some comments asking about the safety of using these materials, as some may be chemically treated or could have had something spilled on them in transit, etc. We appreciate the comments and don't wish to dismiss or ignore them, as we ourselves have concerns of being exposed to harmful chemicals, and try to avoid them at all costs. We, based on our research and the process we put each piece of wood through, do feel comfortable using pallet wood as material for a variety of projects. We have found that anything that may have been on the wood is removed in this process. In order to show that to all of you, we decided to do a little experiment. While it might not be "scientific" per say, we feel that with some preparation most if not all contaminants can be removed. In this post we will try and demonstrate that with a few precautions and minimal preparations, pallet wood can indeed be used as a great source of free lumber, not to mention saving the landfills of unnecessary waste.



1520487231870.png



First, let's touch on where I think a lot of this concern originally comes from. It is a very well know fact that using treated wood (i.e. pressure treated, stained or painted) is not recommended for use in gardening. While I also believe that using treated wood in gardening structures is not a good idea, I think the reason it is dangerous is of utmost importance. You see, when you use treated wood in your garden it in constant contact with water, therefore leaching any chemicals used on the treated wood directly into the soil. The roots of your plants are then feeding from the now chemically filled soil, where those chemicals then enter your food supply.



Now, when using pallet wood for things like beehives, this leaching effect is not present because the hive is not in constant contact with water and is sealed on the outside to protect against the weather. Also, bees coat the inside of the hive with a combination of wax and propolis, therefore preventing any contact with the actual wood. As for the honey, It is made and stored inside the wax comb, never touching any wood surface. Now what about the cutting boards? Well, first off, you should never use pressure treated wood in anything that comes in contact with your food. We only use hardwoods for use in the cutting boards because hardwoods are traditionally not pressure treated. We then plane the wood, removing any surface area and seal the cutting boards using beeswax and oil.



Because Douglas Fir is a very porous wood it is commonly used as pressure treated wood and due to the process of the actual pressure treatment, it absorbs the chemicals deep within. We don't recommend using the pressure treated wood in anything that comes in contact with your food or livestock's food, period. Because of this we will be omitting pressure treated wood from this experiment. But, that's not to say it can't be used in other projects like outdoor furniture, firewood boxes, livestock pens, storage containers etc.



So, what about the pallets that are not pressure treated but may have been surface treated with some sort of preservative, or had chemicals spilled on them, paint etc. Do these sorts of situations make the whole piece of wood unusable? Let's find out;



IMG_20180307_192509.jpg



For our example we begin with 2 different pieces of Douglas Fir that have been planed to a specific thickness. In example #1 we dumped "Minwax deep penetrating strain" on a piece of Douglas Fir that was planed to a thickness of 1.2445". Which would represent a spill of some sort of chemical.



IMG_20180307_192557.jpg



IMG_20180307_192713.jpg



In example #2 we coated a second piece of Douglas Fir with "Minwax deep penetrating strain" that was planed to a thickness of .5055".



IMG_20180307_193026.jpg



IMG_20180307_193530.jpg



We will then allow the stain of each board to fully dry. Then, we measured each piece of wood with a calibrated Mitutoyo caliper and have taken pictures of the beginning thickness.



We would like to note that Douglas Fir is one of the most porous woods found in pallets and so every other type of wood especially hardwoods will require less preparation.



The idea here is to see how much material needs to removed before the wood returns to its original state. While this may not be the most scientific approach we feel it should demonstrate approximately how far surface treatments reach into the wood. Since we are using a high grade deep penetrating stain, we believe this would be an extreme compared to what they may be coating these pallets with in a commercial setting.



In example #1 (stain dumped) the first pass of the planer removed .0115" of the surface while removing a large amount of the stain, but not all. On the second pass through the planer, we removed .0225" and ended with a surface that was completely clean and without any evidence of stain still remaining. So, removing .0340" (approximately 1/32") was enough to remove any visible evidence of the stain.



IMG_20180307_192807.jpg



IMG_20180307_192857.jpg



In example #2 (stain spread) the first pass of the planer removed .0045" and again the majority of the stain had been removed. On the second pass we removed .0165" and the surface was completely clean. With a total of .0200" removed there was no visible signs the wood had been stained.



IMG_20180307_193620.jpg



IMG_20180307_193658.jpg



So, by removing just a small amount of the surface area off of the pallet wood, you are essentially removing what may have been spilled or sprayed on it as well. Now, we recommend you always use the best and cleanest pallets you can find, as well as common sense. But we hope that this little experiment has helped in your decision making of whether pallet wood is a good source of free material to use around the homestead. We believe it is, and we will keep bringing you tutorials on exactly what we do with it here, to hopefully encourage you to make it instead of buy it as well.


Thank you for reading,


Happy Homesteading.

PhotoGrid_1519632405335.jpg

Sort:  

My opinion - building with pallets is safe! I've built a little house from pallets and will make another one. Now I am using pallets as firewood.

DSC_0258.jpg

Thanks for the writing this up and looks like good valuable information!

They either treat pallets by fumigating them with methyl bromide, a toxic pesticide, or by heat-treating them in kilns. For reusing purposes, look for pallets stamped with an “HT”, which means they haven't been exposed to chemicals (at least not in the treating process.)

Hey @mrkstn1, thank you so much for the comment. I should have put something in the article about the "HT" stamp. Thank you for pointing that out.

From the research we had done, I was under the impression that methyl bromide was outlawed in every country other than China, so it was not something that would be used on pallets anymore. Here is the information we have found,

[HT] = Heat treatment / [MB] = Methyl Bromide / [DB] = Debarked / [KD] = Kiln Dried

"[MB]: Methyl bromide fumigation, this is a potent pesticide linked to human health problems and ozone layer depletion. Methyl bromide fumigation kills invasive species like pine beetles.

In 1987, the Montreal Protocol aimed to regulate the use of methyl bromide, along with multiple other chemicals found to impact the ozone. This type of treatment is now banned in Canada and many countries because it poses health risks to workers handling the pallets. However, you can still find it in some places. If you find an MB pallet (likely from Asia or Oceania), please do not use it for your craft projects or as firewood, find a waste-removal company that can dispose of it properly."

Source
https://www.1001pallets.com/pallet-safety/amp/

We have personally never seen a pallet marked "MB" but always try to choose our pallets carefully. Our goal in this experiment was to mainly address paints, seals, stains applied to pallets or spills that may have happened in transit.

can never be too careful. most people are looking for rustic so an older pallet could make its way through....... And just because you can't see it doesn't mean its not there...... I'd stick to the kiln dried ones if possible. I think most people are aware these days so the other crap doesn't surface......

Thank you for this post! I have been wanting to gather up some pallets to make a few containers for gardening my greens (ie. spinach, mesclun & arugula) and knowing how to properly prep the wood/slats is very helpful.

This post has been resteemed by @woodworkcurators
woodlogo2.png

Daily promotion and curation for the Woodworking community.
You can read about us here

Win SBD in our Weekly Woodworking Competition

Love all the detailed info in this post! We bought a bunch of pallets, pine I believe, a few yrs ago. Freshly made with no stamp. We were told they'd not been treated and I've no reason to doubt that as now they're getting some wood burrowing beetles (I think. Not termites but something clearly chewing a 1/4" hole.) The plans for these pallets were basically to make a pallet wall but possibly also outdoor furniture and trellises. I don't consider myself the absolute greenist of any sustainable minded person, but I feel completely comfortable with our pallets. I appreciate the effort put into this post because while there are differences of opinion in the sustainable community, I Know you guys are very conscientious and thorough so it's helpful for everyone to see your thought process and reasoning to help dispell any judgements that others might make not understanding these types of details. It's up to each of us to make the best decisions what we are comfortable doing. It's good for this information to be discussed then people can make up their own mind, such as you have. PS. If I ever do use our pallets for planters, I'll likely be using either as a facade or plastic lined as self watering planters. Many don't agree with using plastic, either, but I have reasons I'm comfortable with.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.30
TRX 0.11
JST 0.033
BTC 63968.82
ETH 3136.80
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.28