You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Steemit Engagement Challenge WOX Community S10W2: Drawing Hands
Hi @steemdoctor1.
I don't think I'm wrong if I say that this is the most horrible and poorly done drawing I've seen in this contest. Marking the division of the fingers at random, without any consideration of the proportions, with unfinished lines leaving the position of some fingers in relation to the hand or the other fingers in ambiguity. To make matters worse, you have shaded the entire hand evenly, which does not distinguish differences in distance, shadows, lightness or volume.
You say you have deleted the non-essential parts. With what criteria did you do it? The nails, for example, were not essential?
What's the point of choosing a pose that's difficult to interpret if you don't make the slightest effort to capture its essence?
Greetings.
I have read with concern several evaluations and comments from some judges in charge of the challenges of this community.
I turned my gaze towards this because some users contacted me and let me know that they felt bad, humiliated and diminished with their evaluations in the challenges, I want to limit several suggestions for you:
Remember that there are 7 challenges, one for each day of the week, which means that users must work quickly (and efficiently) to be able to participate in as many challenges as possible, adhering to the rules, quality and time. own content, without adding that they also have to comment on other participations.
Most of them are not artists, so I think the expectation level should be low.
Being a moderator or judge is a responsibility but can be done without offending or demoralizing a user (this only results in users not wanting to participate in your challenges).
You can be objective when evaluating, that's what the score is for.
Anyway, remember that we are not studied artists, but we still want to participate in the challenges and express ourselves.
@steemcurator01 take a look at this please.
I agree that the evaluation comment should motivate you to further improve your skills. It would also be unpleasant for me to receive such a form of assessment.
But this medal has a downside...
@jorgevandeperre has been preparing this contest for a long time, he took it seriously and expected the same approach from the participants.
Checking a lot of applications for contests, I have identified several negative trends.
-In a hurry to take part in all the contests of the week, without exception, participants create quick low-quality posts "just in time" in the hope of getting a few coins. The quality of such posts cannot be high or even average (with rare exceptions).
-There are some participants who have higher social statuses on the platform. They hope for support because of their status, not the quality of the work done. Unfortunately, this situation also takes place.
I absolutely agree that the jury should be as objective and correct as possible and the comments should be respectful. In this case, the person simply did not restrain his emotions, although this is not permissible. But I understand him too.
We all need to be more respectful of the events of these contests, so as not to turn them into an empty formal fiction. And, of course, respect each other and communicate kindly with each other.
P.S.
I think it's not about the professionalism, the skills of an artist or photographer. It's more about a conscientious honest attitude to the task. If I see in the contest the efforts of the participant, the amount of effort and his desire... in fact, this is a more valuable result than a quick simple drawing by a professional, which did not cost him a lot of work (there are some). Participation is, first of all, effort, work and, of course, the result.
I totally agree with @nahela, these contests are made for all audiences, here some have more ability than others, of that we are all aware. But belittling the work of others, saying it looks horrible and claiming it's the worst thing you've ever seen, that's humiliating. Judges, we must be patient, kind, be guides, so that users are motivated and keep trying, we can not end up belittling the work of others because it is not to our liking.
More respect please.
In the Whatsapp groups of Colombia-original there are constant complaints about deals like this. To the point that very few want to participate in the challenges of this community in particular. I think there are things to improve, and not only at the artistic level in the users, but at the level of treatment by the jury.
The idea of the challenges should be, even if we are not artists, to have a good time, and it is not something that is happening, not when we see that the users, the vast majority, do not want to participate.
Buenas noches @nahela, realmente es preocupante como han tratado a algunos participantes. Es preferible que no comenten si lo que van hacer es humillar y hacer sentir mal a las personas.
Apoyo este comentario, gracias por expresarlo de manera tan asertada y educada @nahela, ciertamente he leído varios comentarios y más que ser formativos son despectivos, nada agradables al ojo de quien los lee.
Gracias por el llamado de atención, es necesario.
Hola amiga @nahela en verdad te apoyo porque no deben de tratarnos mal por el simple echo de no saber dibujar.
Y creo que esto se hizo para dar lo mejor que tenemos y no para que nos humillen de una manera tan despreciable.
Muchos nos atenemos de participar para evitar la molestia.
Espero se tomen medidas.
Agree with @bambuka. It's not about participating in as many challenges as possible, against the clock ...with this dynamic it's logical to submit mediocre work and get criticism in line with what's submitted. Quality should be rewarded, not quantity.
I have said that I'm not much good in drawing but I have given my best. Mistakes are surely the part of it and I am happy thay you have marked the mistakes, (but don't suggested the solutions). Anyways, I respect your reviews, thanks again.
Te felicito por hacer tu mayor esfuerzo, creo que estos concursos no deben ser votados por nosotros los que no somos grandes artistas, es lamentable que te falten el respeto cuando muy bien dices que no sabes dibujar. Eres un caballero y muy respetuoso, Dios te bendiga.
Thanks dear friend 😊
Uy que animo es como a los niños en la escuela les piden dibuja un cuerpo humano y s hace un circulo y 4 palitos eso es y ya.
Aqui estamos para aprender, no para humillar, en las reglas no piden profesionales
Hola amigo Jorge, realmente creo que esta no es la forma de tratar a los usuarios, nuestro amigo @steemdoctor1 no es artista como tú, y la mayoría de los participantes tampoco lo son, por lo que no puedes evaluarlos en base al nivel en el que tú estás por tus conocimientos sobre dibujo.
Cuando somos moderadores o jueces debemos ser una guía para los usuarios y dirigirnos a ellos con respeto, no de manera despectiva como he visto que lo han hecho todos los jueces en algunas oportunidades.
Los usuarios no quieren participar en sus retos por miedo a ser tratados de esa manera, y esta dinámica se creo para incentivarlos a participar y para divertirse en el proceso. No solo los artistas tienen derecho a participar y ser tratados dignamente sino todos en general.
Ciertamente podemos evaluar de manera objetiva, pero para eso están los puntajes, el resto, como los malos tratos hacía los participantes no son necesarios.
@stef1 creo que es necesario evaluar todo lo que está ocurriendo.
Right my friend @franyeligonzalez. I think they should also pay attention while selecting the topic. We should avoid such topics which are different for many users to participate. But if we have set such a topic then we should never expect the artistry/photography of the professional level. And discouragement like this comment is really bad. This will impart bad impact and users will be fearful while participating. Anyways, I hope that administration of this community will look into this thing.