Geology and Civilization Part 1: How Dinosaurs Affected the 2008 American Presidential Election

in geology •  last year 

There is a line of blue Democratic Party voting counties stretching across the otherwise red Republican Party voting American South. It's known as the Black Belt, and it owes its existence entirely to geology. It's a fascinating story that I'll discuss here in a second, and it serves as a great introduction for my new series, which looks at the ways in which geology has affected the way we construct and manage our civilizations. This series is NOT about 'lessons geologists have to teach civilization'- instead, it's a breakdown of how various civilizations in our past have interacted with our world and how it's worked or failed for them, and how we're doing in turn.

The 2008 election map by county. Note the curving line of blue counties in the southeast. [Image source]

So how did geology send the votes of those counties to Obama in the 2008 election? To answer that question, we've got to travel back to the Cretaceous, the last age of the dinosaurs that ended 65 million years ago. The Cretaceous was characterized by a few traits other than dinosaurs- it was extremely warm after its early colder history, with little in the way of icecaps, leading to much higher seas than today. In addition, the Cretaceous seas were further affected by the much higher levels of vulcanism present then. It tended to push the seabed upwards- warmer, younger seabed (which is all produced by volcanic processes) floats higher atop the mantle than older, colder seabed.

So due to the much higher seas, coastlines were much farther inland. In fact, due to the Laramide Orogeny, the mountain-building event that forged the Rocky Mountains, there was actually a shallow sea stretching from the gulf of Mexico to the Arctic. This seaway, the Western Interior Seaway, and the shallow coastal seas covering what is now much of the American South were biologically extremely productive. Among other things, it resulted in the huge numbers of fossils found in many of these regions today. Most importantly for our purposes, these waters were incredibly rich in carbonate skeleton bearing marine plankton, largely of the variety known as coccoliths.

The coastline of Cretaceous America. Note the correspondence between the coastline and that line of blue counties.[Image source]

When carbonate rich marine plankton dies, their skeletons settle to the seafloor. Over millions of years, the Cretaceous plankton became chalk. In fact, the Cretaceous is named after the huge beds of chalk deposited during it- creta is Latin for chalk. Chalk is porous and alkaline, and led to fertile, well-drained dark soils across the region. These soils were the reason for the name of the belt.

One crop grew especially well in the soils of the Black Belt- cotton. With the invention of the cotton gin by Eli Whitney in 1793, chattel slavery in America went from a slowly shrinking sector of the American population to an abrupt boom industry. By 1860, black slave labor in the American South provided two thirds of the world's total cotton. Cotton became an economic juggernaut in America, and most of the slaves that fueled it lived in the Black Belt.

The White Cliffs of Dover, in England, are formed of chalk deposited at the same time as the chalk in the Black Belt.

Despite the popular image of plantations that lasted through multiple generations in a single family in the South, most were relatively short-lived. The most profitable cotton-farming methods were hell on the land, and wrecked fields in a few short years. This meant that cotton farmers were always having to buy new land, always to the west. These expansion pressures were a major cause of the American Civil War, as the wealthy slave owners were trying to expand into territory also desired by the free laborers leaving the East for more economic opportunity.

After the Civil War and the freeing of American slaves, due to an extreme lack of economic opportunity most of them remained in the same areas they had been slaves- often even being employed by their old masters. Today, these areas have populations ranging from 50-85% African American. African Americans tend to vote Democratic overwhelmingly, and their show of support for Barack Obama in his presidential bid was immense. The Black Belt states still ended up voting for the Republican Party, which is a whole other sort of political tale, but it's still an interesting little electoral narrative.

Machu Picchu, capital city of the Incas. The Incans will come up a lot later in this series. [Image source]

This story lies at a crossroads of several sciences that examine the interactions of nature and civilization. These include the history of technology, historical ecology, historical geography, and, most importantly for our purposes, environmental history. Environmental history is, fundamentally, the study of the interaction of civilization and nature, and the feedback that results. Environmental history has been forcing a sea change in the ways we interpret much of history. Up until recently we put relatively little account into how the interactions of civilization and nature affected history- something that's changing rapidly.

Environmental history is a surprisingly young science- it can really only be traced back to the environmental movement of the 1970s, and didn't really pick up serious steam until the 1990s. There's good reason for this, of course- the Cold War was, for instance responsible for a climate fairly unfriendly to the study of environmental history. To quote the British environmental historian Bruce M.S. Campbell, “...the long dominance of anthropocentric analyses grounded in either Marxist theory or neoclassical economics means that scant attention has as yet been paid to the historical roles of environmental processes and forces.” Both major ideologies of the Cold War demanded that the universe revolve around us- anything that lowered the stakes of the struggle could not be tolerated. We'll go more into the history of environmental history and environmental thinking in a later post, though.

[Image source]

Over the course of this series, we'll be using the lenses of Environmental History and its sister sciences to examine exactly how humanity has and is interacting with nature on a civilizational basis. If there's one thing that environmental history teaches us it's how many pitfalls there are that can end a civilization- we need to be careful, because we're standing on the edges of several of them.


Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Much of human culture derives from the environment within which man lives. The so-called "Plains Indians" began as sedentary semi-agrarian society that evolved into nomadic society, once it came in contact with European colonials and the earth-shattering technology of tamed horses. Horses allowed for these sedentary social units to be able to chase heavier game of American bison in the plains, transforming once the sedentary culture (and its religious mythos) into nomadic culture (and subsequent shifting of its religious mythos to more nomadic paradigm).

Climate variations differ significantly in longitudinal rather than latitudinal direction. Thus, the ease of technological and cultural exchange in East-West axis (following possibility of crop and livestock transplantation) compared with the inordinately difficult travel between North-South axis. Also, the courses and nature of rivers determined the possibility of technological exchange, and thus, progress of civilization.


I'll definitely be touching on this stuff a lot in future posts!



From your title with the words "Dinosaurs" and "2008-american-presidential-election" I was expecting to read about the politicians themselves! But seriously, an enjoyable article and shows how much we are influenced by the environment.


Thanks! And yeah, it's astonishing how much some people like to imagine that the world is merely the stage upon which mankind acts, rather than nature being one of the main determining forces of history.

What an appealing title, lol. And it's not even technically clickbait =P


Hah, thanks!

Great info, interesting learning how the geology of the area affected the current demographic patterns. I look forward to future posts about similar things.



Beautifully written! I'm looking forward to more parts of your series. I actually learned a lot today. And you are correct in that we have been, and still are, way too focused on anthropocentrism as if mankind is a completely independent domain, when nature is what shaped us to begin with.


Thanks! I hope you enjoy the series!

Your Post Has Been Featured on @Resteemable!
Feature any Steemit post using!
How It Works:
1. Take Any Steemit URL
2. Erase https://
3. Type re
Get Featured Instantly & Featured Posts are voted every 2.4hrs
Join the Curation Team Here | Vote Resteemable for Witness

Illuminati, Free Masons... They existed even in the age of Dinosaurs! They are still controlling the world. Reptilians. And why is the raptor (eagle) American symbol?

Great article and interesting point of view



I'm totally adding Environmental Problems of the Greeks and Romans to my reading stack.

Another interesting aspect of the need to forever move west to continue cotton cultivation is that there's a trend of increasing automation from East to West. Essentially, better cotton harvesting methods had a high initial capital expenditure, and it was much more economically feasible for new plantations to adopt them. Older, established farms had too much sunk costs in old technologies. At least, that's an interpretation I read in The Travels of a T-shirt in the Global Economy.


It's a really good book. The author spends as much time talking about the way the Greeks and Romans thought of nature as he does talking about how they damaged it.

I've never heard of The Travels of a T-shirt in the Global Economy, that sounds fun!

hai .. a very good post. i like your post


What about it do you like?


I love the way of delivery

Congratulations! This post has been chosen as one of the daily Whistle Stops for The STEEM Engine!

You can see your post's place along the track here: The Daily Whistle Stops, Issue #94 (4/4/18)

The STEEM Engine is an initiative dedicated to promoting meaningful engagement across Steemit. Find out more about us and join us today.

It is nature that makes man get off his fat lazy ass and move, and if someone else is in their way, bang bang Bang.