Why day 2 of "12 Days of Coinbase" was a disappointment

in #coinbase6 years ago

Before I start, I want to acknowledge that what they have done is a nice thing, but considering the way they started it out and the fact that Coinbase is evaluated at $8b, this 2nd day has disappointed a lot of users over the internet.

image.png

At first glance it looks like a very charitable thing to do and it's going to a location where they are in dire need of other payment solutions considering the inflation and the way things run there. What is bothering people is that after the 1st announcement of "12 days of Coinbase" this isn't as big of a move and Coinbase might be shooting itself in the foot instead. If you run through the numbers, they are going to donate $1 to 100 families for 3 months, which totals $9000 USD.

Now bear in mind that Coinbase is a $8b company, if you were to compare it to Steem's marketcap currently laying at ~$70 million and then looking further into how much users from Venezuela are making on our blockchain, it makes the donation amount from Coinbase a considerably minimal amount. Now I'm not saying that it's not a great thing they are doing, of course any donation is welcome for the people in need, but others are taking this as a cheap shot at marketing and especially considering it was one of the 12 days of Coinbase following a very powerful first announcement this has annoyed quite a few people. The bar has been lowered on what they can expect as the next days of announcements and a question that has been flying around as to "why ZCash?" following their recent listing of the currency to coinbase.pro.

Now of course this isn't the best course of action to compare "donations" with Steem rewards, but let's just for fun do it. In a post 2 months ago I wrote about how much users that have disclosed their location to be Venezuela on their Steem accounts were earning. At the time of writing that Steem's market cap was at $220 million and the 1735 active users that openly were from Venezuela were earning 8240 SBD and 8140 SP per month. At the time that was approximately $15k a month, so that'll be $45k for 3 months and bear in mind there may be more users from that location that have not disclosed it due to their strict laws and bans of cryptocurrencies.

45000/220000000=0.0002% while 9000/8000000000 equals 0.0000011%, 0.0002/0.0000011= 181.81, not sure if my math here is completely correct as its early in the morning but it seems as if Steem is rewarding users 181x more than Coinbase's donation. Again, while these are not numbers we should be comparing it is something we should be proud of as a community and the people we are helping on a day to day basis. Considering traffic stats and how distributed we are in developing countries, there is another factor which could explain the low price of Steem. Unfortunately we live in a world with great imbalance of wealth and the price of Steem in some countries will never drop low enough for the users to consider "not selling cause it's too low" as they will be pressured to sell anything to survive either way.

Lastly, great for Coinbase donating but in retrospect I understand some users were underwhelmed by this 2nd day announcement. Coinbase is a company though and their main priorities are profits for the shareholders and bringing adoption to Crypto will continue to be one of their main priorities to not just make the world a better place, but at the same time enrich the early investors of the company.

One thing I personally am looking forward to is decentralized exchanges. Not just for the security, but one thing that attracted me to crypto was that anyone could invest any amount into a project which was very different from how people were investing in companies or projects before. Sadly Coinbase chose the old ways but there are competitors in the horizon and they have a shot at reclaiming dominance in the space as much as the next guy.

Sort:  

I really like your explanation of the subject, and I think I understand your point, the truth is that at first glance without many calculations, you are right. I am Venezuelan and to fulfill in two days my first year in Steemit, for the previous year I could appreciate more the contribution of the platform to the users of my country. Today, despite the price of Steem, the few Venezuelans who have remained in the blockchain, it is because the value of the dollar here is getting higher every time. But even so, I have 2 jobs within steemit in Hispanic communities and I keep my personal blog active, I think the best decision we can make is to do 100% power thinking about long term benefits, or try not to do power down, the truth is that it is not the same anymore.

Personally I owe a lot to steemit :) It hurts that there is no way to invest (I do not have to invest either, it's sad, lol), maybe that's why I've been dedicating myself to look for some help from whales that appreciate the work of some communities Hispanics whose votes 80% are for Venezuelans.

So, you contagious the disappointment that you explain in your post.

If you ever thought for one second that Coinbase is not a typical corporation that does flashy things for tax purposes, you may need to reconsider.

Coinbase is in its totality, in full definitions, all shape and form... A wall street bank. A crypto bank to be sure, but a wall street bank nonetheless. It has all the markings, all the bearings.

People may argue that they drive adoption.. Sure... But do you think the newbies who got into crypto through Coinbase will ever in a decade have the mindset that you and I had?

"Welcome to the decentralized world of Cryptocurrency, now first, fill up these 2 forms, take a head shot of yourself, present your ID, passport, proof of residence and credit rating. We do not accept anyone with prior criminal records. Please comply to your respective state tax regulation, and we deserve to confiscate your coins for any purpose we deem appropriate persuant to the Federal obligation granted to Coinbase Group Ltd. Under US Federal Reserve AML/ATF policy"

Posted using Partiko Android

I mean yeah...this was a complete joke lol. they have so much money if you going to be "charitable" do something BIG 12 days in a row. alot more than 100 families need help there...

I agree that it is underwhelming for a Company with those resources not to do more... However, consider the following... $1 USD today in the hyperinflationary environment currently happening in Venezuela is not the same 3 months from now... If inflation holds, the $1 in 3 months time will at least hold its value vs their local fiat currency which is what I think they had their intentions with here in the 2nd day. Venezuela has been an area where more citizens are searching for alternatives to sustain their purchasing power with cryptocurrencies which shows in the demand for bitcoin and merchants now accepting more cryptos across the country.

Posted using Partiko iOS

Can you please name some decentralized competitors?

Look up 0x, Bancor, Bitshares. Also the Steem blockchain acts as a decentralized exchange and will be even bigger once SMTs are out.

Binance is creating their own DEX and asset issuer.

Haha, coincidentally binance is the only exchange I use..^^

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

You would think they would have focused energy into finding a cryptocurrency to list that could help empower and allow those from struggling parts of the world to earn a living from. The amount of PR they could have generated over the long run and them showing cryptocurrency in action as a good thing.

Instead of committing that as a gift they just gave charity. The kind you just toss some bucks into a box and pat yourself on the back for "helping people." You know those kinds of people where they go around telling everyone that will hear how they gave a couple of bucks towards such as such.

Granted they are not even here posting blogs as far as I’m aware. So how in touch with cryptocurrency are they really?

Damn. Cheap marketing indeed.

Everyone should be aware of this comparison, not cause we do it bigger... But we do it better 😎

Posted using Partiko Android

If I'm reading this correctly, they're announcing something like a "gift" every day for 12 days? Like that 12 days of Christmas shit? Well, traditionally, there's a lot of gobshite gifts for many of the days, with bigger ones as it goes on. So, the second day sucks. Well...it's really good for some families that are in really dire need. But it's not what we would expect from such a big company. There are 12 more days. Hopefully they'll get the message from people disappointed with it, and reconsider if their future "gifts" aren't quite enough.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.15
JST 0.029
BTC 63126.26
ETH 2596.37
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.76