The last two days, I was called upon to assist this community.
After listening to them and looking deeper into the allegations, I can gladly report that, in my eyes as an outsider, this team did nothing wrong except for late payments of rewards, which, although they have explained it, is not right. I don't think they will do it again. (•ิ‿•ิ)
As far as the nomination of winners, they did what was expected of them; "We will leave it to each community to decide how they select their weekly winners."
If the accuser doesn't want the 5SP he was rewarded with, I will take it.
The winners selection is mainly based on the whole team; every week the contest organizer gives a winner, every moderator gives a suggestion, and we work with freedom as a team. We hosted two seasons before and five weeks of this season with no objection or allegation. We always welcome you to guide us where we make mistakes.
Sorry for the late reply. Nowadays we are celebrating our religious festival Eid, and it was the same reason for the delay in reward distribution.
Hello sir, we are a team and every decision to select the winners is discussed with the group. Before publishing the results, as my colleague rightly says, the winner does not necessarily have to be the one who commented the most, we evaluate the quality content, content that meets the requirements requested for due participation!
One moderator per week held a contest where they had the responsibility of sending and suggesting a publication that met the requested guidelines!
Supporting the comment of my friend @dexsyluz that an author can make many comments, but the content of his work is not good, so there may be another who made few comments but has good content in his publication!
There's a blame on healthy-steem community that winners are selected on the base of favouritism and even rewards are transferred to winners of engagement challenge season 16 last weeks specifically in advance.
@steemcurator01 most respectfully I want to make it clear that obviously before posting actual report,it is always decided by team that who should be the winner and it is always asked by admins from moderators that which user is deserving to be selected as a winner as my friend @dexsyluz is saying that most of time contest organizer gives maximum suggestions to choose winner but other moderators are also always free to give their opinion so now it should be clear that choosing winners is not a decision of only admin or any single person.
Winners are always choosed by admins and moderators collective discussion...
Only being top most in engagement with users is not key to success.
Depending upon words quality, grammatical quality, original ideas of a user in expressing his content and original pictures all these are preferable things in choosing a winner so we all team members keep in mind all these criterias.
By keeping in mind all these points,It is clear that claim of unfairness by that user is baseless and all team members are witnessed of it that we are working in a coordinated way.
The last two days, I was called upon to assist this community.
After listening to them and looking deeper into the allegations, I can gladly report that, in my eyes as an outsider, this team did nothing wrong except for late payments of rewards, which, although they have explained it, is not right. I don't think they will do it again. (•ิ‿•ิ)
As far as the nomination of winners, they did what was expected of them; "We will leave it to each community to decide how they select their weekly winners."
If the accuser doesn't want the 5SP he was rewarded with, I will take it.
Your comment hurts me most and it's because I know so well how you benefitted from the rightly done engagement challenge.
I saw you comment so hard that you you were winning every community, you know the true rule and method it's been done.
my question for you is did you engage on as many post to increase your chances?
Or
You were winning because you knew people?
If yes please don't let them overlook the method
I am sorry if my comment hurt you as it was not directed at you.
https://steemit.com/hive-168072/@patjewell/can-i-win-a-steemit-engagement-challenge
This is how I win contest on Steemit.
I will even make double sure that I have the tags in the order it is listed in the contest.
As for that 5SP, are you willing to give it up? Half maybe? (•ิ‿•ิ)
😂 it's too small to fit in a soon to be orca wallet.
At this stage any bit counts (•ิ‿•ิ)
Hi @steemcurator01
The winners selection is mainly based on the whole team; every week the contest organizer gives a winner, every moderator gives a suggestion, and we work with freedom as a team. We hosted two seasons before and five weeks of this season with no objection or allegation. We always welcome you to guide us where we make mistakes.
Sorry for the late reply. Nowadays we are celebrating our religious festival Eid, and it was the same reason for the delay in reward distribution.
Hello sir, we are a team and every decision to select the winners is discussed with the group. Before publishing the results, as my colleague rightly says, the winner does not necessarily have to be the one who commented the most, we evaluate the quality content, content that meets the requirements requested for due participation!
One moderator per week held a contest where they had the responsibility of sending and suggesting a publication that met the requested guidelines!
As always, creativity and quality are sought!
Atte
Edgar!
@dexsyluz I agree with your statements!!
There's a blame on healthy-steem community that winners are selected on the base of favouritism and even rewards are transferred to winners of engagement challenge season 16 last weeks specifically in advance.
@steemcurator01 most respectfully I want to make it clear that obviously before posting actual report,it is always decided by team that who should be the winner and it is always asked by admins from moderators that which user is deserving to be selected as a winner as my friend @dexsyluz is saying that most of time contest organizer gives maximum suggestions to choose winner but other moderators are also always free to give their opinion so now it should be clear that choosing winners is not a decision of only admin or any single person.
Winners are always choosed by admins and moderators collective discussion...
Only being top most in engagement with users is not key to success.
Depending upon words quality, grammatical quality, original ideas of a user in expressing his content and original pictures all these are preferable things in choosing a winner so we all team members keep in mind all these criterias.
By keeping in mind all these points,It is clear that claim of unfairness by that user is baseless and all team members are witnessed of it that we are working in a coordinated way.
Thanks for your time ....
“We are proud, fair, and committed as a team. We believe that each one has a voice and will therefor respond accordingly.”
Thank you so much my dear respected sir.
As a team we have joined hands together in picking winners with top engagement along with quality post
I dropped a report on my findings because the data looked so much for a comment.