Pin code automatically set without confirming pin in eSteem App

faisalamin (80)in #utopian-io • 6 years ago

Project Repository:

Project Name:

eSteem

Expected behavior

Pin code must be work when we type the same pin code in the confirm pin text box and if it does not match it must shows the error else if it is matched then the pin code is required to unlock the app otherwise it must be disabled.

Actual behaviour

eSteem app has an option of security of Pin code and there are two steps to set the security one is type the new pin code and other is confirm the typed pin code. But the issu is here, app implement the pin code security even then we doesn't type the confirming pin code.

How to Reproduce

Open the eSteem app and go to its settings
Enable pin code option and type your pin once.

Do not type the Confirm PIN Code

eSteem App:

Version 1.6.0

Operating System:

Android Oreo 8.0.0

Recording of bug

#bug-hunting #opensource #esteem

6 years ago in #utopian-io by faisalamin (80)

Sort:

fego (72) 6 years ago

Hi @faisalamin, thanks for making this contribution.

I was able to replicate the behavior you described. The app is expected to open normally when you do not complete the PIN setting before previously exiting. The PIN part should only come up when you navigate to the settings on second launching. This is a serious issue, cause if the user forgets the initial PIN that was used without confirming, he gets locked out of the app till it is maybe re installed.

Below is my feedback:

Your post title does not contain sufficient and clear information. Submission title should include the app name and version number, as well as a brief description of the occuring issue ([Product Name] [Product Version] – Succinct description of the bug).
The actual and expected behavior should be formal and short. The expected behavior could be shortened to - application should not ask for pin when re-opened after a user had previously exited app before confirming pin change.
The steps you provided were clear and easy to follow. Including the pictures made it the more easier. Only thing wrong was the video recording, please turn off sound when making records for the bug reports.
You did not open this issue on github. Please consider this in your future reports, as this is a prerequisite to submitting contributions to this category. The PO's find it generally useful, cause it directs their attention to what needs fixing.
I see you have not included a technical analysis, neither have you proposed a fix. Well, adding these to your reports not only makes it technical, it also increases your total score.

I hope this feedback helps. I look forward to your future reports. .

Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.

Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io/.
Chat with us on Discord.
[utopian-moderator]