Steemtopia #6: To this ONE it Makes a Difference

in #steemit8 years ago (edited)

To This ONE it Makes a Difference


Yesterday I read a great post by @bleepcoin titled Why Steemit is Not Utopia and You Should be Happy and I wanted to touch on something about this.

Is Steemit a Utopia?


I want to start with that I absolutely agree with @bleepcoin on his position, Steemit itself is not a Utopia. In fact by the definition of Utopia being absolutely perfect, it CAN'T exist, knowing that "Perfection doesn't exists anywhere in nature." Besides, Steemit is a platform or tool we may use, but not the ideal itself. Even if Steemit scales up and becomes hugely successful, it's not the tool (while still being extremely useful) itself that moves us towards a better society, it's the people and how they use it. I don't see anybody arguing that Steemit was Utopia if it's populated solely by trolls that spew negativity or hate. Power itself isn't good or evil, but rather how power is wielded to determine this.

I view Steemit itself as an economic platform to generate and (ideally) reward discussion on what we want on a fundamental level such as life, liberty, property, happiness, meaningful relationships and work, etc. It all has to start somewhere and I am personally excited to see where this goes, especially the talked about craigslist/marketplace.

Why Utopia is Important


With all that said, I still feel the concept of Utopia to be very important to discuss because this is how we begin to self-reflect, think and communicate our individual ideals. While this may only be a mythical place (outside our own minds) it gives us the much needed metric of what I want, what am I working towards and am I going in the right direction. I'm typically not a fan of roaming around in circles just to feel like I've traveled, I search for progress.

A point I would like to touch on is that not everybody (in the general world population) is ready for the things to change. It's easier escaping through entertainment or deferring your power to someone else's judgement so you don't have to think about uncomfortable questions or complexities. While having a Utopian ideal in mind and an implementable path to create such a system are always going to be necessary, there are unspoken requirements for anybody that would wish to live in such a society. Which was discussed in a previous post called Ego Work.

Trying to think of all the intricacies of an ideal or implemented society is daunting with rabbit hole after rabbit hole of issues and what if's. So instead try to take some time furthering yourself or others so that we don't NEED to be told not to murder, steal or assault. Remember that the Non Aggression Principle is useless if we don't feel that others are going to adhere to it.

Conclusion


In conclusion I want to tell you about a part in the movie Holy Man. The main character tells a story where he walks up to a beach only to see thousands of star fish washed ashore and slowly dying. He see's a girl who is frantically going from beached starfish to starfish throwing the back into the sea.

He asks her, "Young girl, why are you trying to hard to save all these starfish? There is no possible way that you will be able to save them all." Her response was, "to this ONE it makes a difference. And to THIS one it makes a difference."

Don't underestimate the importance of working on ourselves and helping others who are doing the same. Every ONE makes a difference!

Sort:  

Thank you! Now others can see the whole movie! It really is a great watch :)

Focus on creating our own Utopia's and spread the joy to those around us- friend or stranger. Trying to create or control other peoples leads to Dystopia. Continue to throw starfish @sykochica, it does make a difference.

Beautifully said @opheliafu!
I'd love to see what you can paint with this picture in mind, both utopia and dystopia sides. I bet it would be phenomenal with the style you use.

I don't know, on the surface they may look the same!

If only we had halograms available where what you see changes based on your perspective. Lol. Someday :)

I thought more the dichotomy scene like this:

But this is why I'm not an artist.

Great post. I absolutely agree it's ultimately the people who will make Steemit a good place or not.

Community is the key.

It will never be a utopia because as you say that is a theoretical construct which will never exist in the real world.

That does not make it an excuse to then turn it into a situation of "every man for himself" where everyone just looks after their own self interests. Like I said community is key and that is what will give this place true success.

Also love the starfish quote.

I could well imagine a very advanced alien life form billions of years more advanced than humanity coming to earth and looking at us as even less than starfish - more like bacteria and questioning the value of one of our lives. If there were some massive catastrophe would it save us or just leave us to our fate?

I think the answer would be the same in that situation. All life is valuable and has meaning to those that live it. I suspect any sufficiently evolved being would believe this - if not their species would not have survived long enough to get to that point.

Thank you! This post meant a little more than the others for me.

I understand that to many the work Utopia induces a 'scoff' response of "yea, that will never happen." Whether we call it utopia, anarchy (usually with another qualifier) or whatever, we really are all speaking to some ideal. Sadly, modern society seems to consider this sort of thinking to be taboo, that I really hope to be a part of doing away with.

I like the advanced alien life analogy. The concept of scale is also something that isn't often thought of, let alone discussed. For example, over the years I've tried to change my behavior from killing bugs in my home, to instead getting them on a piece of paper (or something) and releasing them outside. Just because they are in my home isn't justification for me killing them.

While this is just a chosen behavior that I hold, and I'm sure others do to, but it's not my learned response as a child. Changing these instincts require mindful effort over a long period of time which unfortunately isn't a preferred activity of the masses. (I trust individuals, not people.)

I'd say if humanity today were presented with the same situation of the advanced aliens of helping the 'starfish/bacteria' to be 50/50 at best. However I have hope that we are progressing towards better odds.

Totally agree. I too went through the same thing with insects. As a child my response was to just kill them but now I try to just release them and help them if I can or just let them be. Yes killing something because it is inconvenient or you don't understand it is wrong.

I don't think we are there yet as regards the alien test. We are still a very savage and primitive species and if change doesn't come we will eventually be wiped out and replaced by something else that may (or may not) take a different path.

Speaking from the never ending optimist point of view...
"At least were going in the right direction!"
One person at a time.
I hope it's fast enough. :)

Well written and spot on! I agree with @cryptofiend above when he says "community is the key" and I too have been trying to create a community in my part of the world!

Thank you!
For those that haven't seen what @norbu is doing I urge you to take a look! I see it as an implemented case in point of what this post talked about; community is key and to this one it makes a difference.

https://steemit.com/steemit/@norbu/introducing-steemit-to-nepal-the-first-ever-steemit-meetup-in-kathmandu-13th-aug-2016-steemit-on-top-of-the-world-literally

Yes! Thank you for this great post. Steemit is just a tool, not the goal or the driving paradigm.

This was a fun and meaningful one for me to write. While I'm very interested in the options for implementation of a better world, it is also necessary for individuals to progress themselves too. It's important for us all to be reflective and take responsibility for ourselves.

I just love the reference. Yesterday I restumbled on a tale like that about minnows, while combing through Joseph Campbell's Reflections on the Art of Living. I've been wanting to use it somewhere, and this looks like such place. Although perhaps it isn't as relevant. It goes like this:

A wonderful example is a story I was told about a Buddhist monk whom a friend was following. Now in Tibet, people go to a slaughter-house, buy a lamb that is about to be killed, then give the lamb its freedom, and that is a pious act. Accordingly, this monk, who had a cluster of beautiful girls around him, was going to perform a pious act by freeing five hundred fish.
And so, with his constellation of beauties, he went from one bait shop to another in Monterey trying to buy five hundred minnows. But bait was in short supply, and the shopkeepers said they were not going to sell him minnows for liberation. Finally, however, he found a shop that would, and he and his entourage, carrying buckets filled with fish, went down to the shore, where they had a ceremony of blessing the fish that were about to be given their freedom. Then they dumped one bucket after another into the ocean. Well, pelicans flocked from every point of the compass, and the little monk ran back and forth, waving his robe, trying to keep the pelicans away.
Now, what is good for pelicans is bad for fish, and this monk had taken sides. He was not in the middle place. This is to me a very important story. Every now and then, I wake up laughing at that monk and his banquet for the pelicans.

Well, it all matters. For the pelicans! ;-D

Thank you! Holy Man is a great movie, I highly recommend it if you haven't seen it. I still laugh at the quote, "They gave him the chainsaw!" (Which only makes sense if you've seen it, lol)

I love Joseph Campbell and this story!

I do appreciate the importance for the Middle Path and this explains it very well! Technically the minnows were actually freed...into nature. He'd done what he set out to do, but instead he disrupted nature from eating them. Lol

Have you ever watched His Mythos talks? They are top notch, like listening to the stereotypical favorite wise grandpa. I couldn't find the whole thing in google, just a few little bits, starting here:

http://www.athenalearning.com/joseph-campbell-mythos-i-the-shaping-of-our-mythic-tradition/
(I honestly could have done with out Susan Sarandon bits though.)

Simply Great Information and Presentation

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.12
JST 0.027
BTC 61787.88
ETH 2991.71
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.48