IS STEEMIT A PIONEER INTO A DARK FRONTIER IN SOCIAL MEDIA?

in #steemit6 years ago


Wow. I’ve been away from Steemit for around two months and so many changes have occurred. Apparently there’s a change coming to the pay out structure, there’s new games like Steem Monsters, people have come and gone or really slowed down on posting, others have joined and taken off at a sprint. Recently I was trying to sell a friend on joining and she took one look at the platform and said “Oh, it really reminds me of myspace back in the day. It does look like posting whatever you create would be kinda tedious though.”

Up until recently I have never really compared Steemit to Myspace as a social media platform. This is mainly due to never using social media. (I have never seen it relevant to my career or social life and above all hated the invasion of privacy and how user data was managed.) But in many ways there are some similarities here. It’s the first big player in cryptocurrency social media, in the same way Myspace was aimed at teenage users Steemit is aimed at crypto users, it is being discovered by people outside of the original target market, it’s growing….more or less. But both platforms can easily be called trail blazers in the field of social media.

Time passed after the launch of Myspace and by June of 2006 it passed Google by as the most visited site. I’m not optimistic that Steemit will ever reach this dizzying height but would see it as cool if it did. But eventually Myspace drifted into obscurity and was replaced by easier to use applications like Face Book and Twitter. The real key to those two entity’s success wasn’t just their easy to use applications though. What made them become what they are today was the easy access to the instant. Their ability to be addictive. Like a drug.

Most of us are aware of the fact that the need to be socially accepted is a powerful force. Sure many of us like to believe that the opinions of others aren’t relevant to how we see ourselves but this is normally us being dishonest with ourselves. The need for social acceptance is practically written into our DNA as a species. For a significant part of our evolution being socially accepted in the tribe was what decided life or death. The tribal configuration is our evolutionary stable model as a species. Like dogs in packs, cattle in herds, lions in prides, etc. In today’s society we don’t tend to outwardly acknowledge this as a huge player in our survival as social creatures. Yet we create political groups, sports groups, gangs, even identities based on music genres. When we are liked it feels good, when we aren’t it feels bad, when we are accepted or part of a group it feels good. What’s behind that good feeling is one thing. Dopamine.

Anytime we as human beings find ourselves being liked or praised or accepted we experience a small hit of dopamine if we see the praise or acceptance as personally rewarding or fulfilling. Dopamine is a powerful neurotransmitter that acts as a messenger between brain cells. When you have that amazing slice of cake and it feels good that’s dopamine, a cigarette after a meal and that settling nicotine hit is our friend of dopamine again. Alcohol, cocaine, marijuana, MDMA, all cause huge spikes in dopamine production. The same goes for that repetitive song you may like or television program. Dopamine helps us to repeat actions that we find rewarding so we will repeat them again. This of course is crucial for us as a species so we know where to find food, water, and want to reproduce.

In many ways our need to feel accepted and rewarded is easily hacked. Trent Harris who is the former design ethicist for Google said that traditional feed structure on social media sites is patterned off of slot machines. You never know if you will be rewarded by the content, but the chance you may keeps you coming back much like gambling. Neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky has done extensive research into dopamine’s effects on behavior. Sapolsky used monkeys as test subjects. He taught them that if they were to push a button ten times a light above the button would come on and a treat would be given, each time measuring the dopamine response in the small primates brains when they were rewarded. He then changed the set number of button pushes to a random sequence where the reward would arrive at 5, 20, 8, etc button presses. The more random and more anticipation the monkey was subjected to the higher the dopamine spike before it even received the treat.

The same thing that kept the monkey pushing on the button to switch on the light is the same thing that keeps us refreshing the page to check likes on a post, pulling the slot machine handle, pressing like, waiting on a response to a text etc.

But how is Steemit a potential pioneer into the frontiers of the dark side of social media? Adding monetary reward to an established addictive behaviour is the answer. Tokenising approval. Could it be that Steemit is a testing or proving ground to measure the effect so that the next platform can be streamlined to make the user experience more addictive? There are many platforms out there at the moment who are already positioning to compete in the tokenised approval economy to do just that. Face Book has even voiced the desire to dip a toe. Could this be because the combination of combining monetary reward with the reward of social approval is recognised as an incredibly potent formula? Could be. Data is the new oil/gold after all.

It may seem that I’m bashing Steemit here. I’m not. I enjoy using the platform. Through it I have met some truly wonderful people from who I have learned a great deal and interact with off of the platform. There is a light side basically. I do like the lack of censorship, the self regulation, community mined people, the content… I happily admit I feel rewarded when I engage. I am selective in what I post about my personal life, understand after reading the user agreement that my data is being collected, can be sold on by Steemit, and am not to fussed. Their not going to pull messages and contacts off of my phone like Face Book or track my location outside of my IP. Basically as far as invasiveness goes it’s no different than E Bay user terms and agreements in my opinion so not bad all in all.

But is it possible for all the positives to someday be outweighed by the negatives in tokenising social interactions? Should we use things like Twitter and Face Book as examples in how these platforms grow and impact people? I.e. going from being entertaining, to part of a lifestyle, to a vital apparatus in social interactions, to altering how we socialize as a species? Is that already a byproduct of social media today? What will adding money to the mix do?

I’ve always believed people should live how they want to as long as they leave me alone and don’t force their choices on my person. Or their views. Legalize everything, let people be responsible, share what you have and be humble in the sharing. I basically prefer kindness and freedom over regulation and cynicism. I’m not being cynical in this post by the way. I’m pointing out that there are dark possibilities and really look forward to hearing from you guys on what you think in the comments. I try to keep up with comments and vote for meaningful ones as my way of saying thank you spending the time to read. I also try to check out the blogs of those who comment as it’s a rewarding practice and I tend to do it as a bit of a Steemit habit. It usually turns up cool posts as well. There are some great people here.

Well guys that’s it for now. Thank you so much for taking the time to read my humble post. Many blessings and as always Steem on.

image credits:
Youtube
Washington Post
Trak.in.com
BigNewsNetwork.com

Sort:  

I’ve always believed people should live how they want to as long as they leave me alone and don’t force their choices on my person.

That is something a lot of people believe, yet we must still be a minority, because it seems like everyone wants to tell everyone how to live, what to eat, where to go, and what to speak, except of course when it come to them.

Here here my friend. I know a lot of people wish for things like wealth or popularity, but most if not all of my wishful thinking is geared towards just wanting freedom and simplicity in life..... and a quite place to fish from time to time of course. lol

Hi @mudcat36! Happy to see you are back. I hope all is well with you and your family. :)

Steemit does remind me a lot of Myspace..the beginnings of social media. Let's just hope Steemit will become the "FB" of the time (in terms of endurance) and not fade into history like Myspace.

Be sure to get your steemmonsters cards. They will be hot!

I've been hearing a lot about the steem monsters thing. It certainly looks interesting. Hopefully we keep having awesome ideas like those springing up on Steemit. Good to hear from you bee. :)

I hope so too @mudcat36. That would indicate steem is flourishing if developers/investors are willing to dedicate their time. Nice you hear from you too! :)

It's a very complex thing @mudcat36.

Steemit reminds me most of sites that date back to the origins of blogging; the first "social blogging" venues back around 1999-2000.

It was the birth of the "interactive" web; the idea of commenting was born, and people kept stories online and shared their lives and there was dialogue and interaction. Xanga, Diary-X, LiveJournal, others...

MySpace (first) and then Facebook were the game changers. The "social" part was distilled down to tiny "blips" instead of full-blown conversations. Social blogs didn't work so well for teenagers... too much work to get your dopamine fix. Hence the success of MySpace.

There are a lot of people on Steemit who miss those social blogging days... the sitting down and telling a story or sharing a well-crafted opinion piece, and then having an ongoing dialogue with your "subscribers." That's a large part of why I am here.

The "old" social blogging format and the new "short" format of MySpace and Facebook was — as much as anything — a generational split. Let us remember that MySpace came along at a time (2005) where it was just becoming (financially) viable for kids to access the web "in bulk." In earlier times, not only was "owning a computer" a $3000 proposition, but monthly Internet charges were HIGH.

Something was "lost" around 2006-07 when social blogging started its death spiral. Xanga — at its peak around 2005 — hosted around 32 million bloggers. They were left without a "home." I hated MySpace and FB... it was just "meaningless fluff" and a giant contest of who could accumulate the most "friends."

Meanwhile... these things are deliberately addictive. They have an entire FLOOR of developers at Facebook who go by the title "retention specialists." Their job it to make very single interaction as "addictive" as possible.

Steemit isn't that sophisticated, but they have the gamification of social media down, by luring people with "a few cents trickling in." It may not make much logical sense but it works on the same psychology as tossing a handful of coins into a crowd: People scramble madly to "get their hands on some," even though a few pennies and nickels have NO material impact on their lives.

It's what we do, as humans. Is it "dark?" I don't know... but it makes for interesting discussion!

=^..^=

Wow. What a beautifully written and thoughtful commentary on the post. Thank you for taking the time to create it. It brings back memories of shouting at people to get off the phone so the internet would work and a walk into the era of constantly being asked if one was on Face Book and listening to the pissing contest I used to hear those around me getting into on there friends numbers. I remember when these platforms really exploded in growth and I couldn't help but see them as an inconvenience. Later in life I saw how much of a persons time they held the potential to devour and the more negative impacts and I went from seeing social media as an unnecessary inconvenience to developing a dislike for it. The analogy of tossing coins into a crowd is incredibly apt. I must admit that monetary gain didn't lure me to Steemit but rather curiosity that snagged me. I've invested in cryptocurrency for over the past 6 years so seeing a content sharing site built on a block chain really caught my eye. I do wonder though how monetary incentive for content will play out in the long run in social media though. The drive for acceptance is a primal instinctual urge and logic doesn't always play a roll. The same with greed as pointed out in the analogy of tossing coins into the crowd. Logic takes a back seat as you said. Gustave Le Bon once said that in a crowd the individual disappears and that the surgeon, cobbler, and brick layer posses the same amount of intelligence. Group think gone frenzy because of a shared stimulus. Crowds when focused on a single shared point of outrage or positive stimulus like a sports team winning for instance behave erratically and chaotically. With social media sites strictly based on personal approval of ones self and ones acceptance of ones own person reinforced by the crowd the sharing is limited though it's sharing that provides the reinforcement. ... Well it can look that way and there's certainly a lot of lonely people with a lot of followers on Face Book. But the drive to gain wealth or a better word.. greed. That's a shared single focal point for most of us as human beings that can move us to frantic in many ways. Adding that to the mix could produce some very interesting results in the future in regards to how people interact through these platforms and in society. This isn't me saying monetary incentive in social media is going to cause mayhem on the streets or anything extreme, but it's certainly going to have interesting results if/when it grows to mass adoption. Hammers build hammers break. I suppose it depends on how we use them. I'm heading over to your blog to check out your content. Thank you so much for reading my post btw, as well as the wonderful commentary. :)

Hmm MySpace.. That platform drove me away from social media back in the day. The spam was just too much. And not a day went by that something got hacked, The MySpace suicide machine was is an epic tool to get rid of the account, it is interesting to see that the machine still exists and now also caters for MySpace Twitter etc. The problem with Steemit is that a suicide also would disconnect the creator from his/her data. And then there is that wallet, That always links back to the owner.
Banks used to have bank secret to provide 'privacy'. And all that does NOT exist on steemit.
In a way the transparency is great to find the scammers but it comes at the cost of the privacy OF EVERYONE. So privacy is not the best topic to compare Steemit with MySpace, there are differences but privacy is hard to find. :-) Don't forget to add discord in the mix, and how discord uses the email protocol... Privacy nightmares episode 11.

I do not agree with the steemit privacy policy and TOS, so thats why i now use busy. I'm really missing the dark theme as the light Busy theme triggers dopamine warfare in my brain.
The thing is this: A website should always respect everyones privacy wherever they are on the planet, and should NOT require ANY exceptions. So may i say it?

STEEMIT PRIVACY SUCKS!

There you have it.
And this is exactly why I refuse to agree with the privacy policy.

Adding money to the mix, and a set of keys that isn't really scam proof. O and also a wallet that everyone can open and see someones 'wealth' still feels horrible to me.
In a world where kids commit crimes for sneakers...
Now give those kids a steemit account and you have the recipe for maffia at the playground.

It is a double edged sword, we need transparency to be able to catch the bad guys. But it should NOT be at the cost of everyones privacy.

Back when we used dialup and BBS people solved their own issues. Back then politicians did not beleive in the internet and even dismissed it. We (old and boring politicians) don't need that geeky stuff, so nobody will ever need it. And they ignored the crap out of if. Nowadays you can't even make an appointment at cityhall without communicating, using an outdated email protocol that isn't even encrypted... So we don't even can make an appointment in privacy. And how handy, they also have logged your email address, and IP. And National Security also gets a copy of your appointment.

Privacy first.

What a great response! I would happily celebrate any service that protected user data as the first priority or didn't rely on selling data to third parties... just like I'd celebrate an honest politician, the discovery of elves, Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny being real, etc. I look around frequently and just feel a combination of disenfranchisement and disgust at where we are going with technology. The ability to be deeply interconnected yet it still is used to keep shit show practices on auto repeat from business practices to the individual. It doesn't feel like privacy is dying, it feels like it's dead in many ways. I couldn't agree more with your response. I'm certainly going to check out busy as I keep hearing good things about it. Thanks for the both the great commentary and sparing the time to give the post a read. :)

Ultimately a team of people with a goal that is just (not merely good intentions) should be formed and efforts should be made to create a platform that respects humanity by default. Instead of twisting and turning like worms bureaucrats to write up lame exuses to ignore BASIC HUMAN RIGHTS under the guise of a 'policy'.

I think the net should have a system like TOR as default. But then a system that does not have a military background. Problem is that arpanet (the system the internet is build opon) is the same ARPA as in DARPA.
Then something like steemit should rum like a kind of .onion site. And accounts should be able to securely log in without leaking any personal information. End to end privacy by default.
Right now every company, home or cellphone is part of a worldwide military network, we need a network thats build by the people.

@mudcat36 is is ba-a-ack!!! 😁😁😁

" I am selective in what I post about my personal life, understand after reading the user agreement that my data is being collected, can be sold on by Steemit, and am not to fussed. Their not going to pull messages and contacts off of my phone like Face Book or track my location outside of my IP. Basically as far as invasiveness goes it’s no different than E Bay user terms and agreements in my opinion so not bad all in all."

I was a bit put off by those new terms of agreement but happy to see you say you don't feel their as invasive as facebook - the fact that my info can be collected and sold for marketing purposes is annoying to me but it gets me thinking of the future and the possibility of the social crediting system coming online here in the US.. it's worrisome to me but as one person there is not much I can do about that LOL

I haven't been on in a while but started using busy to get on steemit because those new agreements made me weary. Glad to see someone who knows a bit more about it say that they are not terribly invasive, though.

Nice post as usual @mudcat36

Hi @amariespeaks. Happy to see you on too! I hope all is well with you and we start seeing you around again. A hi here and there will do. In case you are not ready to come back, I will wish you a happy summer with plenty of sunshine with your family. :)

@beeyou my dear! how are you? I hope everything is going good :) I have been sporadically jumping on here and discord. Inching my way in when I've gone a spare minute or two! We are having a wonderful summer, doing lots of fun things outside. The weather has been great over here. thank you for asking <3 <3

All is well with me @amariespeaks, thanks for asking. ❤️

Busy summer too and enjoying the sunshine. Happy to hear you are enjoying family time. It is always great to see you and have you spread your cheerfulness. One inch, two inches..come back when you are ready. :)

Holla @amariespeaks! Long time no speak! Lol. I've been away for a bit so getting back into the swing of posting. Yeah, at this point I'm not to fussed. Every where you look user agreements are going to snag details that if we could and still use the product we would just say no. Over here in the UK and Europe internet censorship is invasive but there's not really a willing public in regards to resisting anything. So what used to be "I Agree" is now I comply. I hate it personally. Living on an island like Orwell did seems appealing at this point. lol. I dropped you a message in discord yesterday so give me a shout as and when. Glad to see you're still about. :)

I definitely hate it too lol but it seems there is no evading it at this point. oh, I've replied to your discord message :)

Very provocative post. I always worry about the future of any platform that has the potential to collect so much about us. But, selling info is better than giving it away, I suppose.

Nice article @mudcat36. I think people will tend to do whatever they can to get their dopamine hits regardless. The disturbing factor is that they are writing about this in their whitepaper and are seemingly exploiting the psychological trait intentionally.

"The economic effect of this is similar to a lottery where people overestimate their probability of getting votes and thus do more work than the expected value of their reward, thereby maximizing the total amount of work performed in service of the community. The fact that “everyone wins something” plays on the same psychology that casinos use to keep people gambling. In other words, small rewards help reinforce the idea that it is possible to earn bigger rewards."
steem-whitepaper.pdf (page 13)

Thank you for reading. I sometimes think for these players in social media it's a case of if we don't exploit this then someone else will come along with a product and do it at some point. But I hope that the monetizing of social approval doesn't become dark. Great excerpt from the WP by the way. :)

To the question in your title, my Magic 8-Ball says:

You may rely on it

Hi! I'm a bot, and this answer was posted automatically. Check this post out for more information.

Siapa yg ada main steemit kalau mendaftar link di bawah ini akan mendapat uang dolar

https://steem-byteball.org/#OU7YURVUKD6PV5SVU544BNIGBI5ZEYSF

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.15
JST 0.028
BTC 61940.19
ETH 2433.78
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.50