Steem: Where DOES the money come from?

in #steem6 years ago (edited)

And the Answer To the Money Question Is...

So the natural inclination of those who visit Steem is to wonder who's giving out the money? Is this monopoly money? How does this all work? Many are naturally skeptical. Some may just dip their toes in the water. Others might dive in and ask questions later. Whatever the case, almost everyone probably wants a better idea about the theory behind Steem dollars, so here is a brief explanation:

A blockchain-based software network creates Steem dollars, to be used as currency, from loans on the value of Steem digital assets. Steem digital assets represent the ownership of this software network and have value because they're useful and they are scarce.

In general digital assets can be used as money, act like company shares or be used to access specific digital resources. The more people use any particular digital asset, the more they are worth. The estimated value for various digital assets can be found on the website The website lists digital assets that are collectively valued at over $12 billion and growing and many of these digital assets like Bitcoin have value because they are both useful and scarce. The question just becomes how useful and valuable are each of these assets? Most people have a hard time understanding how something digital can have that much value. Isn't software easy to copy, corrupt or hack?

Digital Value? Beginning of Virtual Economies.
In the last decade, multi-player video games with virtual economies have demonstrated that digital goods have real world value. Some may treat video game items like collectible baseball cards. Others may find video game items useful to improve their virtual lives and satisfy a material, emotional or psychological need. Scarce items such as powerful weapons in a medieval fantasy game called Diablo or gold in World of Warcraft can take hours to find, earn or accumulate so they become valuable. In fact a game item in Diablo 3 sold for as much as $16,000. Many people have bought and sold virtual gold and other game items on World of Warcraft for dollars or exchanged them for real world goods. In the game Second Life, users create virtual characters, live in a virtual world and buy things like virtual real estate. Linden dollars, the virtual currency used in the game Second Life, are also traded for real dollars. One estimate of the secondary market of real money changing for digital goods was $2 Billion as early as 2007. This was just the beginning of virtual economies.

Is it Secure and Who Owns It? From Video Games to Bitcoin in the Real World.
The establishment of Bitcoin followed an independent path from the video game industry, but the value of virtual items and currencies had already been demonstrated. However with video games, game creators ultimately controlled the supply of these digital assets. If a system were to be created for the public, the control of the system would have to be more decentralized. There were also some key technological issues that had to be addressed to create digital money & asset systems that are secure & decentralized enough for broad public use as explained here: “Bitcoin: What Took Ye So Long? Bitcoin became the first real world experiment with blockchain-based money. Ever since the Bitcoin currency started in 2009 with unknown speculative value, it's since grown in value from millions to hundreds of millions and is currently estimated to be worth over $10+ billion. As mentioned earlier Bitcoin and alternative digital assets in total are estimated to be around $12+ billion. All this value is stored digitally on a network of computers using software. No banks or institutions are required! Today Bitcoin and other digital asset systems are practically impossible to hack or corrupt because they use advanced consensus mechanisms and military-grade cryptography.

Isn't Software Easy to Copy? Intangible Value
Digital assets are easy to copy or replicate. The same goes with software platforms. However, most of the value of Silicon Valley tech giants are intangible and rooted in the network effect. The more people that use a system the more valuable it becomes, and value increases exponentially for every new user that is added. Take Facebook or Twitter for example. The cost to develop the core software for each platform is probably in the millions using the latest technology. More than likely Facebook & Twitter can be built with hundreds of thousands of dollars and really crude versions can be built for tens of thousands. Many software developers can build a lot more for less because of the advancements in software technology, tools and open-source libraries. But even if a technological product were easy to replicate, would you expect copycats to be worth $330 Billion like Facebook is now or $10 Billion like Twitter? The brand, network effect and the psychological attachment people have to a particular product are all huge competitive advantages. Those are the same reasons that Bitcoin and other digital assets maintain value even when the technology is easy to replicate.

Furthermore creating sustainable business value is not just about the product. Just because you can cook a tasty burger doesn't mean you can create a business and take over McDonalds in a few years. If you can mix up a nice combination of soda ingredients it doesn't mean you'll dominate over Coca-Cola. McDonalds has been around since the 1940's and is currently valued at over $100 Billion and Coca-Cola started in the 1880's and is now valued at over $200 Billion.

Digital Assets – Money? Commodities? Stocks?

Money is what something is used for, not what something is - Daniel Larimer

Sea shells, beads, cows, real estate, tobacco, gold and silver all have been used as money at some time or another. The definition of money is subjective, but various commodities or assets have been used as money at different times in history, and in different situations and geographies. We have 180 government or bank issued currencies being used today. Some commodities or assets have better characteristics as a medium of exchange, store of value or unit of account, but any community or ecosystem can ultimately choose what they want to use as money.

Some of these new digital assets like Bitcoin can be seen as monetary commodity assets. Other digital assets are required to access or use a system's resources. For example, Ether is required to execute smart contracts on the Ethereum network and Safecoins are used to access storage on the Maidesafe network. Some digital assets are similar to company shares such as the DAO or Bitshares.

Digital Assets & Money in the Steem Ecosystem

The Steem system is built on secure blockchain software that run on computers. There are three types of assets in the Steem ecosystem. Both Steem and Steem Power are analogous to company shares. A third asset, Steem dollars, are created as a loan on Steem collateral and issued to contributers to the ecosystem as currency.

Steem is similar to publicly traded company shares. The amount of Steem doubles each year so there is signficant dilution for those that hold Steem, however like many fast growing startups a rapid increase in value may outpace the dilution. Just like company shares (ie. stocks) these digital assets have value as more people use and contribute to the ecosystem. The estimated value of the total outstanding Steem assets is currently about $20 million on

Steem Power
Steem Power is similar to private restricted company shares and have disadvantages and advantages. One disadvantage is that holders can't sell Steem Power immediately; hence they are illiquid. The advantages of Steem Power is that holders:

  • May earn more Steem and Steem dollars as dividends to offset any dilution
  • Have voting power to determine the value of each post.

Steem Dollars
Steem dollars are assets that are created from loans using Steem/Steem power as collateral. If the Steem ecosystem is worth $20 million, the Steem software can create one million in dollars as a loan on the network and issue it as currency for circulation. It's the same as if you owned Apple stock shares worth $500,000 and created a $25,000 loan on your shares and used that as money. You can use similar mechanics with real estate. In fact commercial banks create money this way. Just think about home equity loans and then think about regular home loans and how banks use real estate as collateral to create fiat money.

The blockchain software network executes the entire loan process & interest provisions for Steem dollars and the issuance & allocation of new Steem/Steem power.

A blockchain-based software network creates Steem Dollars, to be used as a currency, from loans on Steem digital assets. Steem digital assets have value because they're useful to a growing Steemit community and are scarce.

Remember we're still in the early stages of this digital economic evolution and much of this is experimental so it's good to keep your expectations measured. That said, might as well jump in and write about your interests, have fun and enjoy the ride!


Thanks for a good post.
But isn't it possible that steem dollars can "go bankrupt" if the value of the assets drop by 95% or more? In a normal market it would be a total fluke event. But in cryptos extreme moves are much more common.



Hey thanks! As the market value goes below a certain point less Steem dollars are created. Currently there is only $3million in Steem dollars out of $465million in value so that's less than 1% so it would have to go down 99%! Also even if that were to go down that much you get a certain amount of Steem collateral that may be temporarily worth less, but you'll still have something. Just like if you backed money with real estate the real estate value may go down and you may end up getting the real estate collateral instead of money. Eventually the real estate may be worth more.

Thanks for such a informative post...

For Steem to really take off it just needs to copy youtube's video format and keep the decentralized anti-censorship aspects.

And that just happened. Check out

steem dollars or any cryptocurrency value totally depends on demand if everyone cashouts steem dollars it will eventually go down.the bitconnect tokens that were given to its investors as an exchange to their capital while it was shutting down is a good example ,

like any other currency in the world

Just a little due dilligence got me to this old post, but nonetheless it is good info. Anything that can be digested that helps anyone to understand the mechanisms that make it all work are good. Thanks in arrears!

As a bonus, a 10% annual interest rate is awarded to Steem dollar holders.

If I have understood right, there is no fixed interest rate. It can be changed by witnesses so it can adapt to market conditions if necessary. This might be good to make clear so that people don't feel like they are betrayed when they get some day less than 10 %.

Ok thx @samupaha! I'll remove that for now. I thought I heard the 10% interest somewhere, but the whitepaper doesn't specify any fixed rate so you're probably right.

10% is just the default value but @samupaha is correct it can be changed by witness vote according to market conditions.

Thanks @steemrollin ! Brilliant and simple way to explain what is Steem starting from the very roots of the digital value.

I still wonder though: each time I upvote a post, where the money comes from? Who finances the upvote as it does not come out from my own wallet apparently?

Is it Steemit, backing the value on Steem and Steem Power?

Could you bring some light on this matter? Or anybody else maybe =)


Have you found an answer already, as I am wondering about the same.
In addition, where the money will come from in the future?

Hi @Alczak, unfortunately nope...

The financing comes from the reward pool. Each day a certain number of new tokens (Steem) are mined and distributed to creators and curators of quality content. The creators and curators receive this in return for contributing to the blockchain. The tokens have a monetary value because they are a commodity people are willing to exchange fiat currency for. That’s my understanding anyway, I’m fairly new to Steem so I could be wrong.

Hmm, but I don't see anyone wanting to ditch steem once they start blogging, they have invested time and hard work, therefore the market is very unlikely to crash. A brilliant idea!

This clears out a lot of things but the Steem Dollars part still confuses me.

You said SD are loans created from collateral of Steem/SteemPower. Does that mean The company or whoever creates the loan is liable to someone else who provides the loan? Who provides the loan? Is the person/entity who created SD in debt to someone who provides SD? What happens if the person/entity can't clear the loan?

Is SD an IOU like it's mentioned in this video?

@tshering-tamang I like Mike Maloney and consider myself a goldbug too and the video has many good points, but also misses a few concepts. Yes there are many things wrong with the current traditional fiat/central banking system, but that's another huge topic to discuss. With Steem, the software network distributes new Steem just like the Bitcoin distributes new currency to miners. Part of the allocation of new Steem is used to create Steem dollars. Let's say hypothetically the Bitcoin network wanted to issue Bitcoin dollars instead of issuing just Bitcoin to miners. The Bitcoin network could created 1 new Bitcoin and then create a loan on the Bitcoin of $35 and issues that to miners. Miners now have $35 in Bitcoin dollars backed by a Bitcoin that is worth around $700. People would be extremely comfortable with that. The Steem network does something similar and tries to maintain the debt level at 5%. That's very conservative. In the modern economy banks sometimes create fiat money at 100% loan-to-value (LTV) meaning if real estate prices go down banks have less collateral to back some of the money that they created in the past.

The Steem software network could be designed to just issue you Steem directly. However when you eventually sell $1,000 in Steem to someone else it could be worth $800 or $1,200. Instead the network issues you $1,000 of Steem dollars based on $20,000 worth of Steem collateral so you don't have to worry about the volatility.

Thanks @pharesim @cryptoctopus and @steemrollin This makes a lot more sense. The blockchain issues SD immediately after Steem is created at a very low debt level at 5% locking up the created Steem for collateral. Got it.
And, the SD is non-volatile since 1 SD = $1 worth of Steem. The number of Steem we can get for SD can change but the value of SD won't change.

Interesting subject. The concept of money and value are like matter and anti-matter, with today's global economy this thought has become fuzzy. Here I give my own opinion on how value has become underrated.

Does bitcoin create new currency? That wasn't my noob understanding that bitcoin "farming" is really just processing bitcoin transactions, and the bitcoin "farmed" is really just a processing fee. The number of bitcoin is finite, and no new bitcoin are produced in farming.

If this is true, this is why bitcoin is a good store for wealth. It doesnt suffer inflation or "quantitative easings" like governmental currencies.

That being said, I'm still curious about steem creating new currency. Mathematically, wouldn't this devalue currency at the same rate its created?

Yes miners process transactions and put them into blocks, but they are rewarded a new supply of Bitcoin with each block that is mined. The supply for each block is halved every four years. It started with 50 new bitcoin per block and currently is 12.5. Hence the inflation decreases over time. I have to double check what Steem inflation is, but it may be in the same ball park as Bitcoin.

SD can only be created by the blockchain itself. New Steem are created and immideately locked up as collateral.

I love the video... I have been giving this some though. Steem differs from Federal reserve notes like this:

  • First and most significant for the long term: Steem does Not charge interest to those that use it. This is not an obvious risk which is a big reason for the scam the video mentions. When you charge interest on every dollar and try to add it up, this is never ending every increasing aks compounding debt! Charging interest on a core asset is a guarantee that that money can never be paid back. Almost instantly and for eternity more money will be owed than is in circulation. This means it will have an out of control never ending dept. This is the scam used by centralized banking.
  • Steem prints money only on behalf of the steem platform using well known and well understood rules. Our chain does not print money to pay anyone royalties. The royalties come from holding assets like Steem or Steem Power in the hopes that it will increase in value. It does not do this to pay "owners" or founders just because and for doing nothing. For this reason Steem is like a non-profit. Instead, owners and founders usually do hold shares and reserve the right to sell them.
  • Steem is not a monopoly. Users are not forced to hold it.

Finally (probably a re-cap) .. Dilution is really cool because it is so efficient and seamless. It is the best way I know of to help distribute growth of the platform and share price back out to active users and content providers. So, just buying in and holding and getting very rich can now be offset a little by re-allocating some of those profits to new active users. When you re-allocate you are basically forcing a re-investment. That re-investment can in turn offset the dilution if it triggers growth and demand. That only happens in bull markets, even during the bull markets prepare for the bear markets and make profits by providing content. When you see full circle like this you can simply just average everything. Large movements in price don't mean much it is only the average that matters. Additionally, we have the Steem Dollar where it is undesirable to invest and price stability is needed (to pay others, for base expenses or liabilities, etc). Welcome to self-made entrepreneurship, enjoy the ride!

IOUs are not bad in their essence...the concept was used even when people were bartering. It is how they are created and who is backing them that make them of good quality or bad quality...same thing for derivatives.

This is exactly what I was looking for. I was confused as to how Steemit would be creating value of underlying assets for its Steem and Steem Dollars and this explained it simply and beautifully.

Thank you steemrollin!

I feel like I've stumbled upon the next Facebook, mixed in with the Stock Market! It's exciting! I'm still trying to wrap my head around the money concepts though. Thank you for this informative article.

Yes it is exciting! Glad to hear you like it and see you around!

Brilliant, touches on all the key points :D

The best explanation of how the money works in Steemit. Bravo!

Even though this was published last year, it is still very useful and informative for new users like me. Thank you for writing this!

Awesome! I was looking for exactly this post last night. Much appreciated.

Thank you for putting these concepts together.Nice article!!!

Absolutely fantastic. Thanks

Thanks for this Nice post of "Where DOES the money come from?" am new to the platform, but to know how the network makes there money as being what was on my mind, but with this i could see that greater things shall i do
Once again Thank you

Hi, Thanks for this post. It is clear and interesting.
I have a question though :

Where does Steemit value come from ? What are the factors determining its market cap ?

If you take Wordpress, Google or any companies, its value will be determined with its capacity to produce cash, to sell ( ads with apple and wordpress, phones and computers with apple ).

Is Steemit going to sell ads, is it not going to be free in the future ?

It was my first comment on this platform and I'm glad it was on you're helpful post !

The value is given to it by the users. The price in USD is determined by supply and demand. The market cap is just a useless number in USD, as far as I know. It's just the average value of one unit times the amount of units.

The value of Google is given to it by the users as well. If no one uses it, the value goes to zero and so does the price of the shares. Value is not what is it worth in USD. That's just the price. Price and value is not the same.

Google also doesn't "produce" any cash. The central bank does. Google just takes a part of it by producing ads and selling them.

The concept of Steemit is a bit different. It produces Steem - not Dollars. Steem is generated by the Steem network - not by a central bank. When you cash out, what you do is to exchange Steem for fiat currency, like Google when it sells an ad. The difference is that you can't use the ad or Google stocks to buy something else.

cleared many things. thank you so much for the article. you defiantly deserve my upvote.

Glad to help!

Thanks for a great article. I was wondering where all the steem came from and you answered the question perfectly!

Why would anyone choose to carry on creating free content for Mr Zuckerburg?

What an interesting post! This was very informative.

This should be an official Steemit source to put it easy for those of us starting to steem.

I found this article from user "mind over" article about steemit. I am a new comer so rather than post an article for the starter i might as well read good articles such as this that answers a lot of questions on my mind. The article where is the money coming to buy writers here is what i want to know.

this information is very helpful. i now understand what im in and cyber world now :)

Interesting piece!

Followed and resteemed! Answered a lot of my questions on how STEEMIT works!

Glad it helped and thanks for the resteem!

Great post I can now explain this more concisely to friends/family as where does the moeny come from is a common question that people want an answer to... Also, how about the interest rate on SD?

Glad you like it! Yeah I removed the interest rate part to simplify things. Interest rate is set by the witnesses and initially is at 10%, but can change. The interest is paid from a reallocation of value from Steem/Steempower to Steem dollars.

Amazing post and thanks a lot

BOOM! Bang on the money... pun intended. Definitely will be a reference point I will be using and sending people to.

What a great job explaining ! Thank you !

Thank you! Glad you liked it.

would money still exist in the future?

Finally found a post exactly what i am searching for.
good read. thanks for sharing
you answered most of my questions.
cheers buddy.!

Thank you @steemrollin, this made it all clear for me, very much appretiated.
Have a nice day,

Being a Steemit noob this is very helpful. Thank you for this info!

Thanks a lot for the informative article @steemrollin. As a newbie on the platform here, this really helps me understand the way STEEM works in the background, which leads me to wonder why many other websites (eg: reddit) did not take this route much earlier!

Awesome articles steemrollin - I have upvoted most of your posts and added them to a collection of useful articles I am putting together for newbies. Check it out here and definitely let me know if there are other articles of yours I have missed. Thanks!

Brilliant. You had me at "loans on the value of Steem digital assets."

Thanks for this. Suddenly made so much more sense!

Glad to hear!

Thanks fr this post, it has really made me understand the ins and outs of steem currency. For a newbie like me, it's invaluable!

The blockchain software network executes the entire loan process & interest provisions for Steem dollars and the issuance & allocation of new Steem/Steem power...

which means, to my understanding, block chain software executes all the processes regarding only digital assets like steem, steem power and steem dollar but SNS network itself?

In other words, is operating as at the same way as the other SNS networks do like Facebook or Twitter. Am I right?

Thank you so much for answering my dilemma.

Steem/Steem power Is the assets of the Steem eco system
People are trading their Steem for SD to protect their selves from volatility
Once Steem Increase In value, This way Steem eco system has more $ to provide content contributors ? and All runs In DAO ?
Thanks so much for the effort. <3

When the amount of "Steem" doubles each year, does that automatically cut in half Steem's value? I'm still trying to understand this. Thanks for writing and sharing this article.

Informative post. I was searching for this.

Thank you so much for this explanation. With every read I feel I'm understanding this more and more.

Thanks man, great post!

Fantastic post bro! Answered many of my questions.

I realize that this is an older post, but a fantastic post regardless! It was very informative, and a pleasure to read. Thank you for your effort. I just started a few days ago and I'm really excited about the Steemit community.


I mean the founders

Thank you for this very informative post; as a newbie learning the ropes I need all the help I can get to understand the Steemit platform, and your post has helped.

Thank you so much for this article, exactly what i was looking for, my account is about 3 days old and trying to understand how it all works and then my partner says to me" yeah but you are happy to drive the car without knowing how the engine works!!!"so very true, anyway i am so super excited about this platform and you have just helped me greatly, steemrollin, much love

Glad to help and have fun on this platform!

Nice work... Thanks you so much

I am new to steem and this just answered so many questions. I'm mostly commenting so that I can look in my comments section and be sure I can find this article late. Thankyou so much!

Thanks, I'm quite new to steemit, and this really helped a lot in making things clear!

Couldn't ask for a better explanation.

I finally understand how this works. Great time to be an engineer :)

I read the post as well some comments with response however still have confusion and not going to be clear on steem, steem power and steem dollar & then how to cash the steem dollar in money. Can you clearify me in sample words further plz.

Great article in explaining how Steem works using real-world example! Thanks.

Cleared all my doubts

really interesting! Thanks for explaining so well, really informative! I got interested in Bitcoin a year after first began, and almost got involved, but I didn't... happend to a lot probably :/ started last year to invest in to various coins... working out... let's see

Don't worry, you're still an early adopter to Bitcoin and crypto!

Thank you so much for this. I was looking every where for a comprehensive answer, and this was it.

Dear steemrollin this is a masterpiece and elucidates further on a lot of questions provided very cognitive and precise answers. Very lovely and good write up. I am so delighted to be part of this steemit community with clear cut direction.

Greatest post on SteemIt!! thank you

Being that you are making actually money from the site, is Steemit required by law to give annual tax statements or income receipts to users who've cashed out Steem into dollars?

An older post but still helpful to those trying to understand how this all works. Seems like the platform has been going a while and continues to work so that is a great sign. I wish I had heard about Steemit earlier!!


Great explanation. I can see the effort you put in to structure it beautifully which makes it an easy to read as well as understand. Thanks for sharing.

This is one of the best breakdowns of Steemit economy and the concept behind it.

That was tremendous! Thank you for the understanding of the basis and how it is all calculated.

You're welcome. Thanks for reading!

Hey man, I have been researching a lot on steemit and where money comes from? My understanding is that Steem Dollars are created from loans on steem digital assets and Steem digital assets have value as it is helpful to a growing number of users.

In simple term, one way they get money is by people buying steem power to promote their content. Is there any other way they get money?


Thank you so much for this amazing post!

Is there a maximum amount of Steem coins that will be created (like Bitcoin has 21 million bitcoins)?

How does Steem mining work? Does it use proof-of-work or proof-of-stake algorithm or something else? Does the mining reward decrease over time?

If newly created Steem is given to content creators and people that hold Steem power, what incentives do the miners have?

By curiosity, do the developers of Steem, Steemit and DTube have a salary? If there are no fees, where would the money for their salary come from?

Thanks for the intro post!

Thanks for your informations, i'm new to steemit btw

Thank you for all the helpful advice it's my first week on Steemit and I feel like my brain is getting fully reprogrammed.

You have answered all questions in my head and learned many things. thank you @steemrollin

thanks a lot for giving this because it helps me to attarct me more then before thanks steemit

I have been reading your articles to understand steemit myself and find your content very very helpful.

I just followed, looking forward to more content :D

Don't like reading all that much, but this post just kept me entertained the whole way through!

My main concern about Steem is that there doesn't seem to be anything backing the currency. Dollars are backed by the US government. Shares have dividends. What's keeping steem from being completely bubble based? I'm vaguely aware of a card game that uses steem, but what else? Can steem really support itself on a card game alone? I guess what I'm asking is, what's stopping steem from turning into a bubble?

Value is only set by the public.

still interesting today! Where did you go?

thank u for the great explanation !

Hello, are you looking to earn extra cash? Earn money by paid surveys and etc. I recommend Clixsense. Free to sign up by clicking below link.

Solid article. I was about to post a similair post. Not sure if I believe in the current crypto investment climate but I do believe in the blockchain. We do need to look better at the insights of every coin. What team is behind it, is there any management. How strong is the product, is there any product at all? Besides there is: They give great insights in the team, the product, advisors, community, the business and the business model and other techincal insights. For example: To watch Steem Detailed analysis.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.27
TRX 0.07
JST 0.034
BTC 24114.41
ETH 1903.21
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.30