Why Steem is unique in the Cryptosphere - A comparison of the features and history of the current top 7

in #steem8 years ago (edited)

Cryptocurrencies Chasing Money

In the top 7, we can see where the money sits in the Cryptosphere right now.

Market Cap Rankings of Cryptocurrencies

  1. Bitcoin has the biggest share because it is by far the oldest, and its blockchain immutability is the strongest because it has the most onerous PoW algorithm.
  2. Ethereum and Ethereum Classic have positions in the top 7, because of their potential, right now the value is speculative because there pretty much is nearly no actual dAPPs to speak of. The DAO went down in flames and people are still holding out for better apps to be built, but I think in the long run, while its programmability is a massive advantage, it is also a serious vulnerability - What is the Killer App?, is what matters. What will propel adoption? If Ethereum is just a blockchain/smart contract toolkit, its currency is way overvalued, and in fact, I think it will likely fork again for other reasons related to this.
  3. Ripple - Again this is a factor of age. Really, Ripple is an odd one out in this list, because it is not really in the same category. It is a payment network, alone, nothing more. Its success has been mainly about how it has facilitated opening avenues for payments. So this is also why it is doing quite well. But not spectacularly so compared to the ones under it.
  4. Litecoin - Basically this is bitcoin 2.0. The changed algorithm to scrypt reduced its asic exploitation, and it was one of the very first alts. There is a new crypto coming up soon called zCash, which has an even more asic-resistant PoW, it literally practically limits hashrate by memory bandwidth, which entails an entirely different approach to mining. zCash will be mineable by anyone in idle downtime, so it will never be short on hashpower. It also will be the first to implement Zero Knowledge Proofs, enabling the blockchain to be immutable but not reveal any data about who exactly has which coins, or who they sent them to, only that they moved.
  5. Dash is the number 7 on this list at the moment. Dash is somewhat similar to Steem, in that it has a redistribution system. Dash allocates part of mining yields to the developers. The idea is that this makes the system self-funding. Dash is also the first to implement instant transactions and uses a similar system as Steem Witnesses in order to lock transactions in quickly before there is any chance of pushing a fork for a double spend.

Steem really is unique amongst these 7 contenders for the most investment funds in the Cryptosphere. It actually already has an anti-volatility smart contract (Steem Backed Dollars) and an interest-bearing long term smart contract called Steem Power. No other crypto has these measures built in.

Steem does not need to have funding specifically allocated to developers like Dash does. The developers participate in the competitive redistribution system on the forum, and because of their influence on the way the system works, they naturally gain a lot of votes because it is of interest especially to Whales, who have the biggest stake in the system.

In Dash, also, the marketing for the platform is also taken care of by the developers, who take part of the inflation from new mined currency, and divert it to this purpose as well. Steem, by contrast, farms this work out to each and every account, people can promote, or demote, the system as their opinion dictates. This is a model that resembles the Open Source community, and that itself is indeed the foundation of cryptocurrencies as a whole.

Application developers who are putting work into extending the platform also contribute significant value to Steem. Instead of centralising this process as Dash has done, instead, anyone with an idea, programming skills and the time and patience to do it, can create applications based on the Steem blockchain. If they make good money out of it, their idea is probably good and this will lead to further improvements from talented developers.

This does not have to be limited to the this blockchain. It can include both external centralised and distributed databases of various kinds that combine together with the central blockchain. I have a design for this, and I am sure I am not the first to think of it, and I think there will be a lot more of this. My proposal is aimed mainly at improving scalability of the discussion forum by adding filter mechanisms, so that people can fish out the stuff they are interested in, and ignore the rest. My idea allows for the possibility of a possibly fragmented, garbage-collecting chat system, that distributes chats through a blockchain, while not requiring massive storage to keep it, by expiring old posts. There could also be some kind of ranking system devised as well, that uses memberships and some kind of reputation system that help to further improve the behaviour of people on the system.

Others could devise sidechains that vest Steem in other ways, implementing more smart contracts than the existing ones. The Steem token, the volatility hedge Steem Backed Dollars, and the interest bearing Steem Power are not the only ways that contracts can be implemented. It is just the simplest ones. Others could create other ones that vest steem in other ways. It could back a blockchain secured system of lending or insurance, for example.

Unlike all others except Ethereum, Steem really is designed to be added to, and filtered. What you see now is not the end of the design, the designers are just focusing on their part, the core, and if the core works well, it will naturally accumulate additions. Unlike Ethereum, there is a basic set of financial instruments that are intended to diminish volatility and encourage retention of investment

There is a lot to be said for the genius of the design, in my view, it is headed for the moon. But not alone. Precisely because it is a social network.

The reason why Steem could move up the ladder, in my opinion, is because it takes into account investment strategies, it hedges against volatility, the development is entirely voluntary and paid for within the framework of the forum system, those who invest in it are incentivised by the outcome of their yields to be or hire good curators to help improve the content quality, and those who produce the best material tend to rise to the top.

Furthermore, there is no reason why some cryptocurrency systems cannot team up to enhance their respective userbases. Ethereum and Ethereum Classic, and Bitcoin also, have built in programmability that could assist in accelerating the development of collaborative subsystems that boost both platforms. But Ethereum/ETC have the problem of an overly complex programming system, and Bitcoin's is very simple but the development community is quite in gridlock over changes. Steem, on the other hand, could integrate these features more easily if the need was seen, since it is so new as yet.

Though there is something of the same developer gridlock in the core in common between Steem and Bitcoin. Subsystems don't necessarily have to be built on immutable PoW blockchains to be value-adds. Many aspects of Steem do not need this, since they are adjuncts to help regulate behaviour and the voting process in ways that do not directly depend on the core infrastructure.

Steem has both marketing, labor for development, and standard types of investment instruments built into it. This is what attracts investors. It will take time since the platform is still in development, but it's off to a running start already.

Sort:  

This is a good article but the front picture is bad why don't you make a Jpeg of the seven currencies and call it comparing the top 7 why Steem is unique. Also tag crypto-news dash ethereum instead of development etc.

I'm not sure how to go about making something eye-catching for the top image. The chart needs to be in the article. I have this idea of personifying each coin's logo with stick figure legs and arms all running after a $ sign or something. Well, I'll amend that. Try something like that. I made all the other changes you suggested, thanks for your suggestions.

Nice this is much better.

If you don't mind I might use this pic to promote your post.

Hell to the YEAH. I have been doing a lot of thinking amongst this and reading discussions not just here but elsewhere, and I think I really need to gather a group of developers. I am targeting Python, and Python has wide applicability. Maybe not on the mobile platforms, but on all desktop/laptop systems. I think there is a lot to be said about improving Steem's market penetration by enabling this class of users. I just need more python specialists especially in Mac, Windows, and Qt. If we could all get this moving forward quickly, we can implement the essential features that will make this more accessible to new users, enhance the curation process by giving users the ability to filter their feeds more, and improve the overall image of the platform by encouraging a lot more small investment. 100 whale sized investors can have a big impact here, but 100,000 minnow sized investors with 50 bux each, it's still 5 million! We need minnows. We need users. Some users will be investors.

I just read what you wrote. I am deeply grateful for your support :)

Looks like no one read it. Oh well I did have some luck doing this one time.

It's only 3 hours since I posted it. You never know when the whale will jump in and make a vote. My first time I didn't pay attention to who did it, wandered into the trending feed, found a thread where they were busy posting, and roasted them. It put a big ding in my balance just 2 hours before payout.

I am not so much motivated by capturing the short term - indeed I have several dollars of late votes on numerous old posts. I will be happy if this one racks up enough that I get paid enough Steem that I can sell the Steem for bitcoins and load my wirex debit card. I have a little more money coming in next week, most probably, and my pay from my last two weeks at my job, which should cover me for rent.

But anyone who disparages me for thinking I can buy the time to contribute winning posts, is badly mistaken. I am also trying to buy time so that I can focus on developing applications. In my newest post I show that a bit over a day ago, a post I made about an issue with the website has had someone in development take notice and maybe soon a sorely absent feature in the website will be implemented, proper user blocking.

here: https://steemit.com/steemit/@l0k1/effective-post-filtering-by-user-is-coming

Writing vote-winning posts is not the whole story. If you can improve the website with your ideas, above is an example of progress towards such a goal.

For steem to move up the market cap there will need to be more demand for steem, you havn't explained how to achieve that? As it stands sells are overpowering the buys and it's been like this for 3 weeks...so unless the whales slow down or we create more demand for steem then the market cap is heading down which is not necessarily a bad thing since a low price allow for faster distribution

Well, I thought I had covered it, so I amended the conclusion at the bottom to directly summaries my reasons for believing this. It needs to be understood by investors that part of what they are getting for their votes is development. To stay ahead and continue to move forward, the accessibility and utility of the platform must continue to progress.

But the fundamentals, of a marketplace in votes for ideas, while entertainment brings minnows, what brings the Whales is development and marketing that sells the benefits of the platform. We certainly need a lot of the former, but they also bring scalability and moderation problems with them. The latter will be put off by failures to address these issues, but this can also be ameliorated by the development of new ways of accessing it and additional features not in the core forum system.

Sure, I think the developers of the website could stand to possibly improve the website, but nothing is stopping anyone from making apps. Without mobile apps, there will be a lot of impediments to adoption by those schools of minnows. Without filtering systems the minnows will spend too much fighting and not enough digging up the gold at the bottom of the tank. Without a good group/moderation and chat system, development is slowed by the difficulty for people to find each other and work together.

All of these things are happening.

Adoption doesn't necessarily mean demand for steem. Steem's slogan is "blog, get paid" and new users are expecting "free" rewards when they sign up, most users won't buy steem power. Adoption rate may bring in some new investment, but if the price keeps decreasing the adoption will also decrease so it is very important to create demand for steem or a better incentive to not sell ( a marketplace), maybe you have some ideas? I think user promoted posts could be a good start, similar to reddit users would be able to get their post trending by paying for it with steem, the steem could be sent to a burner address so that they don't hit the market ever again. This will increase demand and decrease steem supply so it's healthy for stability of the platform.

Your point about promoting your own stuff, you can already do that with Steem, just throw in surplus cash you have into Steem Power. You could even directly promote my work by sending steem into my account, that I could vest into steem power and increase my ability to push my material higher up.

Steem is a very minimal platform, and while it may seem like this is a weakness, it is actually a strength, if people organise groups to fund development of enhancing projects that help bring more in. There is developers making a mobile platform already, this would be huge for bringing in userbase.

I think actually the core anti-volatility and interest bearing smart contracts will eventually prove themselves to be effective. The price of steem against a falling bitcoin price, is difficult to properly assess. If you look at the different trajectories of all those cryptos pictured in the picture in my article, you can see that bitcoin as a metric for Steem is not entirely indicative of the situation. More avenues to exchange out Steem than Bitcoin already exist, and will become more important.

I don't think that the forum itself, is core to the success of Steem, but rather the built in smart contracts and the way it is distributed. It is not a recipe for fast growth, but slow and steady. This is explicitly stated in the Whitepaper and it is smart. We don't want steem to be a flash in the pan, we want it to burn like a nice slow combustion stove. This makes it good for investors, and more money in the pool means more rewards for contributors, in the long run.

We can't sit on our laurels. There is several other distributed forum platforms in alpha and will be released in a few months. We are all stakeholders in this. I have more than quadrupled my share in value on my account in 2 weeks, and the more I hold, the more I am invested in keeping this going.

edit

can't comment because under this is too deep in the thread (limit is 4). You make a very good point about ethereum being backed by computation and this is why its' market cap is bigger. The same criteria can give you info also why Bitcoin is so big. It requires a lot of electricity to implement it.

This speaks to something that I have been saying for a long time: that the backing of the cryptocurrency has a big impact on its market capitalisation, alongside its beneficial architectural features.

in fact, Steem, almost literally is backed by Time. Its' structure of smart contracts delays gratification, and this is partly to stop pump-and-dump abuse and to reduce the bad press of high volatility. As someone who has tried to profit from trading with bitcoin, I can attest that the volatility of bitcoin is incredible. It is reduced in the case of the giant chinese exchanges with their high volumes, but after my experience with EUR/USD exchange rates back in 2008, the volatility makes profitable trading impossible.

Your other point about temporary upgrades. This makes a lot of sense too. 10 bux and I can be at the top for 2 minutes. This is a good idea.

Your point about promoting your own stuff, you can already do that with Steem, just throw in surplus cash you have into Steem Power.

I mean paying like 300$ to get a spot on the trending page for 12 hours, do you know the influence I will have if I power up 300$? Nada,niet. Even if I power up 10 000k ( which i will never have ) my post will only increase a few cents.

The price of steem against a falling bitcoin price, is difficult to properly assess.

What exactly are you arguing?

You know why ethereum has such a high marketcap? because the currency is needed to executed code on their blockchain so people know there will be demand for it, with steem it is not entirely clear why people would be buying it as an investor isn't it something that you are questionning?

Very well written. Love Steem. Just posted first few things yesterday. Will move some of my BitShares over here into Steem.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.14
TRX 0.12
JST 0.024
BTC 51981.11
ETH 2334.35
USDT 1.00
SBD 1.97