Thank you! The roll is back in its place for the next time. The goal is not to punish or to be cruel, the goal is literally to teach him that he needs to learn to plan for things happening. Getting toilet paper is a minor thing, going and delivering a spare tire to him 50 miles out at 3 in the morning while he has a wife and family in the car in the winter is what I'm trying to teach him how to eventually be able to cope with beforehand. :)