RE: You like Scary Movies? What's Your Favorite Scary Movie? Here's my list of favorites and why
My favorite scary movies from your mentions are among my favorites and they are : The Shining (1980), Rosemary's Baby (1968),The Babadook (2014) , Alien (1979), Psycho (1960),Lost Highway (1997),Scream (1996), Don't Look Now (1973).
I made another list with movies that I find them scary and are not mentioned by you and I hope you will find some that you have not watched yet: The Entity (1982), It Follows (2014), Audition (1999) aka Ôdishon, Paranormal Activity (2007), The Orphanage (2007), Halloween (1978), The Conjuring (2013), The Conjuring 2 (2016), The Ring (2002), Eraserhead (1977),
Inland Empire (2006).
I have not seen: The Haunting (1963), The Exorcist (1973), Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978), Misery (1990), The Blair Witch Project (1999), Fat Girl (2001), Red State (2011) and those from runner ups.
Great article @vincentnijman which helped me to find some movies which I think I will like.
It is impossible to remember and name all my favorite scary movies but I have seen and enjoyed The Entity. I don't remember that I found it very scary.
It Follows is on my to see list.
Audition is one of these movies that I find too nasty/ painful to enjoy and rewatch. So I did not mention it. I experience that with many Asian movies. Especially with movies that involve some kind of torture, bodily mutilation.
Halloween (1978) is one of my many favorites too, the same goes for Eraserhead. I don't find the latter scary, so I did not mention it.
All those movies you haven't seen are definitely worth watching ;)
Have a nice day!