You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: A Small Village vs A Big City: A Short Productivity Analysis
My preference has been for communities about 150,000 - 200,000 in size. They are big enough to have diversity, culture, comprehensive public services including transportation. Yet they are small enough to get around by bicycle and to get out of town or across town in just a few minutes.
I've lived in smaller and larger communities. The key I found, for having a small town feel in a big city, is to have a neighborhood focus. Cities with clear neighborhoods can really maintain that small town feel, with local stores and community centers. I got to know my neighbors just as well as in small towns.
You are trying to get the best of the cities and the best of the towns and small villages. Seems like these mid sized communities are within that sweet spot. Thanks for the opinion! :)
You're welcome. It's an interesting discussion.
Yeah.. I might research some facts and post a new title around the subject. @allfabeta has inspired me and I had some deep deep thoughts about the homestead perspective of the issue.
There are definitely a lot of different angles to the discussion -- overall society, energy and material flows, economic efficiency, food security, adaptability, vulnerability, individual perspectives over different age groups, social networking. Lots to think about!
Hah.. agree. To be on the safe side, one should just share his own personal point of view.
It gives you a lot to write about, too! :D
Yeah, once day when I become urban/population scientist I'll change my style of writing and explore all the options you were talking about! :)
Yeah, I see your point. I'm in an area where sidewalks are optional and there are no shoulders on the road for safe walking. And even then it's MILES to town and at least 1 mile to the nearly bus stop. Still, I like the woods for peace of mind. There is something to be said about the vibe of a community. My currently neighborhood is a landing spot. The vibe here...? Well, let's just say I can hear arguments nearly every day from someone's house. The funniest thing was when one of the neighbors said, "I don't have to listen to you. You ain't my woman!"
I nearly fell out! hahahaaa (get me out of here!)
I can imagine your response to that neighbor's comment! Yeah, each place has its advantages and drawbacks. But the woods are always a nice place for an attitude adjustment!