I guess it depends from woman to woman. I myself fall in the same group...humor is what always got to me. That skillful way of twisting words making a plain thing sound hilarious. Yet i have quite a few coworkers who go by appearance card. Nothing wrong with that. We are simply attracted to different stuff i guess. Biology is a funny thing.
Oh far be it from me to say no to a handsome face...but they need more than that to go past the first five minutes, 'cause after a while...fine, you look good, but what else can you do? :D