A phenomenon called Patriotism

in #libertarian6 years ago

I have been thinking about writing this article for a long time, but the last drop was a bunch of yelling drunkards with Czech flags drawn on their body. I met these guys on the way from work during the first third of ice hockey match of the Czech Republic and Canada, which they probably missed somehow, although they were very well prepared for it; not to mention countless fans dressed in Czech ice hockey team’s outfits and the impossibility to go by car for a few minutes without seeing a car with a flag on it.

I have nothing against hockey, I like looking at this game; I appreciate the quality of the game, good hockey players as well as professionals in (almost) any other field. But I do not understand the meaning of the ubiquitous Czech flags (or a reason why receptionists of one corporation wear hockey jerseys); absolutely incomprehensible to me is the phrases: “our boys” or “Come on Czechs, we will win together!”... Why “our” boys? In what sense should they be mine, for example? And what does it mean “together” in that context? What share of a possible win would all the “Czechs” have?

These questions lead me to a bigger question about patriotism itself: why should I be proud that I am Czech or why should I be proud of what other Czechs have accomplished? What did I do for it apart from being born here? And the overwhelming majority of Czechs are not in a different situation. If somebody gets a citizenship based on their effort and endeavor (such people are there), I understand that he could be proud then. But where is the reason for pride of the others who are citizens just because of randomness? Not only they did not have to do anything for it, but they even got the citizenship before they could choose anything.

So where does patriotism originate? Although it is a concept of pride of something for what we do not do anything, which is essentially an oxymoron, the patriots are everywhere (and there are even more of them in the times of world championships in all kinds of sports). There are two main reasons I think: the first is government-controlled education – because patriotism is very much utilized by the government, thus they implement this to its citizens in their childhood; the second reason is probably some genetic equipment that encourages us to be cohesive with the troop. Our species survival in the past times may have largely depended on this instinct, so some of us may apply it on the whole nation or even the state. Of course, there may be other reasons... maybe the two reasons above may not be as important as I think. But I cannot come up with any rational one.

However, the crucial question – regardless of the possible causes of the patriotism existence – is what is this property good for and for what is it not? I see only one real advantage of patriotism (and it is quite questionable): people who have done nothing, for what they would be proud of, in their lives can create this pseudo-pride towards the nation; I find this contentious because I would say, that some individuals may lose motivation to actually do something in their lives. All other “benefits” typically include circle arguments, for example: we need patriotism to maintain our language and culture for our descendants; the answer to the question why this is desirable, of course, somehow refers back to patriotism.

The disadvantage is an easier manipulation by their own states that often like to be identified as nations; the good patriot is then willing to tolerate many things done by the government, to support its policy of protecting “domestic” companies and other regulation. The best patriot then takes a gun in his hand, and goes killing strange people somewhere the government sends him because he does it for his beloved nation, which must be true when politicians claim that. Of course, I don’t say that this would apply to everyone; I have no doubt that there are also reasonable people among the patriots.

That is why I think that it would be desirable to distinguish two diametrically different things: if one comes to patriotism because he likes the history of some nation, its culture, habits, landscape, or maybe the local cuisine, it is a simple preference based on taste, so just like many have their favorite music, food, place, this person just like some nation; it is completely different when one becomes a patriot because he has been manipulated since he was a child, because such a person has a solid basis in his head for further manipulation. Distinguishing these two cases is, in my opinion, almost impossible in most cases; on the other hand, I am afraid that between patriots dominates those who, to a certain extent, have succumbed to brainwashing. Why? Well, preference based on taste should be somewhat random (of course, not entirely); but how many “patriots” would be “loyal” to other country than the one where they were born? Some definitely would. It is, of course, certain that some have come to loving their country based on their taste and preference. Everyone else, however, is a victim of insidious manipulation (and there are many of them, because there is just very small proportion of “patriots” that love “foreign” countries who must be the product of non-manipulated choice due to the variety of tastes).

Two conclusions result from that. First, I would like to recommend to all patriots to think more deeply about their patriotism; I do not claim that this must be necessarily be the above case, but there is probably a considerable chance that you have been manipulated (and it may be easier to manipulate you further). Secondly, it is a question for parents whether they want to lead their children to patriotism; I understand that some have love for nation deeply in their heart, but: isn’t it better for your descendants if they come to such things by themselves than if you force them (in their early age) to respect flag, anthem and so on? Isn’t the chance for later manipulation (for example, by politicians) much lower when they know why and what they really love?

Another articles

Česky: https://www.mises.cz/clanky/fenomen-zvany-vlastenectvi-1785.aspx
Author: Urza

Who is him?

Urza is Czech anarcho-capitalist author, he has written about thousand of libertarian texts on the web and printed media and also the first Czech book on anarcho-capitalism. He lectures at schools and conferences, made a number of videos and is often invited to many discussions.


Just decided to stop by and see what you're all about...

I visited Prague in the Past and even picked up a U.S. Five Dollar Gold Coin, that I spotted, while walking around Old Town Prague...

Everyone likes to feel like they are a part of something, much bigger than themselves...

During my stay, I did see the Flags you mentioned...

They seemed to be Celebrating a Game Win...

But even being a Patriot of your Country of Birth, we all face a lot of Division, while growing up...

One side of the Class Room against the other...

One Class Room against the other...

It goes on and on and on...

Anyway, thanks for the up-votes I've been seeing...

Always feel free to comment, if you have any questions or answers...

August 11, 2019... 15.6 Hollywood Time...

Thank you for the good article that has made me study and understand the attitude of the author better and understand more. This article makes me learn what I never knew. Thank you very much for the good article.

Great article. Rarely do we explore « patriotism ». Resteemed.

Posted using Partiko iOS

Congratulations @laissez-faire! You have completed the following achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of upvotes
Award for the number of upvotes received

Click on the badge to view your Board of Honor.
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:
SteemitBoard World Cup Contest - The results, the winners and the prizes

Do you like SteemitBoard's project? Then Vote for its witness and get one more award!

Patriots look at their nation's culture versus others, and in solidarity to love their country, feel proud about making it better etc. There is nothing wrong with patriotism. Proud to be Czech looks pretty favorable and worthy vs Cambodian where there is a total dictatorship for example and no human rights.

thx 4 the upvote!

AlphaOmegaEnergy (aoecoin) the World's #1 Breakthrough CleanEnergy Startup is going on the Blockchain this year with 2,922 new techs.

  • We are doing a Seedround on Blockchain
  • Paying 300% Fixed Return Minimum to our Investors as a debt note.
  • Pre-sales are open now DM to invest.
  • We will be building power plants with our world leading technology, as an asset backed Blockchain. We are mining with the power we make, and building an electric plane and several scalable social enterprise divisions as well.
  • We are securing the Seedround chain also with 100% collateral in shares of the company and a debt note. We have every receipt practically in triplicate.
  • Make a Big Return helping us CHARGE IT ALL! And Change The World!!
  • We will Comment your post, follow, and or up vote every time you support one of our posts or make positive comments! All promoters send me your win-win services & solutions!

Can visit our steemit and check us out!

We changed The World.png

Sorry I am so late in commenting on a VERY excellant article. It raises questions that I have not thought about for many years. It also provided answers, or the path to an answer, to the questions.
Here, in the United states, we are kind of taught from birth to "Love your Country" and only submit to it's leadership. Thankfully I had very early on "free thinking" parents. They showed me "Love your Country" but "think for yourself". Hence, I guess my "Patriotism" was late in developing.
Keep up the good work, NEVER give up the good fight, be careful!

Patriotism is to love your country...
Global Illuminati are opposing this trend as much as they can.

me gustan mucho esta clase de temas, creo que hoy en dia laas personas confunden el patrotiotismo con el hecho de ser fanaticos de deportes, creo que ser patriota va mas alla del simple hecho de apoyar a tal seleccion de cuakquier deporte, el ser patriota es sentir a la patria en las venas luchar y defender los intereses nacionales, y luchar por el crecimiento y el desarrollo de tu pais, desde tus capacidades . saludos muy apreciable concepto, y discutible. ;)

Thank you for the good article

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.30
TRX 0.14
JST 0.039
BTC 62161.87
ETH 3424.20
USDT 1.00
SBD 4.90