I received my power down today about 3 hours after the HF and also had 5 weeks to go.
Thanks to @justinsunsteemit and his sockpuppet witnesses I could reduce it to 4 weeks.
Perfect!
I start to like sunny-boy - he helps to promote hive and helps us to leave steem even quicker.
But I find it a little bit unfair that he gave 64 steemians/whales the possibility to power down even quicker to bittrex.
Well, I guess it was not his intention but a stupid mistake.
What the hell is going on here? Can anyone clear that up for me? :( Are every (good?!) people powering down STEEM now and leaving the blockchain? If yes: why?
I would appreciate a link or something to do some readings about this.
Hi @xchng,
well, that would be a complete book to write.
In short:
Many people walk away from steem to hive because steem now is a centralized place run by one person (Justin Sun with his sockpuppet witnesses) with censorship and theft of stakes (23.6 million steem if I'm not wrong).
Yes, they are. The reason is mostly technical: because the Supreme Overlord of Steemit Inc has enough voting power to decide every single top witness. Secondary to that because that power is being heavily abused. If the accusations of the abuse are true or not (I'm pretty sure they are but Justin Sun will lie about this as long as he lives), a blockchain under a constant 51% attack is not a blockchain, it's not safe. That has been corrected with the HIVE fork, where we all are now. This can still be an interesting community but it's being censored as heck and it isn't technically a blockchain any more.
First a question (you DO NOT need to answer on this, if you don't feel comfortable with it): Do you have a reputation of only "3", because of your opinion against STEEM and all of their actions, maybe? Just asking because you seem like a "professional account" from here and such a low rep is very unusual, isn't it? 😳
I already heard about the abusive use and the thing about the witnesses. But: I always thought that Justin intends to "rescue" STEEM, since here was a big censorship going on with an unfair curation-system? Hard for me too see through all these trees where the forest is lol
Thank you also very much for your help! Will try to see things as objective as I can :) Will take a look on this! Thanks!
I used to have a reputation of about 47, which is now 48 on HIVE. I am as surprised as you are, afaik it comes from some recent downvoting on me trying to help people out to understand better what is happening. I don't really care.
Justin honestly needs a narrative. Looking at the facts it doesn't match up. I think the censorship people refer to is basically just minnow posts not really reaching much people, i.e. a discoverability problem. That is not censorship though. After Justin stepping in there is actual censorship happening though, that is really scary to see. The worst of that is that the posts involved are actually invisible. What I have seen a system is used where 1 day from posting the post remains visible, so people basically contradict censorship is happening in that time "because I can see the post", then it disappears. It's technically still on the chain, but to have it turn up you need to have the direct link to it, which you might be able to get through e.g. steemd.com. Most HIVE prime witnesses are censored like that.
Also, Justin focuses 100% on a social narrative, what most people are sensitive to. That is how the story keeps people supporting him, because they feel heard. I understand that need of people and actually on the HIVE side there is a lot of work going on to make people better heard etc so I kinda expect this to be solved over time. What Justin hides with this however is that 100% of the voting power that has the "community witnesses" in power comes from what used to be the ninja-mined stake, the Steemit Inc stake that was not meant to be used for voting. It is proxied through a puppet account, but the full voting power comes from him. To someone else (@heimindanger of d.tube fame, see my comments on his HIVE account) I described normal DPoS voting as the equivalent of e.g. an electoral college. Some people are more in charge of others, but a vote is going on for several people. Several people vote for a smaller group of people. Everyone technically participates, but the people with the bigger stake have more influence. This is by design.
What is difference on Steem in the current construction is that by engaging the ninja stake for voting, we have one person choosing everyone in charge by proxy. In governance terms this is a puppet state. If HIVE is an oligarchy, this is a dictatorship. You could still see this as a proper form of government, but just as much as for a government you wouldn't call this a democracy, the resulting chain is not a blockchain. This is a problem that hang over Steemit from the start and some ex-Steemit developers already wrote some code to possibly correct this problem, the work of whom has been used to prepare the HIVE fork. This is why Justin is so adamant to call that cutting out of the Steemit Inc stake a theft. If it had been left in the fork, he would be able to immediately do the same kind of hostile takeover. If the people who supported his puppet witnesses in the time up to the fork would not have been cut out, they would have wrecked so much havoc the first days of the fork that it would result in an immediate failure.
Sorry this comment got so long, I hope it explains enough to have you well updated about everything that happens, and to avoid possible censorship on my guerilla information actions maybe make a copy of this post if you want to show it to others...
... because those accounts were already frozen, and if the funds were sent back, the owner would still not be able to withdraw their Steem since Justin was already holding their Steem hostage, even though they could view the balances.
Yes Ma'am @canadian-coconut but those users certainly have accounts in exchanges where they can receive their individual liquid steem.
Now it is still unsure if Bittrex will do the trouble of giving either to the affected parties or back to steem because of the issue of consensus regardless of the stake being stolen.
Oh, I thought that you were talking about sending back to the Steem wallets.
I think that "Robin Hood" was worried that he wouldn't have enough time to sort out all of the Bittrex account #'s, before Justin Sun might discover what happened and somehow regain control of the community account. Plus he may not want to expose who he really is, which he would have to do in order to ask people for their Bittrex account #'s.
Yes that might be the case, to secure the stake before Justin Sun could get hold of the account again before this "Good White Hat Guy" could sort out on how to redistribute it again. So they now have to hope that Bittrex would give it back not to the last owner community321.
For my opinion Bittrex will choose to give it back to the latter because again of the consensus factor.
Yes, the robbed all of my accounts. They are just after money only. They took @mottler money and he hasnt been active in 4 years. No ones money is safe on Steem, it has become a centralized database run by a 3year old with a ninjamined stake.
"You see? There are still faint glimmers of civilization left in this barbaric slaughterhouse that was once known as humanity. Indeed that's what we provide in our own modest, humble, insignificant - (sighs deeply). Oh, fuck it."
Am I really the first one with a none-bot comment? 😂😅😂
Thanks so much for taking this action!
EDIT: hahaha profile picture and background - HILARIOUS!!!
Here is the thing: Moving the funds back to Steem would only put them back under Justins control. It would be better if the affected would create @bittrex accounts and keep their fund on the exchange.
And then slowly selling them so the price won't drop too badly.
I am ecstatic that you used the word "you're" instead of "your". This type of genius is uncommon on the internet.
I think is the best thing that could have happened to Steem. If the Steem community really just wanted to be rid of those built hive and those who...were included for unknown reasons, then they have done that. Now, they can go on about their business.
At this point, or the point in which bittrex gives the funds back to the account holders, everybody should be squared up. Justin has his funds to use unfettered in governance of Steem. The old witnesses and a few randoms have their Steem to do as they wish. Seems like a good point to make the clean break that many seemed to hope for.
The "owner" is technically community321, and Bittrex basically flat out said they would return the funds to the "owner" if proof is provided. You are just too fucking dumb to understand what they mean.
Robin hood wouldn't send the money to @bittrex and ask them to work on re-distributing it.
You could have created new accounts for each stolen user, and send them the keys with an encrypted memo.
Chinese are retards to make this account with anonsteem (basically they don't know about account recovery), but you are equally stupid. You aren't even anonymous ...
I dont know, but seems like steem witness are now running another update, seems to me like they do whatever they want and they do have 20/20 sock puppet...
Quit acting like you agree with this you absolute fucking idiot. You said the Hive witnesses fired the first shot and understand why Sun took the actions he did.
Please follow @dpet for upcoming events.
Our discord channel is up and running, come on over and say hi, lots of avil pet owners are awaiting you there. https://discord.gg/GYrnsNm
Am I really the first one with a none-bot comment? 😂😅😂
Thanks so much for taking this action!
EDIT: hahaha profile picture and background - HILARIOUS!!!
Unfortunately it is no longer steem to transfer. Because of your fok .
Can you tell me when it is possible again? You would be very THANKFUL.
I hope it goes on with Steem would be a real pity about it.
love greetings MAX
This text is translated, so don't be surprised if it sounds funny
Hi!
It's a great day as I have the privilege of meeting you here! But since you are interested in something built on the blockchain, would love to see you on Commun as well: https://commun.com/askcommun/@support/1589882559. There you can set up your own community with your own token and get donations from the first day 😇
I don't know what else to say! I'd pay a whole Bitcoin to see the tantrum Justin probably threw when he found out about this. Not only Is he a shitty businessman, apparently he's a shitty criminal too. 🤣
/salute 100% - I'd give you a big fat upvote if Justin Steemy didnt take my Steem away!
Just wait for the mother of all dumps about to come very soon. You'll be able to pick up some nice and cheap.
🤣🤣🤣
There you go Dan, I've got a big upvote for you...
I upvoted on your behalf and behalf of everyone else who's funds got stolen.
Consider yourself blessed, I'm stuck with 5 more weeks of powerdown - and your Steem is now in much better hands than it was just hours ago! :D
5 more weeks? Haven't you heard about this amazing new feature on Steem called the 4-week powerdown?
I received my power down today about 3 hours after the HF and also had 5 weeks to go.
Thanks to @justinsunsteemit and his sockpuppet witnesses I could reduce it to 4 weeks.
Perfect!
I start to like sunny-boy - he helps to promote hive and helps us to leave steem even quicker.
But I find it a little bit unfair that he gave 64 steemians/whales the possibility to power down even quicker to bittrex.
Well, I guess it was not his intention but a stupid mistake.
:') I could use a 10-minute powerdown too.
Hi @pundito mate.
What the hell is going on here? Can anyone clear that up for me? :( Are every (good?!) people powering down STEEM now and leaving the blockchain? If yes: why?
I would appreciate a link or something to do some readings about this.
Thanks in advance guys! ♥
Have a nice day!
Hi @xchng,
well, that would be a complete book to write.
In short:
Many people walk away from steem to hive because steem now is a centralized place run by one person (Justin Sun with his sockpuppet witnesses) with censorship and theft of stakes (23.6 million steem if I'm not wrong).
So most people move away from steem.
CU around!
Hi @pundito,
thank you very much for your information mate!
Will keep an eye on this :)
Greetings and a wonderful weekend! ❤️
Peace
XCHNG
You too have a wonderful weekend :)
Just read a bit like https://peakd.com/hive-181335/@lukestokes/wmjtrllk where @lukestokes made a great video and has some interesting links about the situation.
Or read this statement from a lawyer: https://peakd.com/hf23/@apshamilton/pro-bono-legal-opinion-for-victims-of-steem-hf23-and-bittrex
Please inform yourself about the latest development @xchng! Especially the statement from the lawyer says a lot!
It's important for everybody on the chain!!!
Yes, they are. The reason is mostly technical: because the Supreme Overlord of Steemit Inc has enough voting power to decide every single top witness. Secondary to that because that power is being heavily abused. If the accusations of the abuse are true or not (I'm pretty sure they are but Justin Sun will lie about this as long as he lives), a blockchain under a constant 51% attack is not a blockchain, it's not safe. That has been corrected with the HIVE fork, where we all are now. This can still be an interesting community but it's being censored as heck and it isn't technically a blockchain any more.
Hi mate and thanks for your information!
First a question (you DO NOT need to answer on this, if you don't feel comfortable with it): Do you have a reputation of only "3", because of your opinion against STEEM and all of their actions, maybe? Just asking because you seem like a "professional account" from here and such a low rep is very unusual, isn't it? 😳
I already heard about the abusive use and the thing about the witnesses. But: I always thought that Justin intends to "rescue" STEEM, since here was a big censorship going on with an unfair curation-system? Hard for me too see through all these trees where the forest is lol
Thank you also very much for your help! Will try to see things as objective as I can :) Will take a look on this! Thanks!
I used to have a reputation of about 47, which is now 48 on HIVE. I am as surprised as you are, afaik it comes from some recent downvoting on me trying to help people out to understand better what is happening. I don't really care.
Justin honestly needs a narrative. Looking at the facts it doesn't match up. I think the censorship people refer to is basically just minnow posts not really reaching much people, i.e. a discoverability problem. That is not censorship though. After Justin stepping in there is actual censorship happening though, that is really scary to see. The worst of that is that the posts involved are actually invisible. What I have seen a system is used where 1 day from posting the post remains visible, so people basically contradict censorship is happening in that time "because I can see the post", then it disappears. It's technically still on the chain, but to have it turn up you need to have the direct link to it, which you might be able to get through e.g. steemd.com. Most HIVE prime witnesses are censored like that.
Also, Justin focuses 100% on a social narrative, what most people are sensitive to. That is how the story keeps people supporting him, because they feel heard. I understand that need of people and actually on the HIVE side there is a lot of work going on to make people better heard etc so I kinda expect this to be solved over time. What Justin hides with this however is that 100% of the voting power that has the "community witnesses" in power comes from what used to be the ninja-mined stake, the Steemit Inc stake that was not meant to be used for voting. It is proxied through a puppet account, but the full voting power comes from him. To someone else (@heimindanger of d.tube fame, see my comments on his HIVE account) I described normal DPoS voting as the equivalent of e.g. an electoral college. Some people are more in charge of others, but a vote is going on for several people. Several people vote for a smaller group of people. Everyone technically participates, but the people with the bigger stake have more influence. This is by design.
What is difference on Steem in the current construction is that by engaging the ninja stake for voting, we have one person choosing everyone in charge by proxy. In governance terms this is a puppet state. If HIVE is an oligarchy, this is a dictatorship. You could still see this as a proper form of government, but just as much as for a government you wouldn't call this a democracy, the resulting chain is not a blockchain. This is a problem that hang over Steemit from the start and some ex-Steemit developers already wrote some code to possibly correct this problem, the work of whom has been used to prepare the HIVE fork. This is why Justin is so adamant to call that cutting out of the Steemit Inc stake a theft. If it had been left in the fork, he would be able to immediately do the same kind of hostile takeover. If the people who supported his puppet witnesses in the time up to the fork would not have been cut out, they would have wrecked so much havoc the first days of the fork that it would result in an immediate failure.
Sorry this comment got so long, I hope it explains enough to have you well updated about everything that happens, and to avoid possible censorship on my guerilla information actions maybe make a copy of this post if you want to show it to others...
https://peakd.com/hf23/@apshamilton/pro-bono-legal-opinion-for-victims-of-steem-hf23-and-bittrex#@brianoflondon/re-apshamilton-qaqkkd Legal Advice about the situation agrees with me.
Don't worry man. Sell off all your steems and focus on HIVE when you get your coins back.
I would consider it as Justin's plan if bittrex doesn't transfer the funds to their original account.
I wonder why he didn't distribute it himself back to the owners to avoid red tape @theycallmedan
... because those accounts were already frozen, and if the funds were sent back, the owner would still not be able to withdraw their Steem since Justin was already holding their Steem hostage, even though they could view the balances.
Yes Ma'am @canadian-coconut but those users certainly have accounts in exchanges where they can receive their individual liquid steem.
Now it is still unsure if Bittrex will do the trouble of giving either to the affected parties or back to steem because of the issue of consensus regardless of the stake being stolen.
Oh, I thought that you were talking about sending back to the Steem wallets.
I think that "Robin Hood" was worried that he wouldn't have enough time to sort out all of the Bittrex account #'s, before Justin Sun might discover what happened and somehow regain control of the community account. Plus he may not want to expose who he really is, which he would have to do in order to ask people for their Bittrex account #'s.
Yes that might be the case, to secure the stake before Justin Sun could get hold of the account again before this "Good White Hat Guy" could sort out on how to redistribute it again. So they now have to hope that Bittrex would give it back not to the last owner community321.
For my opinion Bittrex will choose to give it back to the latter because again of the consensus factor.
I don't think he's taking the Steem
VgA
Hey Dan
I have not been around for while. Did they just take a shit load of Steem from your account?
Why the fuck would they attack you of all people?
Yes, the robbed all of my accounts. They are just after money only. They took @mottler money and he hasnt been active in 4 years. No ones money is safe on Steem, it has become a centralized database run by a 3year old with a ninjamined stake.
https://www.binance.com/en/blog/421499824684900605/CZs-Statement-on-the-Recent-STEEM-Hard-Fork
https://www.binance.com/en/blog/421499824684900605/CZs-Statement-on-the-Recent-STEEM-Hard-Fork
Please Sir, can I have your support on Hive?
I upvoted on your behalf and behalf of everyone else who's funds got stolen.
Legend!
This is one for the history books of crypto. Thank you for standing up for decentralization.
"You see? There are still faint glimmers of civilization left in this barbaric slaughterhouse that was once known as humanity. Indeed that's what we provide in our own modest, humble, insignificant - (sighs deeply). Oh, fuck it."
-M. Gustave, The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014)
Great movie :)
Thank you mysterious benefactor. It was an unexptected move, in religious terms, a miracle :)
fucking legend.
Hero of the day
Am I really the first one with a none-bot comment? 😂😅😂
Thanks so much for taking this action!
EDIT: hahaha profile picture and background - HILARIOUS!!!
The Sheriff of Nottingham would like to cut your heart out with a spoon!
Well done sir!
Legendary 💪🏽
"not the hero we deserve but the one we need"
I salute you
💜
YOU are a BEAUTIFUL SOUL!!!!!!
Big, if true!
]
[
You are a crypto hero champ!
Is this real?
What an amazing feat.
Fucking legend!
I promised myself that I won't do another post on STeem.
Well, your deed deserves a huge exception.
Respect & congratulations!
OMG! You are a legend!
:))
Cheeryooo 🍺
Hats off to you!!!!
Did you ever know that you're my hero?
You...are...stellar
Savage 🤣🙌❤️
Awesome move!
This will be in the crypto history news!
You are the man.
Bravo, You will go down in the crypto history books right next to Satoshi.
Your actions have kept me glued to my screen all day. Thanks for your epic move. Please let me buy you a beer someday :D
This guy is gonna drown in beer if by somehow his/her identity is found out.
LOL does this really happened? i would love to see al funds returned to the owners, that would be epic!...
Thanks for standing up against centralization! BTW you made everybody's day!
God bless you! Thank you!
Well you've proven yourself to be s true believer of decentralisation. Cheers brother in arms
I would consider it as Justin's plan if @bittrex doesn't transfer the funds to their original account.
Here is the thing: Moving the funds back to Steem would only put them back under Justins control. It would be better if the affected would create @bittrex accounts and keep their fund on the exchange.
And then slowly selling them so the price won't drop too badly.
2 things:
I am ecstatic that you used the word "you're" instead of "your". This type of genius is uncommon on the internet.
I think is the best thing that could have happened to Steem. If the Steem community really just wanted to be rid of those built hive and those who...were included for unknown reasons, then they have done that. Now, they can go on about their business.
At this point, or the point in which bittrex gives the funds back to the account holders, everybody should be squared up. Justin has his funds to use unfettered in governance of Steem. The old witnesses and a few randoms have their Steem to do as they wish. Seems like a good point to make the clean break that many seemed to hope for.
The funds that @themarkymark stole from me are in here. It was like $100 or so worth of STEEM.
I'm happy to see some of those downvote spam bot accounts assets get seized.
Everybody liked that!
isn't anybody here going to tell him that he didn't source the image? 😆
Or that Bittrex has refused to return the funds to their owners?
The "owner" is technically community321, and Bittrex basically flat out said they would return the funds to the "owner" if proof is provided. You are just too fucking dumb to understand what they mean.
Meanwhile... still waiting!!
Robin hood wouldn't send the money to @bittrex and ask them to work on re-distributing it.
You could have created new accounts for each stolen user, and send them the keys with an encrypted memo.
Chinese are retards to make this account with anonsteem (basically they don't know about account recovery), but you are equally stupid. You aren't even anonymous ...
What makes you think Justin would not make another HF to freeze and then siphon from those accounts?
heimindanger isnt smart enough to think about that.
No, I just know for a fact that Justin is not organizing the hard forks. It's not like they can hard-fork as fast as you think.
But of course if you believe the hive propaganda like 'justin sun still has 20/20 sock-puppet witnesses', then of course it makes sense.
I dont know, but seems like steem witness are now running another update, seems to me like they do whatever they want and they do have 20/20 sock puppet...
@cardboard @tipu
I have not get the refund about the missing tx, check please.
alanyao transfer 8 SBD to tipu @huaren.news/btc20200427 hide
https://steemd.com/tx/806f26c630f9b206f470dccfb59a34f0e9b046ea
Are you actually this fucking retarded or what? Account recovery wasnt used. And it doesnt matter who makes your account, you can change the recovery.
Well you are a faggot.
Let's say I am a faggot. Then so what? Does it change the value of what I say?
What will you call me next? Jewish?
Btw nice name squatting @netuoso! What a model for the community.
anonsteem ist accessible through TOR (as a darknet site). So of course you are.
You are a crypto hero champ!
You are the #robinhoodofsteem @community321 :D
Quit acting like you agree with this you absolute fucking idiot. You said the Hive witnesses fired the first shot and understand why Sun took the actions he did.
Go suck on someone else's toes.
Very interesting...
Congratulations
A useless former witnes member is crying !! Look who are among them. Click Here
A Bold Move...Bold and Beautiful...
Don't worry man. Sell off all your steems and focus on HIVE when you get your coins back.
😍 I Love you 😍
Thanks so much for partaking in #dailypetphotography!
Please find our post at https://hive.blog/@dpet or https://steempeak.com/c/hive-181573
Please follow @dpet for upcoming events.
Our discord channel is up and running, come on over and say hi, lots of avil pet owners are awaiting you there.
https://discord.gg/GYrnsNm
Site
Delegation
Tip Bot
Event
Am I really the first one with a none-bot comment? 😂😅😂
Thanks so much for taking this action!
EDIT: hahaha profile picture and background - HILARIOUS!!!
Good work. Continue to work. :)
I upvoted on your behalf and behalf of everyone else who's funds got stolen.my Steem away!
Dear Sun
Unfortunately it is no longer steem to transfer. Because of your fok .
Can you tell me when it is possible again? You would be very THANKFUL.
I hope it goes on with Steem would be a real pity about it.
love greetings MAX
This text is translated, so don't be surprised if it sounds funny
I like that image. Its so D&D games o games workshop games
SUN DID THIS HIMSELF TO GET PEOPLE BACK ON STEEM AND COMMENTING TO DRUM UP ACTIVITY!!!
Hi!
It's a great day as I have the privilege of meeting you here! But since you are interested in something built on the blockchain, would love to see you on Commun as well: https://commun.com/askcommun/@support/1589882559. There you can set up your own community with your own token and get donations from the first day 😇
No like scammy bots. I don't care if this is steemy blockchain !
I know who it is: https://steempeak.com/community/@rishi556/i-know-who-community321-was-accessed-by
Admirations
how'd you do it?
With the keys.
F U C K I N G B E A U T I F U L!
I don't know what else to say! I'd pay a whole Bitcoin to see the tantrum Justin probably threw when he found out about this. Not only Is he a shitty businessman, apparently he's a shitty criminal too. 🤣
23M steem ~= 5M USD
Hat's off for the Robin Hood!
Now let's see what bittrex does with this loot~
You wrote history today!!!
Brilliant!!!
Complete respect. If I was the one being stolen and I end up getting the funds back, I would send at least 5% to you. Hope it happens this way.
at least 10%
What a legend. Forget every discussion, quarrel and dispute: This is just an amazing story.
justin robando el sistema
o se pico una ballenita y me dio un voto negativo debe de ser una sucia perversa
Oh.. great move.. much respect.
Looks like my other account is censored from Steem....so here we go:
OH SHIT LOL.
Amazing!!!
Few hours ago I went away from PC with disgust what Justin did and what an unexpected pleasant surprise when I check how that HF went :)
An assbomb right in Justins face!

You just made everyone's day today. Well.... except for maybe Justin's, but he's a turd, so....
Thanks!
Total legend!
The future looks good for steem/steemit.
I salute you - Legendary :DD!
thanks bro let me upvote you although my upvote value is like $0 :P
You are a hero 😍😍
Excellent !!!
Thank you. I'm not really expecting to get anything back, but perhaps Sun will be prevented from having it.
Downvoted by @justyy. What a pathetic loser.