You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Weekly overview of the Blog category - Week 48, 2018

in #iamutopian6 years ago

Hello @didic,

First and foremost, reading this summary is informative and entertaining. I liked it even more because you were able to put it together despite not writing a single review comment this week.

I'll start with the positive aspects of the summary, continue with minor issues that I spotted and then include one or two questions I would like to know your opinion about.

You have an advantage or one could say disadvantage that you oversee an extended category, thus you can actually compare the number of posts written by contributors and Utopian reviewers in the iamutopian branch. I like that you make the charts diverse in different colours, which helps to realise that each chart covers different information.

Although the number of contributions decreased, I think that 16 submissions (excluding irrelevant pieces) still make a solid number. I am quite surprised to see that they were written by so many different people and that there are such good writers as you pointed out.

I found a few tiny issues which I believe were overlooked while writing the post. Right in your first paragraph, you conclude it with an open sentence. Thus I am not sure if you wanted to say something more or you forgot to remove it. Or maybe not but then you missed a dot at the end. :)

I believe that you could name your first chart "Average scores per week" similarly to your other charts that include an average score of specific aspects. Not that one can't figure out what the chart is about but that detail is missing in the chart and the complementary text as well. Other than that, I believe I found one or two typos which are easy to overlook.

And now the last part. Looking at the chart of contributors, I can see actifit as the only representative of a project's account.

  • What do you think can be done to encourage others to come and share the updates in Utopian?
  • What do you think is the obstacle for people who chose not to?
  • Do you believe that projects should be as active in delivering news as actifit?

After reading the whole post, I believe that including a tip of the week is a good idea and would like to see it in the future post of this weekly overview.

This post has not been evaluated according to the public questionnaire for the blog category but a simple set of metrics for iamutopian posts.

Everyone is welcome to chat with us on Discord.
[utopian-moderator]

Sort:  

This is terrific review, detailed, insightful, and useful. I totally left that sentence hanging at the start there, and fixed it now.

The other minor comments have been noted.

Now, to your questions!

Most projects don't publish daily or weekly updates anywhere, which is totally understandable. Actifit adds our tags when their update is significant, which it often is.

For the vast majority of projects, publishing an update with the frequency Actifit does so would result in many empty updates. We, at Utopian, are at a very active stage in our development, and we couldn't sustain a daily update that would interest anyone. Actifit has the "Top Daily Actifitters" leaderboard to anchor the daily post, as it is of great interest to their users. Most projects don't have a true equivalent.

We've definitely had periods with more contributions by project owners and official project accounts. I would guess that right now, with the market as it is, it may not be worth the effort for them. I strongly suspect V2 will shift that.

Thank you for your review, @espoem! Keep up the good work!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.18
TRX 0.14
JST 0.030
BTC 58668.45
ETH 3162.85
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.44