"Being critical of someone else’s race is fine." Really, since when? Please, stop promoting hatred on 3speak

in OCD5 years ago (edited)

k8mihn.jpg


After considering launching an interview series, on @threespeak & doing my best to try to onboard folks on Steem — through Posh initiative/posting on Twitter, I’m losing heart, again.

The reason I’m despairing is because of the blatant fear of Islam and hatred of Muslims that is being tolerated and even rewarded on this platform.

As a Muslim, of course, I’m personally wounded by this ugliness and expect more from a noble experiment such as Steem that I’m invested in.

But, also, as a serious journalist, I cannot in good faith spread the word of this being a professional or fair-minded space promoting free speech when I see the opposite taking place —- with bigots & even criminals (such as Tommy Robinson) taking refuge, here.

Frankly, it reflects poorly on our credibility as a platform that can be respected or trusted & hurts us all.

I’m tagging @theycallmedan, again, on this post, since I believe that Dan is a champion of justice for underdogs and recently posted about this protest march in France, condemning Islamophobia

As it is, there’s far too much violence and suffering in our world because of misinformation and bigotry and it pains me to also be confronted by it here, in a platform that I thought had higher standards :/

I realize that we live in unexemplary times, maddened by fear, murderous ignorance, and mistrust of one another.

Even though Muslims make up around a fourth of the global population, or around two billion souls, for many, the faith has become besmirched with backwardness and violence.

Islamophobia is a widespread, too painful reality, and hate speech is not without its cost.

It is a proven fact that hate crimes against Muslims are on the rise, from bullying in the classroom to racial slurs, as well as more grave offenses, such as mosque burnings, even murders.

Which is to say, hate and violence (on either side) begin in minds and hearts before finding their way to our lips and, soon enough, translating into heinous actions against (oftentimes, dehumanized) Others.

As an immigrant, Muslim, and writer living in Trump’s alarming America, as well as a citizen of our increasingly polarized world, I will not deny that speaking out on behalf of Islam has become something of a burden and sweet responsibility.

I find that I must begin most conversations on this subject, including this one, by stating the obvious: “Terrorism has no religion and most victims of terrorism are moderate Muslims.”

It’s tiresome to be continually on the defensive, which does not always bring out the best in us or the most charitable, gentle responses.

A German Muslim scholar, when asked about the connection between terrorism and Islam, went on this rant:

“Who started the first world war? Not Muslims. Who killed 6 million Jews in the Holocaust? Not Muslims. Who killed about 20 million Aborigines in Australia? Not Muslims. Who sent the nuclear bombs of Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Not Muslims. Who killed more than 100 million Indians in North America? Not Muslims. Who killed more than 50 million Indians in South America? Not Muslims. Who took about 180 million African Muslims as slaves obliged them to leave Islam, 88% of whom died and were thrown overboard into the Atlantic Ocean? Not Muslims . . .”

Which is not to say that I believe, as a Muslim community, we are entirely off the hook either.

I agree with many theologians and scholars of Islam who call for profound self-examination and a better understanding of the faith, such as Hamza Yusuf’s formula for “a renovation of the abode of Islam . . . to make new again, repair, reinvigorate, refresh, revive our personal faith.”

It seems self-defeating and willful to deny that something is rotten within the Muslim community, and that we need serious housekeeping.

As I said, we must begin, of course, by declaring to ourselves and the world in no uncertain terms, Not in Our Name, This Violence.

There is a damning quote, by Canadian author Robertson Davies, that sums up how I feel about so-called “religious” fanatics in a handful of words: Fanaticism is overcompensation for doubt.

To distance ourselves from the blasphemous-murders-who-would-sabotage-faith, we need to embody the peace, love, forgiveness, and sacrifice we find in the spirituality that sustains us, and extend it to those who do not know any better.

For those who wish to throw out the luminous baby, Faith, with the sordid water of current events, it is wise to recall the timeless words of a religiously inspired proponent of nonviolence, the great Martin Luther King Jr.:

Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that.
Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.

I hope those with hate or doubt in their heart might read and share this, as well as the sayings of Prophet Muhammad, below:


neuxrv.jpg


“Refrain from seeing and speaking of the vices of mankind, which you know are in yourself.

The most excellent Jihad is that for the conquest of self.

The exercise of religious duty will not atone for the fault of an abusive tongue.

Whoever hath been given gentleness, hath been given a good portion in this world and the next.

"Give me advice," said someone. Muhammad said, Be not angry."

Humility and courtesy are acts of piety.

The Faithful do not die; perhaps they become translated from this perishable world to the world of eternal existences.

Speak to men according to their mental capacities, for if you speak all things to all men, some cannot understand you, and so fall into errors.

Trust in God – but tie your camel first.

Verily your deeds will be brought back to you, as if you yourself were the creator of your own punishment.

If Judgement Day arrives as you are planting a tree, continue planting the tree.”

Finally, if you wish to learn more about Islam and the Muslim community, I urge you to do your research and consult respected scholars, far more knowledgeable than myself, such as:

Dr Craig Considine or Karen Armstrong (both interfaith advocates & non Muslims).

Or Sheikh Hamza Yusuf & Reza Aslan (Muslims scholars and advocates of peace)

Please, don’t stand on the sidelines and think that does not concern you. If we learn anything from history, it is that ‘Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere’ as Martin Luther King Jr. powerfully said.

Also,Pastor Martin Niemöller reminds us how we are all connected and that if we do not speak up for others, no one will for us when we are persecuted:

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

Thank you, for your attention and I hope we can continue to be proud of Steem and the content we put out into the world.

Sort:  

The most excellent Jihad is that for the conquest of self.

That may be the most excellent form you're interested in, but unfotunately that wasn't the form of Jihad in the minds of the two Muslims who cried out Allah Huakbar while hacking my friend to within an inch of death and murdering her friend before her eyes.

That wasn't the form of Jihad in the mind of the suicide bomber who blew up in a Pizza bar murdering scores including the child of another friend of mine or the kind of Jihad in the mind of the woman who drove him to the attack then drove back to Gaza and read the "news" of the attack she created with a smile on her face (she's now living free in Jordan, wanted by the FBI but not being extradited by Jordan's King).

I could go on. We have very legitimate concerns about Islam and the actions taken by a very large number of Muslims in the name of Islam because we find clear and simple justification for the most horrific actions written in the holy books and in the example of Islam's prophet.

I'm delighted that you and many other Muslims don't go down that path, but until you stop so many other Muslims reading those texts and acting literally upon them, your attempts to silence us with censorship will fail and fail very badly.

I would urge you to direct your energy inward toward reform of Islam. I know that's really hard but you're going to have a much harder time trying to stop us Kuffar talking about Islam's attitude to non believers because we won't.

You mention my friend @tommyrobinson : he has paid an astonishingly high price for speaking up, prison, beatings, financial attacks. He's still going, still not racist and still not a hater of all Muslims, just the ones that want to kill us in the name of what they perceive is their religion.

First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

Well, speak friend, I am listening. This is very well written and definitely brought your struggle to my attention in a way that gives me more understanding. I do not know a whole lot about the Muslim religion, but I do know that in any culture hate and anger is usually the mistake of hypocrisy, selfishness and narrow-mindedness. I lend my compassion to you and your community. Negativity shows only self-hatred and the lack of intelligence. Ignorance can only be uprooted with knowledge, and your writing should help to root up that costly foe. You have my support, and thank you for sharing.

Bless you, for your compassion and support. The Muslim faith is not different from the other two monotheistic, Abrahamanic religions: Judaism and Christianity. Treat others as you would be treated, since we are all One.

I was saddened and shocked to be told by 3speak that "Being critical of someone else’s race is fine." Such is the immorality (or amorality, at least) of the decentralized world, bending over backwards to resist censorship, even it it means giving a platform to hate speech.

Thanks, again, for your kind note; it helps.

I'm glad that it helps. Free speech is one thing, but filling our heads with senseless garbage is another. We seek our own evolution and resonating on the ignorance that should be behind us is only a step toward devolution in my opinion. Hopefully, today's generations will be able to weed out that kind of trash and seek more wholesome knowledge rather than the low-intelligence, attention-seeking behaviors that fuel bigotry.

hatred will destroy things

Thanks for using eSteem!
Your post has been voted as a part of eSteem encouragement program. Keep up the good work!
Dear reader, Install Android, iOS Mobile app or Windows, Mac, Linux Surfer app, if you haven't already!
Learn more: https://esteem.app
Join our discord: https://discord.me/esteem

Most excellent exposition my friend. I think everyone, at some point has been guilty of hate speech.
I was raised up in the rural south of America. Racial division/segregation was a fact of life I grew up with. The N word was used daily, in my presence and by me, but for my family and me, it was mostly in a joking humorous way, and we never said it to a black person.
I was in the 6th grade when the first black kids were placed in our school, an event that cause the more affluent families in town (including one of my cousins, who is a saint of a man) to leave the public school system and found a private school, which is still in operation.
When I moved to Atlanta, the tables were turned on me; being a white man in a predominatly black city, I was constantly on the defensive, constantly looking over my shoulder, jumping at sudden noises, fearing to leave my apartment on foot.
This city is polarized, black against white, I have no idea who is defaming and desecrating the Jewish places of worship, but that has been going on for generations down here, done in the dark, the perpetrators slinking away to hide.
It is the shame of our generation.
And yes, there is Islamaphobia as well, but I don't see that in my daily life, I do see predujice against Hispanics and the Indian Immigrants (Sub continent, not native American) violence and robberies are rampant all around.
Things do not look good for our world I fear.

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

Not censoring speech is kind of the point of the platform, yet here you are, implying censorship is needed. If your ideas are better, compete with them. If you have an opposing viewpoint to someone exercising their free speech, share it.

Criticizing your killing religion is free-speech. The fact you dislike it doesn't change the fact that words -unlike knives, swords or bombs- don't hurt anyone. If you feel hurt because of some opinions, then Twitter is a much better place for you.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.15
JST 0.029
BTC 63549.46
ETH 2562.53
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.66