Two Very Interesting Benitoite Specimens

I recently acquired these two interesting beinitoite specimens. Both have a secondary, rare mineral called Joaquinite in odd locations. I will do a Mineral Mondays post about Joaquinite tomorrow.

The first specimen has a benitoite crystal growing over the joaquinite.

I've collected a lot of specimens over 10 years and this was the first one I have seen with this combination.

I am not a geologist or scientist, but what appears to have happened is the joaquinite formed first with the benitoite forming over it later. The white material is called natrolite and it the last to form. The natrolite usually covers the all of the crystals and they are only revealed by using a hydrochloric acid to remove it and leave the benitoite & joaquinite behind.

This next specimen really has me puzzled. The joaquinite is actually inside of a neptunite crystal!

In benitotite, neptunite and and joaquinite formation, these three crystals form first, then are followed by the natrolite in a secondary injection of hydrothermal fluids. I was thinking maybe the joaquinite formed first then was dislodged by the secondary fluids, but the neptunite forms before the secondary natrolite injection. So the question is, how did the joaquinite form, then have the neptunite form over it?

Here is what I think happened.First, the neptunite didn't break, but instead didn't finish growing. Then the joaquinite attached and grew onto the unfinished neptunite producing this odd specimen. I could be completely wrong and a geologist who is familiar with similar growths will correct me. Util then, I'll continue to enjoy these awesome creations from the Earth.

Here are a few more images of the entire specimen.

The neptunite crystals are fantastic!

Thanks for reading!