You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Critique of Critique
He knows how to play better, has better techniques, knows better and more plays.
The Grandmaster has KNOWLEDGE of more techniques and strategies, but that doesn't translate into MORE options, it actually translates into FEWER (subjectively better) options.
How does a newborn infant have "freewill"? What kind of decisions does a newborn infant make?
giving here the baby answers :D
that a baby has free will you will notice once you tried all sorts of things to soothe it. The baby has it all: pampered, well fed, kissed, cuddled, giving it space, but still the baby decides it doesn't want to stop screaming. Babies do have different behaviors, some can scream you into insanity. :D
But do you think they "choose" (consciously decide) to scream (or not scream)?
Or do you think they are simply reacting instinctively (impulsively)?
I don't know and cannot give a certain answer. But make this an experience of yours, if you are brave enough :) LOL.
Every action is a decision. The Grandmaster has more knowledge and therefore knows more options than the amateur, thus being more free.
The Grandmaster only has one best move (maybe two in rare cases).
They are a "best move" robot.
Their vast knowledge doesn't create more options, it creates fewer options.