You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: EcoTrain Question of the Week - "What was the most profound spiritual moment of your life?"

in #ecotrain7 years ago (edited)

That genetics do not play a role in a scientifically proven medical condition like depression. Forgive me if I misunderstood the point you were trying to make, but I believe you are arguing that depression is in fact not a medical condition at all but a frame of mind that one can simply grow out of (or that it doesn’t exist at all and I am making it up). The ability to grow out of it may be partially true - it’s been proven that pessimistic individuals that focus on negative events and stimuli are more likely to develop depressive symptoms and need to “retrain” their brains/way of thinking using CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy). But I do not believe that is the entire explanation and it frustrates me when people argue this. I do not mean to seem rude or argumentative but I’ve heard the same statements you’ve made from so many people. That’s why so many people with mental illness/mood disorders are hesitant to speak out because so many people argue against its validity. And I’d like to point out that most (99%) of the people who argue that it’s “all in your head” have never experienced true depression or diagnosed mental illness. But it IS scientifically proven - individuals react differently on a base chemically/hormonal level to the exact same stimuli. PET scans like this one even show a visible difference.
Most experts believe genetics play an undeniable role as well - “Anyone can become depressed, but many experts believe genetics play a role. Having a parent or sibling with depression increases your risk of developing the disorder. Women are twice as likely as men to become depressed.” While the exact cause of depression has yet to be proven, the main theory is that “altered brain structure and chemical function is DIFFERENT. Brain circuits that regulate mood may work less efficiently during depression.” Neurons (nerve cells) in the brain communicating via neurotransmitters actually function less effectively. Even IF we take away all science from this and simply say depression/mental illnesses are not real or that they should not have an effect, I believe that simply voicing this idea is still more harmful than beneficial to the individuals who “believe” they have a mental illness. If someone is literally willing to kill themselves over a “perceived” illness, you at least have to give it some credibility. Again, I apologize if I misunderstood your opinion and blew this out of proportion, it is simply something I am passionate about because I live it every day.
EDIT: mainly I disliked the use of the term "fairy tale."

Sort:  

You are projecting - i never commented "is all in your head", what statement makes you think i believe depression is not about physical body as well ?

"You will one day just see depression is not anymore a thing for you and will be then that you will understand that all that time you believed to a fairy tale : genetics cause." Again, I may have misunderstood but saying that 'believing genetics cause depression is simply a fairy tale' is what I based my comment on.

...and where did i wrote depression is only a head matter ?! I don't understand . There are 2 main matters : nature of depression and genetics cause.

Nature of depression: you affirmed that i believe depression is "only in your head" - when and where i said that ?!

Genetics : depression is not caused by genetics - technically it cannot be.

I guess I'm just not understanding what we are debating anymore haha. I must have misunderstood the meaning of your comments and that's my mistake. But I simply meant to state that I do believe depression can be genetic, or at least can be influenced by genetics - my own doctor confirmed this for my mental illness. That's all

You are avoiding the questions . First you throw up saying i think like the others and i consider depression just a head problem - you attributed to me ideas and phrases i never written - and now you avoid the questions - you like to put shit on others you are pathetic .

No, I am saying I don't understand you. The question was: what made me think you said "it's all in the head." I never said that YOU think that depression is "all in the head." I said that both of your statements "You will one day just see depression is not anymore a thing for you " AND "then that you will understand that all that time you believed to a fairy tale : genetics cause" is what confused me and made me think you were saying that my idea was made up. It's sad, I was trying to be civil and actually understand your opinion. But now that you are calling me pathetic I'd rather not continue the conversation. My last comment was an apology for misunderstanding and you then you turned cruel. If you honestly meant well this whole time and wished me well with my depression, I thank you. I wish you well at least even if you think badly of me. Best of luck

Avoiding the questions and wasting my time with short comments after you associate me with ideas and concepts i never write about it's what you did. It's sad you are not able to talk about depression and discover new principles and maybe gain new understanding ....

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.14
JST 0.030
BTC 64821.33
ETH 3466.08
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.51