You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Art Plagiarism and CryptoRecycler Case: @daio (#photographersarenotartists)
Not! I did not post a photo of someone!
This is my art!
All artists paint portraits from photographs!
Not! I did not post a photo of someone!
This is my art!
All artists paint portraits from photographs!
Your art is clearly a derivative work from a copyrighted photograph, hence you need the permission of the author to monetize it. It very simple and the rule is the same all over the world.
I did not take her photo. I painted a portrait!
right, and your painting is a derivative work of the photograph, which you have no permission from the author to monetize. Additionally you dont cite the photo nor the author, so its plagiarism.
"Reading those post I see a lot of other (well known here) artists who replied to tat user in the same way I'm doing with this post, so, let me say: if a lot of artists (well know here and with a good reputation!) here have the same doubts about the posts of that user who are accusing randomly, maybe there's something right in what I'm saying or all we artists are in wrong and just that user is in right? Just to know. Maybe he/she have to be a real life or he's a just a person who doesn't have enough skill to be considerer and artist and so he/she's envious? "
https://steemit.com/art/@silviabeneforti/learning-day-by-day-thanks-the-great-artists
So apparently, @jaguar.force, you and your cohort @ilgiaguaro have been bullying real artists in steemit for quite a while now, building your self-righteousness careers, while paying little attention to real plagiarists.
I suggest that you stop NOW!
"Just an example (just one of a lot of crazy posts tthat user wrote) that can help you to know how much this user is just a troll, look at here(1). I don't know the user he/she accuse to be a plagiarist, but that artist (I think she's a student) simply drew something from a photo online! She didn't copy an artwork, she painted the subject from a photo and she made a good exercise. Sure, it's always good to write the name of the artist/photographer/etc that inspired your work, but plagiarism is something different!"
https://steemit.com/art/@silviabeneforti/learning-day-by-day-thanks-the-great-artists
(1)https://steemit.com/abuse/@jaguar.force/art-plagiarism-case-3-caso-de-plagio-artistico-3-akarantain
@onceuponatime plagiarism is exactly related to the lack of attribution, the same work with attribution of sources, stops being plagiarism. If I say I drew a portrait, and I dont cite an image source it is assumed I made it from a live model or from a photograph I took.
If it was made from a photo someother person took and as in this case I copy exactly the whole composition and not just the face, without crediting the photographer its plagiarism, a specific type of plagiarism called art paraphrasing. You can learn more about art plagiarism here: https://steemit.com/abuse/@jaguar.force/what-is-art-plagiarism-by-francis-leverett-golden
if you can take a photo of art and not be plagiarism
you can draw a photo and not be plagiarism
You are right, you can draw a photograph and it not be plagiarism, if you cite the photograph, and you can take a photograph of a painting and it not be plagiarism, if you dont imply you made the painting yourself.
show me the real artists, these are just draftmen as ilgiaguaro said.
Definitely not you. You are a mere bully.
I should not put a source on my art! Because this is my picture!
This is not a copy! This is a portrait!
When posting content that either is owned by someone else or inspired by someone else’s works, it is proper to list the said source in your post with a link to the original.
Failing to do so is considered plagiarism, and could result in being blacklisted by curation groups or even flagged.
Examples include:
If you understand the rules explained in this comment reply to this comment with "I understand"
Yes, you should ciite the !sources to "your art".
Your drawing is a reproduction of a photo portrait in another medium, meaning: its a derivative work from anothers artist' artwork, hence you should cite the source and credit the artist, and in this particular case since the photo is copyrighted you should obtain permission from the author to monetize said derivative work.