RE: A practical problem for the Anarchist and New Age Voluntarists (and any other starry-eyed idealist). (featuring @vuyusile as author)
So you advocate an evolutionary model driven by the passive virtue of good actors. I like the primacy of choice in the marketplace of ideas. But is this an answer to the women in a poor community that are being preyed upon by a serial rapist? I still can't see how we dispense with law and enforcement; how these services can be located in anything other than in specialist actors; and how the guardians of the specialist actors can be appointed in any more successful means than a democratic process with separation of powers and the checks and balances that this offers.
What happens when those resourced communities that can afford private specialist actors succeed in establishing safety in a community, but simply drive the bad actors into disorganised communities thereby increasing their plague. What do we say to the person who cannot vote with his feet in those communities?
@vuyusile I so feel you, being from South Africa, hating banks and government control over my life, but wondering how on earth it would work in a country like ours, as well as other less developed countries. I have seen all the arguments, but feel that possibly anarchists don't understand about a society like ours? Fellow disciple-in-waiting.
I've read over what I have posted so far and I'm sure you think I'm just offering philosophy rather than real solutions.
That is true.....and admittedly I'm a thinker. Let me try to actually use the non-aggression principle to give a solution. As a precursor to my thoughts, I believe in the younger generation and think they can have a powerful voice in this conversation.
My Solution-
I wasn't necessarily offering a solution to this broad topic that reaches to every part of the earth. I was in a manor suggesting that a community without limitations could choose with discussions the best route(s) they see.
I can understand it feels helpless in some communities (ex. majority of men are causing problems for the women)....if the heavy hand of government law doesn't offer a solution, then what I'm asking you to think about is what do the wronged people do? The limitations are that people don't take on the problems themselves because they are hoping to rely on powers above....but what if we are the powers that need to solve the problem?
You have offered concrete steps at both a decentralised and centralised level; and much to ponder - which is more than some of the other replies. I wish that my steem power was not still so low so that I could vote up some of your and other comments. Tough being a newbie.;-)
Thanks for your feedback. Even when pushed to give solutions, I want to stress the importance of creative solutions by working together voluntarily. By no means do I think my worldview solves all the problems....but I have seen real value by living by these principles and I have faith in myself.
Start a thread seeing who would commit to giving up their comforts for the promise of change, and begin acquiring land resources, and financing. https://steemit.com/anarchy/@zev/a-practical-solution-for-the-anarchist-and-new-age-voluntarists