You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Does Prohibition Increase Violence or Improve Wellbeing?

in #anarchy7 years ago

Thanks for bringing me on board. One piece of clarification, when I said:

A government that has a monopoly on violence does not justify its right to have a monopoly in the selling or not selling of a good

I was not implying that governments do not use their force to monopolize markets only that they are mutually inclusive, in that they don't have to both be true. When I speak of a monopoly of violence I'm only speaking of a small aspect of what we generally consider as government.

Like you I'm also skeptical regulation is beneficial. There is something very attractive about simple and powerful mechanics leading to complex and well functioning systems: like natural selection / mutation and free market. The caveat is now that we're conscious of the forces of evolution we're discussing how we're changing them... for our benefit. The same problem of unintended consequences arises there too.

I hope you're not arguing the current justice system is the best possible system for justice?

You're right. I'm not, but I could argue it is the best we've had so far.

You and I have talked about the faulty nature of eye-witness testimony and how an appellate court judge makes their decisions more based on how long ago they ate than on facts, logic, and reason according to some studies.

This is an opportunity for technology to outperform but requires transparency. Also, just started "Thinking Fast and Slow" tonight and heard him reference this study.

Sort:  

Ah, finally! One of my favorite books explaining what we currently know about the human mind. You've recommend books to me I've fully enjoyed. I'm glad you're getting to one of my recommendations. :)

they don't have to both be true

I guess I fail to see enough examples where they aren't, eventually. Take the United States as an example. One of the first (only?) nation states to start close to a minarchy. Where did it up end? The largest and most powerful army the world has ever known, building an empire, but doing so with control of the world reserve currency. Eventually, over time, centralized hierarchy systems of power become corrupted. At least, that's what we've seen so far.

If that ends, what we'll have probably won't be called government, by my standards. It'll be closer to voluntaryism, I think.

I agree it would be something new.

I might pick up Black Swan also since I heard you mention it and it was referenced in the TFAS book. I've got 14 credits on audible so let me know what you'd recommend. I just finished How the Mind Works by Pinker and then heard he's got a new book coming out and is going to do a show with Sam Harris in Los Angeles.... road trip?

Hah! That would be quite a road trip. 14 credits?!? Dang man. I need to change my subscription because I feel like I'm always waiting for the next credit. I'll check my wish list at some point and see what I have in there to recommend. Almost done with Black Swan and definitely enjoying it.

Hey... road trip would be interesting. I think I'll just wait for it to hit YouTube though. :)

I switched to the 24 credit membership, all at once, in May.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.15
JST 0.029
BTC 63878.47
ETH 2625.83
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.79