You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Why Intelligent Steemians Do Not Exploit the Reward-pool
I just started here and one thing that has been bothering me is the number of useless comments. People seem to be spamming generic comments on some posts, is this an exploit? It's nice and all to say great post, but adding depth and content in a comment adds to the overall post in the form of discussion. It seems like some people are just spreading comments far and wide in the hopes of getting upvotes. Seems like clutter to me.
Well, sometimes users are manually advertising their channels or just copy-pasting their own posts. I think this is not an issue, since flagging feature gets rid of "manual" spammers most of the time.
Bots that do comment can be a problem, you can however make another bot to flag spammin bots.
Just getting creative here.
I agree with your statement on generic comments. I have noticed the same myself since I've been a member. I try my best to give my honest opinion and feedback on whatever material I have read. I don't think I would read the blog if I wasn't interested in the content in the first place, however I think some people think that randomly commenting on as many posts as they can is going to make them rich. I don't think that's feasible or even remotely realistic. I would love to see more genuine conversation held here on Steemit because I think it would generate more attention to the site and the blogs. I appreciate that you pointed out the importance of the content of comments. I will keep this in mind during my time here.
Yes many people seem to be determined to waste their time with useless spam instead of investing time in actual content. Freedom of choice i guess.
Actually, I've made more Steem on comments than I think I have my own content, however I try to comment something that adds to the blog instead of spamming. This is supposed to be a social media platform, correct? So there should be more actual human exchange between the writer and the audience, in my opinion. I suppose everyone could just post content and have their fans read it and post but what kind of echo chamber would that be? After awhile I think people would grow tired of hearing their same thoughts relayed back to them. I have posted a little of my own thoughts for others to read but it's going to take some time to generate a serious following. I appreciate being able to read blogs, gain some new insight and knowledge and add my two cents.
Totally right!!! I have also noticed that people seem to have no intrest in upvoting or reading comments. I have seen so many videos with 50+ comments and highest comment has like 3 upvotes. How are anyone making anything out of that spam if no one is even upvoting them?
For me it's important to know that someone has actually engaged in the content provided. I want to know that what I took the time to write, compose, and add to the platform was worth a comment. It means more if people are actually thinking about what you present than just simply fishing for followers, votes and money, or at least it does for me. I can't really speak for anyone else, but if I am going to read something then nine times out of ten I will leave a comment to let the author know what I thought about the material and what if anything I can add for whomever else may be reading. After all it is, social media, right? Without the social interaction it would seem rather bland, much to be desired.
Would it help to have comments with more upvotes moved higher on the comment list? It would be similar to Reddit but would allow users to avoid most of the useless comments we see. Maybe they already have plans for something like that but I'm not sure.
With that system in place you tend to find whoever gets in early tends to corner the market on up votes. Even a reply on a top parent comment tends to get more up votes than a late primary comment that contributes more overall to the discussion
We would be better served with a random order of parent comment chain being presented at each loading off the page. In the hopes that we are more likely to find and up vote interesting content that helps discussions.