You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Auf der Seite stehen von | To stand with

in Deutsch Unplugged11 months ago (edited)

Thank you for the mention ty-ty

Hmm...
I will have to contain myself, tread carefully, and take my time—because there is so much to say, so much that can be said. These thoughts, these perspectives… they’re tangled and complex. Especially when it comes to politics, wars—there is no black and white. There are countless, perhaps infinite, shades of grey.

First things first:
When someone says they don’t believe in nationalism or don’t hold on to a sense of identity or belonging to their nation—I find it difficult to trust them. Because love for one’s homeland is innate. It’s embedded in human nature. Yes, that’s a separate debate—what one considers their homeland to be.

Also, no matter how much someone insists they’re not biased in politics or in their worldview—there’s no such thing as complete neutrality. Everyone leans one way or the other, even if just slightly.

So it’s worth asking—why did I specifically mention Palestine and Ukraine?
Perhaps at that point in time, I could relate more closely to these nations and their struggles. When it’s a matter of the powerful versus the less powerful (not in will, but in resources), your heart naturally inclines towards the weaker side. And the more awareness, insight, and understanding you have—especially of global politics and strategy—the more likely you are to resonate with certain people or causes.

Having said that:
World politics is immensely complicated. No one can ever be absolutely certain about anything.
But as human beings, we can raise our voices, we can align ourselves with what we believe is on the right side of humanity.

I would never claim that our politics or governance is 100% transparent or flawless—but whenever it comes down to the sovereignty of my country versus an external threat, I will always stand with my country.

And why?
I agree—human dignity and freedom are deeply interwoven. To violate another's freedom through coercion or violence is, indeed, a violation of both their dignity and one's own humanity. But I also believe it's important to acknowledge the nuanced reality we live in, where power dynamics, historical trauma, and geopolitical interests shape actions that aren’t always easy to categorize as purely right or wrong.

In standing with my country, I don’t condone injustice or the suppression of anyone’s right to live freely. Rather, I recognize that in a deeply polarized world, sometimes defending sovereignty, identity, or even survival is seen as force—when in fact it might be a response to it.

I try to stand on the side of humanity—not in absolutes, but in awareness. And while I do believe that my nation, with all its imperfections, often strives toward that side more than away from it, I remain open to introspection. True freedom includes the freedom to question ourselves—both as individuals and as nations.


Give my regards to Vivienne :)

Sort:  
 11 months ago 

Thanks for that big and great comment, worth to be regarded as a post itself!

Please let me not be misunderstood while I pick up just one sentence:

Because love for one’s homeland is innate. It’s embedded in human nature.

I did not yet discuss this issue with 'Vivienne', he-he, but I dare to say:
No, this is not the whole truth, because the time of the nomading humans are by very far longer and thus deeper integrated into our genom as the time of being settled with homes, villages, and towns.
From the moment you take this into account, you will see the large propaganda-part in narratives about homeliness and on the value of so-called "nations". The concept of "nations" mostly was invented in order to veil the character of imperia by giving states some biological character or underline--and more over: the place to projecting some love-like feelings on them.

your heart naturally inclines towards the weaker side

Sorry, I don't believe this. It is not by nature but socially introduced, and the inclining of my heart is not a good counsellor while others (mis-)use to manipulate my feelings and my decisions. If two men get into a battle you may really see which one is weaker, but you never see which other strong powers stand behind whom and put them as mere figures on the chess board...

 11 months ago 

The idea that there should be a perpetrator and a victim, a good guy and a bad guy, a guilty party and an innocent one, that it could be possible to take sides in this way, seems too simplistic to me and therefore ultimately wrong. Because nobody is only good or only bad, because perpetrators and victims should share responsibility (not guilt!).

In other words: it's complicated.

What I can explain quite simply and beyond doubt is that I have neither a meaningful concept of homeland, nor an attachment to a concept of nationality or fatherland, nor a sense of belonging to a group of people born by chance in the same region. I have no sympathy for borders, for the construction of a unit that does not really exist. As long as these ideas are not finally overcome, there will be wars...

I have no sympathy for borders, for the construction of a unit that does not really exist. As long as these ideas are not finally overcome, there will be wars...

Unfortunately, this is not how the order of world works! More unfortunately: there will be wars... We can't do any about it or can we?

 11 months ago 

We could. But not locally or partially or selectively. We need a global and complete change in our way of life, our expectations and our attitude. Unfortunately, people do not seem to be willing or able to do this.

I will tell you when this path will be open: when the need is so great (the climate is no longer bearable for anyone, hunger is insatiable, poverty is deadly). Then we will take the right path together (for a short time) and put all sensitivities to one side.

As soon as survival is assured, economic and religious interests will once again gain the upper hand. And everything starts all over again.

Loading...

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.05
TRX 0.33
JST 0.080
BTC 63435.26
ETH 1684.80
USDT 1.00
SBD 0.41