Manual, Automatic, Semi-Automatic? Which One Should You Choose?

in #writing7 years ago

Cars are expensive -- to buy and to operate. Which is why you may have noticed that there are more motorcycles and scooters on the roads. They’re inexpensive to buy and most of them get much better gas mileage (as much as 60 mpg for the smaller ones) than the best hybrid or diesel-powered cars. You can park them almost anywhere a bicycle would fit, too -- making them ideal for city dwellers or people who don’t have garage space to spare.

And now, have you finally decided to take the plunge and buy your first bike? But wait, which one is really better -- Manual, Automatic or Semi-Automatic?

I can feel that excitement and curiosity you are feeling right now. So let's begin with giving simple definitions for the aforementioned types of motorcycles.

  • Manual. The usual method of shifting gears (left foot lever) and clutch lever to release before shifting gears. Examples are Raider150, Sniper150, RS150 and many more.
  • Automatic. No shifting gears needed. "Gear Shifting" is on the front pulley(driving) and its rear pulley(driven). Quickness and positioning of the "Gears" depends on the engine's revolution(RPM), weight of the ply balls and stiffness of the center spring, "gears" are almost infinite.
  • Semi-Automatic. It has gear shifting foot lever but don't have any clutch lever, all you need to do is release on the throttle before down or up-shifting on the left foot lever.

Now we can start listing the pros and cons of each type. Are you ready to purchase your bike? Check this out first.

Manual Motorcycle

  • Fuel Economy. Usually, fuel consumption numbers are lower on ~ 10% percent, so manual transmission is more efficient. But it isn’t always true. If you are inexperienced driver, you could over-rev your engine and shift in wrong times, then fuel economy with automatic could be even better, plus with it you will not be stressing your motorcycle so much.
  • Acceleration Manual are better when it comes to acceleration. It happens because manual gearboxes weight less, has more speeds to choose from (gear ratios) and there is no torque converter, which “devours” some of the overall torque. However, it’s not always true once again.
  • Reliability It’s another important factor, and usually manual transmission proves itself better in this area. It is because automatic transmission has much more parts and other sophisticated mechanics that could fail. Manual gearbox is much simpler.
  • Traffic Condition. With huge traffic it gets really annoying and even tiring to change the gears and operate the clutch every minute.

Automatic Motorcycle

  • Ease of Learning. Automatic transmission motorcycles are obviously easier to learn than the other types.
  • Engine Size. Most scooter engines range from 50 cc to 250 cc.
  • Turning and Maneuvering. A motorcycle’s longer wheelbase makes it less precise for maneuvering and turning at low speeds. A scooter’s smaller wheelbase makes for better maneuverability and turning.
  • Rider Safety. Both motorcycles and motor scooters require proper training and education, protective gear and knowledge of the rules of the road. In 2013, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration reported 88,000 motorcycle or scooter accident injuries. Safety should always be a top priority.

Semi-Automatic Motorcycle

  • Availability. There are more available semi-automatic sold at a lower price than automatic and manual motorcycle. Choosing semi-automatic will save you money and will definitely give you more options to choose from.
  • Ease of Use and Beginner-Friendly. If you have just started learning how to drive and balance and you’re already aiming to own a Harley-Davidson or even Sniper150, choosing semi-automatic can be of great help. Balance is good because its parts and accessories are not too heavy. There is also gear shiftiing pedals in which you can play with gearing; thus preparing you for manual motorcycle. But of course, manual has clutch. Hehehe.
  • Fuel Consumption. With the new invention in fuel effeciency, manual and new models of automatic transmissions have already surpassed the semi-automatic motorcycles. The new technology is called Fuel Injection (F.I.) and for everyone to know, that would definitely save your fuel consumption!

There you have it -- the simplified pros and cons of manual, automatic and semi-automatic motorcycles. With the information I just gave you, it's now up to you which of the three choices you'll choose. Don't be bothered if your close friend purchased a Harley-Davidson while you're close to choosing Mio Aerox 155. Just be sure you'll never regret the choice you are about to make. Good luck!


Web Sources:
https://www.thoughtco.com/things-look-for-buying-a-motorcycle-2399394
https://www.motorists.org/blog/buy-motorcycle-pros-cons/
https://www.answerbag.com/q_view/53579
https://blog.nationwide.com/scooter-vs-motorcycle/
https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/812148
https://bikeadvice.in/pros-cons-motorcycles-auto-transmissn/

Photo credits:
1 2 3 4 5


New-Animation-1.gif

Follow-Me-(Looped).gif

themanualbot.jpg

follow_themanualbot.gif

Sort:  

I am a mechanical engineer..i will tell you briefly..in my opinion automatic system cars are very easy to operate and compatibility also very good..in manual cars driver should have good skills and experiance of handle the car in some rush situations but in auto matic and semi automatic systems very easy to operate and minimus skills enough for drive the cars..handling is very easy in automatics and asusual in semi automatic also easy compared yo the manual operated system...i choose autimatic system to drive.. present days technoligy increses day by day so we should also run with the technologies and utilities it...
@themanualbot

Manual all the way! 😂 is the way fun drive works same goes for​ cars as well

Indeed, especially when going downhill! But i'm not missing the manual with the horrendous stop and go traffic that we have lol.

Haha, manual is for the ​weekend ride of course 😂

wow its great and really helpful... i have this little knowledge about driving literally on how to make them run but not with the shifting gears and how it affect the fuel consumption thanks a lot for this info

I'm glad you find it very useful on your side. :)

Automatic might be better for since I don't know anything about driving hahah :D

haha mag-aral ka na po. :)

mag aaral na po soon pag may time :D HEHE

we had a semi automatic before but recently bough a second hand aerox fully automatic motorcycle, it's faster and easier to drive! however, its bigger also. :)

magduka man kas automatic. haha

pangtiguwang na ni na motor sir kay di na ganahan ug hasol change2 gear...hehe

Interesting post sir.I think semi automatic is better.By the way I don't know about driving.

Great article! And if i might add, one of the things that I observed that a lot of motorcycle owners in the PH does not know, and causes a lot of accidents that have cost people their lives, is how to countersteer.

Made that mistake last time and crashed, good thing I was on full safety gear. I learned how to countersteer after that crash, when a friend who is a skilled rider pointed out my mistake.

Be careful next time. :)

Thank you. Unfortunately, i learned the hard way. I was almost a hundred kms away from home when i crashed and still had to ride back home.

i will go with the manual one. As they are many benefits of manual. like reliability, fuel consumption and acceleration. seems to be elegant motor bike. keep sharing @themanualbot

Manual is much better, even in cars .I have tried automatic and manual cars , I can say its more fun driving a manual.

I have a Honda Wave 125 (Semi-automatic) and currently using Bajaj Rouser NS150(Manual). I could say that yet manual is more enjoyable to drive plus the fuel consumption is much cheaper. Though tiring, but i can easily adjust my speed with manual.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.19
TRX 0.16
JST 0.030
BTC 68857.19
ETH 2715.71
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.72