SteemFest4: Steem as a platform for business

in #waivio5 years ago (edited)

Having a good time at #SteemFest4 with the old and new friends!

Thank you @roelandp for bringing the Steemians together, organizing one of my favorite events and taking such good care of us!

What is so cool about #SteemFest is the incredible atmosphere of cooperation. It doesn't matter if you build applications, create or curate content, play games or educate others about Steem. We really benefit from each other's success and I feel very privileged to be part of this unique and vibrant community.

A year ago, in #Krakow, I shared with the community the vision of the Waivio platform and associated protocols. And now, in November 2019, in #Bangkok, I am pleased to present the results of the hard work of the dedicated Waivio DevOps team - Waivio platform and to discuss immediate business applications, such as managing restaurant rewards programs.

Presentation by @grampo at SteemFest4

Presentation by @grampo at SteemFest4

Video feed: SteemFest⁴ - Bangkok - Day 1 - YouTube (3:07:00)

We are all very passionate about Steem and we certainly wondered how we could build an independent, profitable and stable business on Steem, a business that would not depend on the price of STEEM, that would not rely on a mass adoption of Steem, that could be launched with minimal investment and that would not require a degree in IT or journalism to run.

Steem as a platform for business

Steem as a platform for business

Most of us have published food and restaurant reviews on social media or on sites such as TripAdvisor, Yelp or Google Maps:
Restuarant review on Steem

Restuarant review on Steem

But this time, I would like you to look at these contributions from a different perspective:

Review as a proof of sale

Review as a proof of sale

Example: Favourite vegan place in Vancouver

Yes, these posts are also a perfect proof of sale!

Two original photos of the dish can be used to confirm that the person has visited the place and paid for the meal.

This simple concept is the foundation of a very popular business model, aka "bring me the customer and I will pay you a commission":

Business model

Business model

If the Guide can prove to the restaurant that the new customer has come and ordered the dish because of their efforts, they can collect the commission and then share it with the customer.

So, would you write a quick review for, say, $3, $5, $8?

New review

New review

Example: go to page Beef Teriyaki at Suhi Mura and click "Write new review"

And the focus of the review is on the photos, not the text. If you feel like telling a longer story, by all means do it - your fans will certainly appreciate it! But this is not a requirement.

The links to the dish and restaurant will already be included in the review template, so there is no need to worry about that.

First of all, how can we ensure that paid reviews are not biased?

We need honest reviews

We need honest reviews

In fact, it's very simple: rewards should not be offered by restaurants, but by independent review services, which aggregate many such offers. This would allow authors to provide honest feedback.

Once the review is posted on Steem blockchain, it would appear in the general news feed, in the author's personal blog as well as in the restaurant and dish pages.

Posting the review

Posting the review

This way, other users will be able to see real-life photos and ratings of dishes as part of the restaurant menu.

Example: Sushi Mura restaurant listing, Beef Teriyaki reviews

The main value proposition of the service is to replace coupons with rebates, or as we are going to call them - rewards. And while users effectively receive the same benefits from the pure financial point of view, there are significant advantages for users.

Coupons vs. rewards

Coupons vs. rewards

Coupons and discounts in restaurants are becoming increasingly difficult for people to manage. And people often complain that they receive "second class" service when they use coupons.

Rewards solve all these problems. Rewards can be easily aggregated from multiple sources and customized according to the user's needs.

And since the customer pays the full price in the restaurant, they always receive the full service and attention.

Finally, writing reviews is an aspirational activity, because it helps others discover great experiences, while allowing the author to build their reputation and social capital.

Advantages for restaurants

Advantages for restaurants

There are also important benefits for restaurants. First, this program allows restaurants to pay only for the results. Overhead management costs are eliminated as well as employee fraud (when employees replace cash payments with coupons) is greatly reduced.

Coupons are also very difficult to target. Coupons are often accumulated by existing clients, unnecessarily increasing the cost of acquiring new customers.

In contrast, restaurants can configure the frequency with which the same customer can become eligible to receive rewards, focusing campaigns on new and lapsed customers.

Frequent discounts can also harm the restaurant's brand, while reward programs require customers to pay the full price at the restaurant.

The next important question is: what kind of commissions can restaurants afford to pay on a continuous basis?

Managing rewards programs

Managing rewards programs

Analysis of the income statement of a typical restaurant suggests that they should be comfortable to offer up to 35% commission off the retail price of the specific dish being reviewed. Customers pay the full price for the other items they order and their friends (people rarely come alone) also pay the full price for their meals.

Guides (agents who manage restaurant rewards programs) are expected to retain 25% of these commissions, while 75% will be distributed to customers as rewards for writing quick reviews of dishes.

The opportunity

The opportunity

There are more than one million restaurants in the United States and their annual sales are approximately $900,000. A typical restaurant records $27,000 in claimed discounts and coupons in their cash register each year.

And if the coupons can be largely replaced by the rewards campaign at a restaurant, the guide can expect to receive $500 per month in management fees.

The numbers

The numbers

Providing such a service to just 20 restaurants could generate an attractive income, which would not depend on the price of STEEM, since the rewards are expected to be distributed within a relatively short period of time. And guides do not need large quantities of STEEM to successfully operate such a business on the Steem blockchain.

But how difficult is it to sell this service to restaurants?

Signing up restaurants

Signing up restaurants

In fact, the guide does not sell the program to restaurants, but rather offers to buy "empty tables". Many restaurants enjoy full occupancy on Fridays and Saturdays, but they may have unoccupied tables on other days of the week.

The next step is to establish two levels of rewards: a smaller reward for cheaper dishes and a higher reward for more expensive ones.

The billing cycle is generally defined by the distribution of rewards from the prepaid fund rather than by predetermined time intervals. Once the fund is distributed, the guide provides detailed reports and the cycle is renewed.

Steem blockchain offers complete transparency not only for user-submitted reviews, their social reputation and domain expertise, but also for all the payments made by the guide to customers.

But what if there are not enough existing Steem users in the area?

Singing up reviewers

Singing up reviewers

Today, one in ten people in the United States dine out every day. And this trend is particularly strong among the milennials, who are also technically savvy and price-conscious.

This means that the guide does not need thousands or tens of thousands of active users to run a successful business.

And locating local foodies through traditional GEO advertising is relatively simple, especially considering that the guide does not sell, but buys services from users.

Indeed, it is a very unique business, because the guide buys services from both restaurants and users!

But isn't this market already highly competitive and overcrowded?

Competitive advantages

Competitive advantages

Although TripAdvisor, Yelp and Google Maps dominate the market, they do not offer any tangible rewards to users. Waivio also focuses on photos and short reviews of dishes rather than long reviews of restaurants. This allows restaurants to compete for top positions using every single item on their menu, instead of just at the brand level.

Daily deals services, such as Groupon and livingsocial, require deep and unsustainable discounts from restaurants. While rewards programs are designed as continuous programs that can be tailored to the ongoing needs of restaurants.

Additional revenues

Additional revenues

In addition to managing rewards programs, guides will be able to provide additional services to restaurants, such as hosting their websites.

The restaurant pages on the Waivio platform are very dynamic, visually appealing and offer many options for social engagement, while the majority of existing restaurant websites are static and do not offer any compelling options for user engagement.

Updated menus (with user reviews, photos, ratings and tags) can also be synchronized with food delivery apps, table reservation services and other review services.

And on top of that, Steem's proof-of-brain consensus can offer another very unique source of income:



When guides convert fiat commissions into liquid STEEM rewards for distribution to reviewers, they do an extremely important job for the Steem community - they create a continuous cash demand for STEEM.

A single guide, managing rewards programs for just 20 restaurants can create positive demand for STEEM at the level of over $30,000 per month!

This commercial activity can lead to a rapid appreciation of the price of STEEM, which is in the best interest of the major STEEM holders.

Steem whales can directly support this commercial activity by using Waivio's matchbot service, which can be used to match liquid rewards with rewards from the Steem rewards pool (ex. 20% match) through upvoting of eligible reviews.

This way reviewers will receive 20% in the form of Steem VP and 80% in the liquid form paid by the guide.

The increase in profitability would motivate existing guides to expand their operations and attract many new guides to launch their businesses on Steem blockchain.

If you like what we do and if you think we deserve to receive some funding from the Steem Development Fund, please support Waivio on the Steem Proposals System. Every vote counts!

Support us!

Support us!

We firmly believe that Steem is the best open blockchain out there and that it is a perfect decentralized platform for business.

We also believe that the appreciation of the value of STEEM will result from businesses using Steem blockchain rather than just speculators making their bets.

And if you agree with our vision and think we are on the right track, please vote for the Waivio proposal: Steem as a platform for business using your favorite app: - /

Just #keepsteeming!


Looking forward to quitting my job to become a full time Waivio Guide ;)

Posted using Partiko iOS

... on writing about all the restos and all the pubs and all the !BEER ;-)

cool plan and count on my support and vote

Indeed, now that we can create objects on Steem and accumulate reviews and knowledge (ratings, tags, photos, etc.) for destinations, resorts, products and... breweries! Imagine going to a pub and getting rewards for reviewing the pub food and separately for reviewing the beer! This would allow us to build maps of restaurants where a specific brand of beer was served. Or even the best culinary pairings!

And thanks for the SPS upvote!

Hey @jeffjagoe, here is a little bit of BEER from @detlev for you. Enjoy it!

voted for you. hope you make it through the 'permission' economy that holds steem back because i love your idea of objects. think you need to now onboard as many ambassdors from each country as possible and have weekly contests -- solid presentation, i watched on the stream.

If I remember correctly, we had a chat last year at #SteemFest3, when Waivio was just an idea. And you do an incredible job of teaching people about Steem!

Waivio needs hands-on coaches to help people start their own businesses. It should not take more than 3 months for a person to start a profitable business here on Steem:

  1. create 20+ listings of local restaurants with 10-15 dishes each on ;
  2. register a business, open a bank account, make business cards (e.g. CEO of "Italian Dining in Vancouver, Ltd.");
  3. launch a review website using all relevant listings in the region (Waivio would allow the creation of customized social sites);
  4. fund a limited number of reward campaigns (awareness and a landing page for ads);
  5. promote rewards to local reviewers (GEO advertising on Google, Instagram, Criagslist, other social channels, etc;)
  6. Sign up restaurants, convert fiat payments to STEEM using local OTCs (over-the-counter exchanges), configure reward campaigns (separate accounts to simplify reporting);
  7. monitor reviews, manage payments (Waivio tools: accounts payable/receivable, customer support, invoicing, reporting, etc;)
  8. establish recurring reporting and invoicing procedures;
  9. optimize ongoing operations through outsourcing (e.g., quality assurance of reviews);
  10. sell the company (full transparency of on-chain transactions).

A typical guide will serve 20 to 50 restaurants and a city of one million inhabitants (more than 4,000 restaurants) offers enough room for 100+ guides. The program can be further extended to breweries, vineyards, all kinds of other businesses, e-commerce, travel, entertainment and much more.

And thanks for your vote on SPS. Hopefully, we will be able to get enough votes of support to speed up the development and finalize the platform.

you must be mistaken, it was not me at sf3. but thanks for reaching out. on this occasion i'll have to say no, i've got a lot on between now and early next year. i wish you the best however and i'll add this to (waivio)

Thank you for the clarification. We will continue to build and polish the Waivio platform, so that it can serve as a solid foundation for people starting their business on Steem.

best of luck!

Interesting to hear the project the other day. Sounds like a real big plan and I hope it's successful! Love food! Love food discount lol #jk #notreally

Supported! <3

Really looking forward for this project to kick off smoothly!

I have been also trying to think of a way for SME to join into steem.

Coupons may be kind of out dated but I still think it can be tweaked for special rates for Steemians along the way so that rewards can be recycled back to the restaurants and then reissued to new (or recurrent) reviewers.

What do you think?

(I need to relisten to your presentation again haha)

The Waivio platform can be used for many different businesses, small and large. We decided to focus on restaurants because today, one in ten people dine out every day, which means that even a small number of active users can produce a large number of reviews. So we don't need to wait for mass adoption to start this business.

With regard to coupons versus rewards - indeed, people want flexibility to use their rewards and STEEM (in contrast to discounts) can be converted to cash, used in the system and perhaps even used as a payment directly at restaurants.

Yes indeed. I got to really check out the Waivio platform later and see if it can be applied.
So far for Asean countries, online purchase is VERY POPULAR especially with the 9.9 / 10.10 / 11.11 / 12.12 cyber sales. The most direct part to get these business entities onboard is to adopt the concept as a Steemian.

Just like in Malaysia we do have a Steemian that owns a food truck who would still be happy to support another Steemian by accepting payment in STEEM.

But because of the volatile price in Steem, maybe we need to look into a way that it leverages for both patron and business owner.

This is something I have been scratching my head trying to find a middle ground.

Initially, the intention was to use SBDs for liquid payments of rewards, but as pointed out by @blocktrades, @arcange and others, SBD liquidity is limited. So it might be better to use STEEM and adjust rewards amounts using current exchange rates.

Yes, totally agree with that.
SBD is not the way to apply the mass adoption for the future.

It sounds very interesting, many people could benefit from it. Hope it becomes a reality soon! Good luck! 👍🏻 😉

Posted using Partiko iOS

I watched your presentation and it was excellent. You’ve got a well thought out business and I wish you great success!

I hope it becomes a reality soon

Posted using Partiko Android

As you got us already during your speech at SF4 - there will be my support for this cool project.

Wow -- impressive plan, and I know some food reviewers who might sign up -- supporting you!

Thanks for the re-steem!

I already use your application, it is already better than many sites on Steem. Special thanks for the filters for post languages.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.23
TRX 0.12
JST 0.029
BTC 66117.27
ETH 3560.84
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.12