You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Garbage In Useful Out Programs

in #utopian-io8 years ago

Your contribution cannot be approved because it does not follow the Utopian Rules.

Generic task requests, like "We are looking for contributors" won't be accepted.

Your contribution is too generic and there isn't a project yet. Usually you write very specific task requests for existing projects. Have a look at the accepted Task Requests on Utopian to see some good examples.

Furthermore, it is really hard to understand what you want to achieve. At least you should have added a descriptive introduction to the project and your vision.

I'm sorry for the long waiting time and for disappointing you now. It seems you really put some effort into your posts but unfortunately this one doesn't belong on Utopian.

For any questions or feedback, feel free to can contact us on Discord.
[utopian-moderator]

Sort:  

(@utopian-io) I would like to clarify what would be appropriate on Utopian. Being new to it. Please bear with me for a moment.

Consider academic, MIT Media Lab type projects. Each task is to build a short program. The algorithm and spec are given like in this case. (It could be given in TLA+, etc.)

It seems to me that I followed the rules, the task requested being to build a concrete program specified in the post.

Yes, contributers are also requested in passing at the beginning and at the very end. However, that was not the task request. That was just there, and if it breaks the rules I can entirely remove the request for contributers from the post.

The task was to code a short program, algorithm given. Most of the tasks that are approved I see are: write a script that does X, make art, design a website, make a bot that does Y. Isn't supplying the algorithm to be implemented more concrete, rather than less, when requesting for code?

Should I remove the request for contributers from the post, and resubmit the task?


Regarding the removed links: html markup connecting sections of the long post to each other. Would help with navigation. But it didn't work on Steemit. -- If you can suggest markup code for bookmarks and menus within a webpage that does work on Steemit, if any, I would be grateful.

The problem with your contribution is that there is no existing project on GitHub. On Utopian it is required to relate to an existing open source software project or to create a new one. Utopian is currently closely connected to GitHub, which is why we have to enforce such rules. This might change in the future but probably not anytime soon.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.09
TRX 0.32
JST 0.033
BTC 110734.92
ETH 3945.99
USDT 1.00
SBD 0.60