You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Distribution of SteemPower and Reward Pool share across Bid-Bots, dApps and Communities
Very nice work @crokkon!
So it looks like 25% - 30% of the reward pool is used by bid-bots. Any idea roughly how much would be added to this figure by minnowbooster and smartsteem?
The dApp figure will mainly have risen in June as MrDelegation made a couple of large delegations out to newer platforms (tasteem and steemhunt I think from memory).
Thank you @miniature-tiger! I'm still trying to figure out how to best capture the sell-your-vote share. Going through transfer histories with an estimated ROI is a complete mess. For MinnowBooster there's an API for the list of votes, so this should be reconstructable together with steemsql. For SmartSteem the API only provides data for the own votes. For others (booster?) I have no idea? I guess we won't get reliable numbers without explicit bot operator support.
So the wallet history of what smartsteem received can really not be used for this purpose?
Neither do you have any clue of it's like 1% or 12%? Or of course somewhere in between.
Getting reliable numbers is really complicated. Looking into the wallet history of a vote buyer I see how much he/she has spent. Eventually there's a partly refund because not all of the bid could be filled. There are lot's of invalid bids and refunds are partly coming from other accounts. It's not always the author account buying the votes and more and more memos are encrypted. I don't know the exact ROI, so if the bid was done shortly after the post was created, there may be several other non-bought/front-running/... votes on the post as well. Additionally, users can keep their balance on smartsteem and minnowbooster, so they can buy upvotes without an SBD/STEEM transfer on the blockchain. One thing that may give a clue on the total number is the amount of STEEM/SBD payed to delegators each day, but that's again a (partly user configurable) fraction of the bid, not necessarily of the vote value (unknown ROI...).
MinnowBooster has an API that shows the bought votes - that might give some insights, but that would be only one of several sell-your-vote services.
I didn't even try to get an estimate on this, so I really can't give any number here...
Alright now I get it.
Best option seems just to ask the owner of @smartmarket. I'm not really good with remembering those things, but I think a witness is the owner. I look it up and ask the question right now.
And @steempress-io too - they got 1 million I think.
In my analysis, I took the vested SP of anyone recieving payment from SS and MB and added that together as 'taken SP' - Like @crokkon says, it's a bit of a mess to slap an accurate figure on this!