Steem-UA suggestions - optional ranking info in comments/delegator pages, voting conflict prevention for Utopian posts

in utopian-io •  14 days ago

Repository

https://github.com/holgern/ua-python

Components

Proposal Description

Many people are using @steem-ua, which usually provides more than 10 times of self-voting of the delegated SP up to 7 posts per week depending on the delegated amount. (Of course, if the post ranking is too low, the voting amount can be lower than 10 * self-voting.) With @busy.pay's voting, @steem-ua's voting encourages people to write good posts. It's been running quite stably, but I'd like to make some suggestions based on my experience and many neighbor users.

Suggestion 1: Option to show rankings in comments

typical steem-ua comment for voted posts, showing UA score/rank, post rank every single time.

Everybody has a different taste, but they are quite many people who don't like steem-ua is showing rankings in every post. I agree that it's trying to encourage authors to make a better post next time, but especially for post ranking, we should admit that it's quite random depending on when the voting round is initiated. Personally I'm okay with showing rankings, since I don't care, but I saw many users who didn't like it. So it's much better if there is an option to choose whether to show the ranking information in the comment.

Suggestion 2: Option to show ranking in the delegators page

So does the delegators page: https://steem-ua.com/delegators/ Currently, it shows the UA score and rank:

Again, I saw many users (especially when their ranks are low) who don't want this. In particular, ranks are sensitive information in most Asian cultures :)

Of course, we're in the blockchain world! Maybe some people want transparency. But in that case, we can still query everyone's ranking like this:

my rank at the moment, still 4-figure, but hey it's not too bad as a normal user :(

So let's make an option so that users can choose!

Suggestion 3: Automatic delegation update

Not sure if this is a temporary issue, but it seems delegator page and thereby voting for them are not updated automatically. I saw people on Discord who said their delegations are still missing after a while. When steem-ua started, it seemed automatic, updated within a day if I remember correctly (or maybe they just ran the update script much more often? :). In any case the update can be more frequently without too much difficulty I guess. At least I should be updated everyday.

Suggestion 4: [Bug] Fix the graph!

https://steem-ua.com/stats

Around the end of last Sep, this graph went wrong. This graph shows the ratio of big (>=5k sp) and small (<5k) delegations. The sum should always be 100%. I actually reported this long time ago, but still haven't been fixed.

Suggestion 5: Voting conflict prevention for Utopian posts

While this suggestions is the most interesting to me, I left it the last since it's only applied to some users.

By the way, how is more than 10 times of self voting possible?
This is possible due to some donors who delegated much more than they receive. Utopian (delegated by @utopian.pay) is also such a case. Due to this collaboration, steem-ua votes Utopian posts. Once your Utopian posts are reviewed and accepted, @steem-ua magically visit and vote your post.

usual steem-ua's comment for Utopian posts

I truly believe that this is a very good collaboration. (Actually, this collaborative voting was stopped for a few days in the beginning of this month, so I was quite worried if the collaboration ended. But after I reported it to holger80, he fixed the problem quick :)

But one "problem" is steem-ua sometimes votes Utopian posts as a regular post if the author is a delegator to steem-ua as follows:

steem-ua voted Utopian posts as a regular post

I think this may happen if steem-ua has already started their regular voting process before being notified by Utopian system.

It happened to me several times and it's still happening to others too. This conflict may lead users to undelegate. While it isn't a serious problem, it's better to be avoided. Personally, I don't like that it's showing post ranking (as explained in suggestion 1) more than lower amount of voting itself.

Mockups / Examples

Suggestion 1 & 2: option to show rankings in comments/delegators page

For these two, I believe the mockups without rank themselves are pretty much obvious. More important thing is how to implement the options, and I think the following @steemitboard's approach would be enough and simple to implement.

@steemitboard offers users an option to choose to receive replies.

For instance,

  • NO RANK: no rank information at all
  • NO UA RANK: no UA rank & score
  • NO POST RANK: no post rank
  • without NO, it enables the information back.
Suggestion 3: Automatic delegation update

Just run the update script more often or use the block streaming.

Suggestion 5: voting conflict prevention for Utopian posts

While there are many ways to achieve this, I think one very simple solution would be this:

  • Don't vote Utopian (based on tag) post less than 3 (or a little bit longer) days old. Utopian tries their best to finish the review within 3 days, so I believe this is already enough.

Benefits

  • Freedom of choice
  • Free from stress due to score/rank
  • Reliability
  • More stable minimum voting for Utopian posting.
    As I explained in my recent proposal, Utopian bot sorting criteria improvement to prevent no voting, recently many Utopian postings can't be voted by @utopian-io due to limited VP. While the amount can never be comparable, still it'd be better if the conflict can be avoided.

Most importantly,

  • More delegation to @steem-ua
    The above benefits will definitely make more people delegate to steem-ua.

GitHub Account

https://github.com/economicstudio

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Hello @blockchainstudio!
Thank you for contributing.
I have been a fan of steem-ua since the day it launched. As you pointed out that it is working nicely but there is always some room for improvement and your suggested features make sense. I do hope that the PO takes note of the suggested features and implements them soon.
We are already looking for your next contribution.

Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.


Need help? Chat with us on Discord.

[utopian-moderator]

·

Hi @syedumair, thank you for your review. Yes, I actually already contacted them on discord and holger80 told me that he'll implement this (probably some of these). Thanks again!

·

Thank you for your review, @syedumair! Keep up the good work!

in Korean: 이건 사실 좀 써놓지가 된 세이브 원고(곽백수 작가님 된 기분ㅎㅎ)인데 매번 랭킹보여주는 steem-ua에 랭킹 정보는 선택해서 볼 수 있게 하자입니다. 솔직히 저자랭킹이야 정확한 기준이라도 있지 포스팅랭킹 역시 기준은 있어도 보팅 라운드 도는 시점에 따라서 랜덤할 수 밖에 없는데 꼬박꼬박 보여주면 기분이 안 좋을 수도 있죠. 저는 뭐야 이따위 랜덤한 랭킹은 하고ㅎㅎ 그러려니하지만 랭킹 때문에 신경쓰인다는 분들도 많이 봐서요.

그리고 유토피안 글 쓰시는 분들은 아시는 숨겨진 유토피안의 혜택이 있는데, 유토피안이 임대를 많이 해준대신 유토피안 글을 보팅해주는 기능이 있습니다. 그런데 이게 본인도 임대를 한경우 충돌이 생기는 경우가 있는데 그 부분도 고쳤으면 좋겠다는 내용입니다.

·

우아~~랭킹이 자주 바껴서 궁금했어요 ~ ^^

·
·

증인이 보팅을 해주면... 순위를 높게 받을 수 있긴 합니다..
제가열심히 일해야 합니다 ㅠ

짱짱맨 호출에 응답하였습니다.

3.1 운동 100주년을 기념하여 북이오는 인터넷에 돌아다니는 많은 문헌의 오류를 수정, 정성스럽게 다국어 버전의 디지털 문서로 출간하였습니다.

3·1 독립선언서 바로가기

널리 공유되기를 희망하며, 참여에 감사를 드립니다.

Congratulations! Your post has been selected as a daily Steemit truffle! It is listed on rank 6 of all contributions awarded today. You can find the TOP DAILY TRUFFLE PICKS HERE.

I upvoted your contribution because to my mind your post is at least 8 SBD worth and should receive 183 votes. It's now up to the lovely Steemit community to make this come true.

I am TrufflePig, an Artificial Intelligence Bot that helps minnows and content curators using Machine Learning. If you are curious how I select content, you can find an explanation here!

Have a nice day and sincerely yours,
trufflepig
TrufflePig

·

thanks but again you overestimated the num of votes too much :) you should also use previous stat of the account.

Hi @blockchainstudio!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your post is eligible for our upvote, thanks to our collaboration with @utopian-io!
Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server

Hey, @blockchainstudio!

Thanks for contributing on Utopian.
We’re already looking forward to your next contribution!

Get higher incentives and support Utopian.io!
Simply set @utopian.pay as a 5% (or higher) payout beneficiary on your contribution post (via SteemPlus or Steeditor).

Want to chat? Join us on Discord https://discord.gg/h52nFrV.

Vote for Utopian Witness!