I can't put my finger on what it was, but there was just something about Heroes that I couldn't take to.

Yeah I've seen True Blood, I suprisingly enjoyed it actually. Watched the first two seasons in one night, didn't think I'd get into it. I did try Grimm, but again there was something about it that I couldn't get into. My personal favourite supernatural show is well, Supernatural. I've been watching it for years, it's now in its 13th season I think which is just insane, but it's got a really good setup. Similar to the X-Files, there's the overarching story and then there's "monster of the week" episodes and so on.

If you do end up trying Lost let me know what you think, I'm curious to hear what you make of it.