You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: Confusing information from Steemworld and FrontEnds //
As I said, the weight in the active_votes array for your votes is being returned as 0 from the nodes. Without weight there are no curation rewards. Did you receive any rewards for one of those votes? If not, it's a bug in steemd or your vote has been broadcast multiple times, which I think could lead to no curation rewards too. Did you use an autovoter?
Since the HF, the exact vote amount can no longer be predicted exactly, because it depends on the payout amount of the post you are voting. I added a 'Sim. Payout' button on SteemWorld, so that we can see how much our vote is worth for a given payout. That feature is still being tested and the result may not be 100% accurate, but it already shows roughly how it works.
Oh... I just realized this comment covers the case that a vote was rebroadcasted leading to removing curation. I believe this is what happened, and I confirmed one of the cases for this.
As you can see i got curation 2 times out of 7 in the screenshot. A week ago i got 0/10.
Im using autovoter on most stuff but it seems the problem, in 90% of the time is tied into @vikisecrets posts.
Is there any way i can find out how to remedy this problem?
Hmm. So what is the 0.07$ vote value at 100% showing exactly? How does that compare with Steempeak and its vote slider?
Those are the predicted (coming) rewards, but it would be interesting to see, if you really received a
Curation Rewardoperation after payout (in Account Operations). I'm not sure, if the reason could be that not all nodes are running the fixed version 0.22.1 yet. I will wait till all nodes run the current version and report the issue on GitHub, if it's not fixed then.It shows that as long as the simulated payout is set to
0, your 100% vote on a post that got no other votes yet (comment for example) is worth ~ $0.07. But keep in mind that (in reality) you always vote the same amount ofrsharesand your vote's value will go up when other voters vote the same post.Wanted to add this so you have more data to work with. On 09/04 and again on 09/05 I voted on posts by @theouterlight. It was right after the 5 minute mark and the amount of curation was very small both times. The posts grew to curation of 30.45 and 41.60 respectively, yet shows 0 pending curation rewards for me. Yesterday I voted in at 6 minutes and that post is showing curation. All other posts I vote on that falls right after that 5 minute bar shows rewards, but I'm still not ruling out a possible glitch in the blockchain timer for some accounts. Hoping though it is some sort of communication glitch from the blockchain to your program though as they should have given me my largest curation rewards of the month, lol.
edited to add that the weight for both votes was 100% as shown as well on SteemWorld.
Thanks for your input! I think I can tell you why you don't get curation rewards (directly) for some posts on 3speak:
They seem to be experimenting with the curation logic. The setting
allow_curation_rewardsis disabled for those posts, so that all rewards go to the author, which is the beneficiary @likwid.I think that the voters will receive the curation rewards as liquid STEEM or so...
I know this sounds confusing, but there is a field
percentageand aweightfor each vote. When a developer talks about the weight, in most cases he means the calculated weight/effect of the vote... ^^I double-checked this: in this case, the curation rewards don't go to the author, they go to to the pool, much like if everyone voted at 0 minutes and took the full penalty.
But yes they also don't show in any interface as such.
Tagging @practicalthought as FYI.
Thanks for your input! I guess 3speak is working on kind of an own curation logic, but I'm not sure how exactly that will work. I heard something about going back to 25/75. Maybe they will transfer 25% of the benef. rewards back to the voters?
Returning those shares to the pool sounds good, but I'm pretty sure that their authors will loose many voters, if they won't get curation rewards anymore.
Thank you. Hopefully they will add a feature that gives one the knowledge they are forfeiting rewards if voting. Until they do I will need to assume all 3speak posts are forfeiting and unless the post was one of the greatest I have encountered will refrain from participating.
Thank you. I was unaware it was possible to disable curation rewards in that way (without it showing rewards declined). Hopefully they will add a feature so we can know, or they might face a situation where curators bypass the 3speak tags.
Just checked the account operations. I got curation 1 time out of 13 votes to Vikisecrets in last 7 days.
There seems to be an issue here.
@gtg any chance you could take a look at this. Would be greatly appreciated.