No one asked for your critique, many here don't post things so that others can critique them, they post so that those that enjoy their work can, and those that don't can politely move along. As for your "truth" I've been a professional photographer for over five years and I personally enjoy this image for various reasons. I'm not positive but I'd hazard a guess that @marinauzelac isn't looking to you to teach them how to get better as well. So maybe instead of trying to "teach" someone how to get better at something you obviously have no clue about (photography) why don't you go read articles that you enjoy and comment on those @pirate?