You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: An Idea for Password Protected and Censorship Resistant Posts/Message Passing

in #steemit7 years ago

It is not unreasonable to have closed communities. On a decentralized system like steem, it would require cryptography, and encryption, to make it work.

My ideal network would allow closed communities with members therein voting full weight and receiving rewards proportional to those weight, if it were a reward system.

My ideal directly contradicts the current steem model of "everyone in everyone else's business", but this aspect of steem is what has driven me and others largely away. I have divested about 80% of my holdings and am contemplating divesting the rest.

One way to change my mind would be to have cryptographically closed communites, and less nosiness, trolling, and harassment, but I'm not holding my breath.

Finally, the FUD about people doing "illegal" things with cryptography is shameful, although I know you don't mean it as FUD.

The ability to communicate freely is enshrined in the charters of many societies, and an online society should be no different. A more important worry is what horrors a government will inflict on its people. I welcome any technology that impedes governmental oppression. For those thinking that governments will not commit atrocities, you need to turn off Dancing with the Stars and start paying attention to world events.

Sort:  

None of what you describe is precluded by the blockchain. It could all be done with an enhanced UI and could even draw from the same reward pool. And after the next hard fork when linear rewards are introduced, there is less reason for anyone to care how anyone else decides to allocate their share of rewards, which fits quite naturally into not even being able to see what is being rewarded (by someone else).

What weaknesses do you see with Steem's current very open model?

There is nothing wrong with a very open platform. However, openness is not mutually exclusive with the potential for closed communities, which many people, including myself, would prefer for most of our communication.

Steem could have both.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.12
JST 0.029
BTC 61440.52
ETH 3447.43
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.52