You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: To Upvote or Not on Comments, That is the Question
I like your perspective on the matter. I too find myself wondering at times what the best allotment for my votes would be within my limits of voting before power degradation. I'd have to agree as well that good comments deserve recognition. I often find myself upvoting comments on my posts that are insightful or provide true feedback/input that pertains to the post.
At times though, I find myself also upvoting because I find a comment funny or intriguing, not necessarily pertaining to the topic. As to whether you should or shouldn't upvote comments/replies to your works; I believe that is pretty much at the discretion of the author and what they find valuable (or not).
Great post and keep up the good work!
Author discretion rules the day. I like that. I have consciously made my decision and criteria. I just wonder how many other authors do the same. I have seen posts with great comments, but no upvotes. I just can't help thinking that sends the wrong message.
I agree, at times it's necessary to (after upvoting) provide an explanation as to what about the post made you decide to upvote/promote it. This, I feel, would also help the authors to know better what to post about or how to go about wording it/etc. It's an all-around win/win when people give positive feedback in addition to upvoting. I don't feel that it's always necessary to upvote to appreciate a comment, sometimes just replying to that comment with positive feedback is enough. I know for me it is, I could care less about whether it's an upvote or a comment to show appreciation, the only real difference is the monetary aspect. But when you're like me, the intellectual gratification tends to be enough and sometimes even more valuable. It's comforting to relate to people and be appreciated and sometimes words can hit home a lot harder than a simple vote that says "Yea, I like that.", but nothing more really. Thanks for the reply! It's nice to see other people's opinions and to share in the wealth of having multiple perspectives on any given situation. Part of the reason I love steemit, so many different points-of-view and perspectives to attempt to put yourself in and perceive differently. :)
I truly like the feedback and 2-way conversation. If I am choosing to blog about a topic, I want peoples opinions (especially if the are different from my own), thoughts, ideas, and passion. So yes, I fully agree with you. Feedback to the authors is golden.
Exactly! An open mind can only lead to catching new/productive ideas. Even if you open your mind and find out that it's something you completely disagree with.. you've now learned where you stand on the matter. Thanks for the intellectual conversation, I feel that steemit should have some sort of messaging/chat system as well, for those who wish to make new connections, but not drag the conversations out over comments. I feel that the potential for mental growth is also incredible here on steemit, simply for the fact that everyone has something different and unique to bring to the table and it may open other people's eyes in ways they never considered. :)
@kainmarx try https://steemit.chat